Recoil corrections with finite nuclear size in hydrogenic systems

Krzysztof Pachucki, Vojtěch Patkóš, Vladimir A. Yerokhin · 2025

Read Recoil corrections with finite nuclear size in hydrogenic systems by Krzysztof Pachucki, Vojtěch Patkóš, Vladimir A. Yerokhin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09455.txt.

Introduction

Krzysztof Pachucki and co-authors clean up the formulas physicists use to predict the energy levels of atoms. Two small effects shift those levels: the nucleus recoils as the electron orbits, and the nucleus takes up space rather than being a point. The paper derives the corrections at two levels of precision without assuming the nucleus is tiny, so the math serves ordinary and muonic atoms alike.

The stakes are practical: measuring a muonic atom's light is one of the best ways to weigh a nucleus's size, and errors in theory become errors in size. The team shows that a popular shortcut, the Breit approximation, inserts a fake term that grows in direct proportion to the nuclear radius. Proper quantum electrodynamics cancels that term, leaving a much smaller contribution that grows with the square of the radius. The authors warn that size estimates built on the shortcut inherit the error.

Catalog record

CREATORKrzysztof Pachucki, Vojtěch Patkóš, Vladimir A. Yerokhin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09455

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Recoil corrections with finite nuclear size in hydrogenic systems Krzysztof Pachucki, Vojtěch Patkóš, Vladimir A. Yerokhin Abstract Formulas for the combined nuclear-recoil and finite-nuclear-size effects of order ( Z ​ α ) 5 (Z\alpha)^{5} and ( Z ​ α ) 6 (Z\alpha)^{6} are derived without any expansion in the nuclear-charge radius r C r_{C} , making them applicable to both electronic and muonic atoms. The obtained results are particularly relevant for high-precision determinations of root-mean-square charge radii from muonic atom spectroscopy. We demonstrate that calculations of the atomic isotope shift based on the widely used Breit approximation give rise to an unphysical nuclear-size contribution that is linear in the nuclear-charge radius r C r_{C} at order ( Z ​ α ) 5 (Z\alpha)^{5} . This spurious term vanishes in a full QED treatment, leaving the correct contribution quadratic in r C r_{C} . For electronic atoms, this quadratic term is significantly smaller than the spurious linear contribution. I Introduction Finite nuclear size modifies the Coulomb potential in the vicinity of the nucleus. Although this effect occurs in the range of just a few femtometers, much smaller than the typical localization region of the wave function of about 10^{5} fm, the resulting shift of energy levels is significant. For example, the 1S - 2S transition in hydrogen is affected by as much as 1 MHz, which should be compared to the experimental accuracy of 10 Hz [ 1 , 2 ] and the theoretical uncertainty of 1 kHz [ 3 ] . It is thus possible to determine the proton charge radius (and, simultaneously, the Rydberg constant) from observed hydrogen transition energies. A comparison of the extracted radius with an independent determination from muonic hydrogen [ 4 ] resulted in a long-standing discrepancy, known as the proton radius puzzle. This discrepancy has now been largely resolved in favor of the muonic-hydrogen radius [ 3 ] . For atoms with more than one electron, absolute charge radius determinations are not yet feasible, as theoretical precision has not reached the required level. However, it is possible to determine differences of nuclear-charge radii between two isotopes of the same element. Of particular interest is the comparison of the nuclear radius differences obtained from electronic and muonic atoms. This comparison is highly sensitive to nuclear-polarizability effects and provides an opportunity to test fundamental interaction theories. This field has been developing rapidly in recent years. For instance, the difference in squared charge radii between the deuteron and proton, r_{C}^{2}(d)-r_{C}^{2}(p) , was found to be in perfect agreement between H-D and \mu H- \mu D determinations, after a meticulous evaluation of deuteron polarizability effects [ 5 ] . Another example is the squared charge radius difference of helium isotopes, r_{C}^{2}(^{3} He )-r_{C}^{2}(^{4} He), which was initially reported to disagree between electronic and muonic isotope shift measurements [ 6 , 7 ] . However, it was recently shown that inclusion of the second-order hyperfine-interaction correction [ 8 , 9 ] resolves this discrepancy. For heavier elements, multiple isotope shift measurements