Let’s Talk Futures: A Literature Review of HCI’s Future-Orientation

Camilo Sanchez, Sui Wang, Kaisa Savolainen, Felix Anand Epp, Antti Salovaara · 2025

Read Let’s Talk Futures: A Literature Review of HCI’s Future-Orientation by Camilo Sanchez, Sui Wang, Kaisa Savolainen, Felix Anand Epp, Antti Salovaara (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09362.txt.

Introduction

Five researchers review how human-computer interaction writes about the future in a paper from 2025. The field is future-oriented by nature, since it designs new ways for people and technology to meet. Yet its visions often stay implicit, narrow, and sure of technology's path. The team examined the most cited papers in a major digital library. They sorted the future talk using a four-part framework drawn from futures studies.

Technology still drives most visions in the field. A growing share of work, though, questions techno-centered stories. Newer work explores uncertainty and human experience more openly. The authors name five chances for the field to contribute more to futures research. They also explain why the old habits persist.

Catalog record

CREATORCamilo Sanchez, Sui Wang, Kaisa Savolainen, Felix Anand Epp, Antti Salovaara
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE115 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09362

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Let’s Talk Futures: A Literature Review of HCI’s Future-Orientation Camilo Sanchez, Sui Wang, Kaisa Savolainen, Felix Anand Epp, Antti Salovaara Abstract . HCI is future-oriented by nature: it explores new human–technology interactions and applies the findings to promote and shape vital visions of society. Still, the visions of futures in HCI publications seem largely implicit, techno-deterministic, narrow, and lacking in roadmaps and attention to uncertainties. A literature review centered on this problem examined futuring and its forms in the ACM Digital Library’s most frequently cited HCI publications. This analysis entailed developing the four-category framework SPIN, informed by futures studies literature. The results confirm that, while technology indeed drives futuring in HCI, a growing body of HCI research is coming to challenge techno-centric visions. Emerging foci of HCI futuring demonstrate active exploration of uncertainty, a focus on human experience, and contestation of dominant narratives. The paper concludes with insight illuminating factors behind techno-centrism’s continued dominance of HCI discourse, as grounding for five opportunities for the field to expand its contribution to futures and anticipation research. Conference: CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 26-May 1, 2025; Yokohama, Japan CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI ’25), April 26-May 1, 2025, Yokohama, Japan DOI: 10.1145/3706598.3713759 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1394-1/25/04 CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models † † cc-license: by Introduction Human–computer interaction (HCI) is a future-oriented enterprise. Interactive prototypes, technical demonstrations and new design methods materialize future visions and shape our ideas of what futures can be Bell & Dourish, 2007c ; Kinsley, 2012c ; Salovaara et al., 2017c ; Lindley et al., 2017f . They do so by introducing imaginaries of advances wrought by technological development Bell & Dourish, 2007c ; Lindley et al., 2017f . However, because the HCI’s field primary concerns are technology development and implications, it risks overlooking other matters of importance, such as systemic implications and long-term consequences Nathan et al., 2008f ; Mankoff et al., 2013c ; Salovaara et al., 2017c . This leads us to ask whether the future-orientation so central to our discipline needs refining to support more meaningful research inquiry. For example, while scenario-building is commonly found in the HCI toolbox, nearly always wielded for envisioning future contexts of technology use Carroll, 2003c , detailed instructions for constructing the scenarios and on how HCI scholars should carry out their future-building Nathan et al., 2008f ; Pargman et al., 2017c are scarce within HCI, and could benefit from critical attention. The intricacies of how societies and perspectives get portrayed in such scenarios and the visions further illustrate this problem. Seemingly neutral narratives that incorporate certain visions may readily simplify the complex weave wherein interactive technologies exert influence over day-to-day life Bell & Dourish, 2007c ; Nathan et al., 2008f ; Ashby et al., 2019c . If nothing else, visions for HCI often express interests of actors invested in the technologies Bell & Dourish, 2007c ; Kinsley, 2012c ; Harrington & Dillahunt, 2021f and perpetuate socio-technological foci that may leave the agencies of more-than-human systems to the side Forlano, 2017c or neglect underprivileged and vulnerable stakeholders. Enhancing HCI’s future-savviness could safeguard against superficial engagement with futures and help us identify pressing questions, alongside rich opportunities Nathan et al., 2008f . Interest in futuring is growing in design-oriented HCI studies especially, as approaches such as design fiction Bleecker, 2009c ; Sterling, 2009f , critical design Dunne, 2006c ; Bardzell et al., 2012f , speculative design Dunne & Raby, 2013c ; Wong & Khovanskaya, 2018g , and more-than-human design Forlano, 2017c ; Giaccardi & Redström, 2020c ; Wakkary, 2021c ; Lu et al., 2024c ; Sanchez et al., 2025c attest, yet the level of exploration and application of futures knowledge remains uneven across our field. Some future-oriented studies are far more comprehensive than others. This paper contributes to the solid development of future-oriented research in HCI by examining the prevalence of short-sighted futuring in HCI. We conducted in-depth investigation informed by works that have called for stronger engagement between HCI and futures studies Mankoff et al., 2013c ; Pargman et al., 2017c ; Epp et al., 2022c ; Moesgen et al., 2023c , to construct a comprehensive picture of HCI’s status as a future-oriented research discipline. Specifically, we analyzed how the field takes futures into account and formulated ways to undertake more reflective futuring , where we use the latter term to describe a dual process: firstly, striving to understand current events deeply and secondly, using that understanding to inform future-oriented actions by exploring potential possibilities Bell, 1996c . To address these goals, we conducted a literature review assessing the extent to which HCI scholarship engages in futuring and carried out analysis directed at the following research questions: : RQ1: How has the HCI field’s future-orientation developed over the last 15 years? : RQ2: What traits characterize the field’s comprehensive futuring? We began by applying keywords and citation metrics to identify influential future-oriented papers from 11 high-profile journals and conferences in the ACM Digital Library (DL). Proceeding from this initial set of articles, we devised selection criteria that afforded manually inspecting the papers’ Introduction, Discussion, and Conclusion sections and, accordingly, grouping the future-oriented publications into those attending to futures only fleetingly and the ones whose futuring could be considered comprehensive. For the 205 articles that appeared comprehensive in their future-orientation, we performed full-text qualitative analysis. To support our analysis, we developed a futures studies-informed analysis framework encompassing four categories of futuring: epistemic stance, contingency perceptions, systemic integration, and narrative. Via the outputs from this process, we are able to describe the timelines followed by the future-orientation work behind the most influential HCI papers, over the years and by publication channel; describe how the most future-savvy papers have handled futuring; and articulate the opportunities available to HCI researchers today, so as to deepen futures inquiry in our field. 1. Related Research Ever since the discipline’s inception as a response to technological advancement Baecker, 2008c , HCI has been evolving, in waves Harrison et al., 2011c ; Bødker, 2006c ; Bødker, 2015c ; Frauenberger, 2019c , with its approach to futures adapting accordingly. Recent development suggests that the field is starting to take a more active and political stance to the futures addressed Ashby et al., 2019c . Increasingly often, HCI researchers step beyond user studies, into co-creation of futures with overlooked communities Harrington & Dillahunt, 2021f ; Freeman et al., 2022i and non-human actors Liu et al., 2018f ; Reddy et al., 2021c ; Heitlinger et al., 2021c . Below, we review the vast expanse of both conventional and emergent approaches to considering the future in HCI. Against this backdrop, we can paint a picture of dovetailing and divergences between HCI and futures studies, the branch of social science most directly tackling systematic explorations of alternative futures Bell, 1996c . 1.1. Conventional Approaches to Examining the Future in HCI To study futures, one needs to study possibilities. Scholars of HCI tackle this in various ways, among which are prototyping Lim et al., 2008c , scenario-building (either by the researchers themselves or with possible future users Carroll, 2003c ; Strömberg et al., 2004c ; Epp et al., 2022c ), observing (potentially opportunity-exposing) ways in which

Read the complete text