Language Agents as Digital Representatives in Collective Decision-Making

Daniel Jarrett Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Michael Henry Tessler Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Romuald Elie Google DeepMind, Miruna Pîslar Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Raphael Köster Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Christopher Summerfield Google DeepMind Michiel A. Bakker Google DeepMind [-0.75ex] Jan Balaguer Google · 2025

Read Language Agents as Digital Representatives in Collective Decision-Making by Daniel Jarrett Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Michael Henry Tessler Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Romuald Elie Google DeepMind, Miruna Pîslar Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Raphael Köster Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Christopher Summerfield Google DeepMind Michiel A. Bakker Google DeepMind [-0.75ex] Jan Balaguer Google (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09369.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Jarrett and co-authors ask whether language agents can stand in for people in group decisions in a 2025 paper. In group choice, a representative makes a person views present when the person is not in the room. Learned models of human behavior could fill that role, with uses in policy design and tests of decision rules.

The team first sets out the formal shape of group decision making and of digital representation, meaning a simulated agent that leads to the same outcomes. They then run a case study on finding consensus among diverse people. Fine tuned large language models proved able to act as digital representatives in that setting.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Jarrett Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Michael Henry Tessler Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Romuald Elie Google DeepMind, Miruna Pîslar Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Raphael Köster Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Christopher Summerfield Google DeepMind Michiel A. Bakker Google DeepMind [-0.75ex] Jan Balaguer Google
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09369