have been conducted for electronic Li, Be, and heavier atoms, while the corresponding muonic-atom measurements are currently being pursued by Ohayon et al. [ 10 ] . The influence of the finite nuclear size (fns) on atomic energy levels has been extensively studied, both within the expansion over the parameter Z\alpha [ 11 ] (where Z is the nuclear charge number and \alpha is the fine-structure constant) and to all orders in Z\alpha [ 12 ] . In particularly, Friar [ 11 ] derived the fns corrections up to order (Z\,\alpha)^{6} for the infinitely heavy nucleus. His derivation and final formulas has recently been verified and simplified in Ref. [ 13 ] . Theoretical treatment of the fns effect in the presence of a finite-mass nucleus, however, has proven to be significantly more challenging. Addressing this effect, Friar [ 11 ] obtained a contribution linear in the nuclear radius r_{C} at (Z\,\alpha)^{5}\,m^{3}/M order, where m is the electron mass and M is the nuclear mass. If correct, this would represent a substantial contribution, as its magnitude is comparable to that of the leading fns recoil effect, which is of order (Z\alpha)^{4}(m^{4}/M)r^{2}_{C} . A similar approach to the fns recoil effect was later employed by Borie and Rinker in their seminal work on muonic atoms [ 14 ] and subsequently by Borie in Ref. [ 15 ] . It was, however, shown by Shabaev [ 16 ] that the linear in r_{C} fns recoil term disappears in the rigorous QED treatment. In this work we derive complete formulas for the recoil fns effects at orders (Z\,\alpha)^{5} and (Z\,\alpha)^{6} . The derivation is carried out without any expansion in the nuclear radius r_{C} . While an expansion in mr_{C} is justified and commonly used for electronic atoms, it becomes entirely inadequate for muonic atoms, where m_{\mu}r_{C}\approx 1 (with m_{\mu} the muon mass). Moreover, we explicitly demonstrate that the term linear in r_{C} at order (Z\,\alpha)^{5} is an artifact of the approximate treatment of nuclear recoil. In this approach, the nonrelativistic nuclear kinetic energy and Breit (magnetic) interaction are added to the Dirac equation, a method that is inconsistent with QED. Using the heavy-particle formulation of QED [ 17 , 18 ] , we apply the exact formula for nuclear-recoil effects with finite nuclear size and demonstrate limitations of the approximate treatment. II Finite nuclear size The finite nuclear size leads to a shift of binding energies of atomic systems, E_{\rm fns} . For a light atom we can perform the expansion of E_{\rm fns} in the parameter Z\alpha , where Z is the nuclear charge number and \alpha=e^{2}/(4\,\pi) is the fine-structure constant, \displaystyle E_{\rm fns}=E^{(4)}_{\rm fns}+E^{(5)}_{\rm fns}+E^{(6)}_{\rm fns}+\cdots\,, (1) where the superscript denotes the order in Z\alpha . Each term of this expansion can be further expanded in the mass ratio m/M , where m is the mass of the orbiting particle (electron or muon) and M is the nuclear mass, \displaystyle E^{(n)}_{\rm fns}=E^{(n,0)}_{\rm fns}+E^{(n,1)}_{\rm fns}+\cdots\,, (2) where the second superscript denotes the order in the mass ratio m/M . The leading-order nuclear contribution is of order (Z\alpha)^{4} and given by a simple formula E^{(4)}_{\rm fns}=\frac{2\,\pi}{3}\,Z\alpha\,\phi^{2}(0)\,r_{C}^{2}\,, (3) where \phi(0) is the nonrelativistic electron (muon) wave function at the position of the nucleus, r_{C} is the root-mean-square charge radius of the nucleus, \displaystyle r_{C}^{2}=\int d^{3}r\,r^{2}\,\rho(\vec{r})\,, (4) and \rho(\vec{r}) is the nuclear charge distribution. Equation ( 3 ) includes the exact dependence on the finite nuclear mass M through \displaystyle\phi^{2}(0)=\mu^{3}\,\frac{(Z\alpha)^{3}}{\pi n^{3}}\,, (5) where the reduced mass \mu=mM/(m+M) . The next-to-leading fns correction is of order (Z\alpha)^{5} . In the nonrecoil limit it was obtained by Friar [ 11 ] , with the result \displaystyle E^{(5,0)}_{\rm fns}=-\frac{\pi}{3}\,\phi^{2}(0)\,(Z\alpha)^{2}\,m\,r_{F}^{3}\,, (6) where \displaystyle r_{F}^{3}=\int d^{3}r_{1}\int d^{3}r_{2}\,\rho(r_{1})\,\rho(r_{2})\,|\vec{r}_{1}-\vec{r}_{2}|^{3}\,. (7) The finite nuclear mass (or, nuclear recoil) effects in Eq. ( 6 ) can be partially included in \phi^{2}(0) through the reduced mass \mu . However, there are further nuclear recoil corrections of order (Z\alpha)^{5} [ 17 ] , which will be addressed in Sec. V . III Nonrecoil correction of order \bm{(Z\,\alpha)^{6}} for \bm{nS} states In this section we recalculate the fns correction of order (Z\alpha)^{6} in the nonrecoil limit, E^{(6,0)} , for the dipole (exponential) parametrization of

Read the complete text