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Language Agents as Digital Representatives in Collective Decision-Making Daniel Jarrett Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Michael Henry Tessler Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Romuald Elie Google DeepMind, Miruna Pîslar Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Raphael Köster Google DeepMind[-0.75ex] Christopher Summerfield Google DeepMind Michiel A. Bakker Google DeepMind [-0.75ex] Jan Balaguer Google DeepMind [-0.75ex] Andrea Tacchetti Google DeepMind Abstract Consider the process of collective decision-making, in which a group of individuals interactively select a preferred outcome from among a universe of alternatives. In this context, “representation” is the activity of making an individual’s preferences present in the process via participation by a proxy agent—i.e. their “representative”. To this end, learned models of human behavior have the potential to fill this role, with practical implications for multi-agent scenario studies and mechanism design. In this work, we investigate the possibility of training language agents to behave in the capacity of representatives of human agents, appropriately expressing the preferences of those individuals whom they stand for. First, we formalize the setting of collective decision-making —as the episodic process of interaction between a group of agents and a decision mechanism. On this basis, we then formalize the problem of digital representation —as the simulation of an agent’s behavior to yield equivalent outcomes from the mechanism. Finally, we conduct an empirical case study in the setting of consensus-finding among diverse humans, and demonstrate the feasibility of fine-tuning large language models to act as digital representatives. 1 Introduction Collective decision-making is a hallmark of intelligent behavior [ 1 , 2 ] , and is ubiquitous in economic, social, and political spheres of society [ 3 , 4 ] . Consider any process in which a group of individuals interactively select a preferred outcome from a universe of alternatives: For instance, consider a diverse group of humans communicating in a mediated environment, seeking to arrive at a consensus opinion on a topic of debate [ 5 , 6 ] . In this context, “representation” is the activity of making an (otherwise absent) individual’s preferences present in the process through participation by a proxy agent—i.e. their “representative” [ 7 ] . To this end, learned models of human behavior have the potential to fill this role, with practical implications for scenario studies and mechanism design. For instance, it can facilitate personalized and detailed simulations of collective interactions, allowing iterative refinement of mechanisms before real-world deployment. The key question is: What makes a good representative ? Simulation for Representation In this work, we explore the possibility of training language agents to behave in the capacity of representatives of human agents, appropriately expressing the preferences of those individuals whom they stand for. On the one hand, this has natural connections to existing work in simulating human behavior, such as learning from demonstrations [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , generating synthetic data, [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] , and creating plausible simulacra of social agents [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . On the other hand, unlike such prior work, our objective in simulating human behavior is specifically for “representation”. This entails unique requirements: (a) grounding in the context of collective interaction , (b) attending to the granularity of individual fidelity , and (c) operating in the high-dimensional domain of language space . Specifically, in this work, we are exploring what representation means, how to measure representativity, and whether language agents can be trained to act as representatives on behalf of humans. Contributions We make three key contributions in this investigation. First, we formalize the setting of collective decision-making as the episodic process of interaction between a group of agents and a decision mechanism (Section 2 ). Building upon this, our second contribution is to characterize the problem of digital representation as the simulation of an agent’s behavior so as to yield equivalent outcomes when interacting with the mechanism (Section 3 ). Finally, we conduct an empirical case study in the setting of consensus-finding in natural language among diverse humans, and demonstrate the feasibility of fine-tuning large language models to act as such digital representatives (Section 4 ). 2 Collective Decision-Making Consider a general setting for collective decision-making, where interactions between a group of individuals are mediated by a decision mechanism , yielding a process that produces a final outcome. By way of preliminaries, we first formalize the notion of a social choice function , which is an abstract mapping from preferences to outcomes that is implemented by a mechanism: Definition 1 (restate=defsocial,name=Social Choice Function) Let N:=\{1,\dots,n\} denote a set of participants , who are engaged in the process of making a collective decision. Denote with \Omega the space of outcomes , from which the participants are required to make a final selection \omega\in\Omega . Denote with \theta_{i}\in\Theta_{i} the type characterizing each participant i\in N , which captures their preferences over different outcomes. Moreover, let \theta:=(\theta_{i})_{i\in N}\in\Theta:=\Theta_{1}\times\dots\times\Theta_{n} indicate the type profile of all participants. Then a social choice function h is a mapping from the space of type profiles into the space of outcomes, h:\Theta\rightarrow\Omega (1) In line with related fields, “participants” may also be referred to as “agents” and “players”, and an “outcome” may be synonymous with an “alternative” and a “collective decision”. \square We operate in the standard setting for discrete-time Markov decision processes. Let x\in\mathcal{X} denote the state variable: While we keep notation simple, x may play the role of “contexts” and “histories” that capture all observations prior to the current time step. Let u_{i}\in\mathcal{U}_{i} denote the action variable for i\in N , and let u:=(u_{i})_{i\in N}\in\mathcal{U}:=\mathcal{U}_{1}\times\dots\times\mathcal{U}_{n} indicate the action profile for all participants. In our setting, u will largely play the role of “utterances” in language space. Denote with T the finite length of each decision episode. The outcome of each episode is precisely the terminal state \omega:=x^{T} . Definition 2 (restate=defmechanism,name=Decision Mechanism) Each participant i\in N is associated with a behavior denoted with \pi_{i}\in\Pi_{i}\subseteq\Delta(\mathcal{U}_{i})^{\mathcal{X}} , and let \pi:=(\pi_{i})_{i\in N}\in\Pi:=\Pi_{1}\times\dots\times\Pi_{n} give the behavior profile for all participants. A decision mechanism \tau is a mapping from states and action profiles to next states, \tau\in\mathcal{T}\subseteq\Delta(\mathcal{X})^{\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{U}} (2) and an outcome function f maps behavior profiles and mechanisms into distributions over outcomes. In our Markov decision process setting, the outcome function is simply the result of “rolling out” an episode of the interactive process between \pi and \tau to arrive at (a distribution over) terminal states, f:\Pi\times\mathcal{T}\rightarrow\Delta(\Omega) (3) A “behavior” may synonymously be referred to as a “policy” or “strategy”, and a “mechanism” may be referred to as a “game” or “environment”. Our setting is in general non-stationary: We may use superscripts t\in\{1,\dots,T\} to indicate time steps, but omit them unless explicitly required. \square Finally, a mechanism \tau is said to implement a social choice function h when h(\theta)=f(\pi,\tau) for all \pi\in\Pi . Both \pi , \tau may depend on \theta , though not required. Often, mechanisms are designed with an optimization objective in mind. For instance, let each participant be associated with a payoff function , g_{i}:\Omega\times\Theta_{i}\rightarrow\mathbb{R} (4) such that g_{i}(\omega,\theta_{i}) gives the payoff that participant i\in N enjoys from the collective decision \omega . As before, for convenience, let g:=(g_{i})_{i\in N} and (with some abuse of notation) write g:\Omega\times\Theta\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{n} . Then a “utilitarian” social

Read the complete text