Glacier data assimilation on an Arctic glacier: Learning from large ensemble twin experiments
Wenxue CAO 1, Kristoffer AALSTAD 1, Louise S. SCHMIDT 1, Sebastian WESTERMANN 1, and Thomas V. SCHULER 1 · 2025
Read Glacier data assimilation on an Arctic glacier: Learning from large ensemble twin experiments by Wenxue CAO 1, Kristoffer AALSTAD 1, Louise S. SCHMIDT 1, Sebastian WESTERMANN 1, and Thomas V. SCHULER 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09314.txt.
Introduction
Wenxue Cao and four co-authors test data blending for an Arctic glacier in two thousand twenty-five. The glacier is Kongsvegen in Svalbard, and the aim is a better mass balance model. Fake but noisy data on snow brightness and depth stand in for real reads. They come from a full energy balance model of snow and ice.
Two ensemble methods blend the data into the model. Joint use of both data types cut error a lot in some zones. One method tracked brightness best, the other snow depth in low snow times. The work shows how such blends can sharpen glacier forecasts. That matters as Arctic ice shifts with the climate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wenxue CAO 1, Kristoffer AALSTAD 1, Louise S. SCHMIDT 1, Sebastian WESTERMANN 1, and Thomas V. SCHULER 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09314
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Glacier data assimilation on an Arctic glacier: Learning from large ensemble twin experiments Wenxue CAO 1, Kristoffer AALSTAD 1, Louise S. SCHMIDT 1, Sebastian WESTERMANN 1, and Thomas V. SCHULER 1 Abstract Glacier modeling is crucial for quantifying the evolution of cryospheric processes. At the same time, uncertainties hamper process understanding and predictive accuracy. Here, we suggest improving glacier mass balance simulations for the Kongsvegen glacier in Svalbard through the application of Bayesian data assimilation techniques in a set of large ensemble twin experiments. Noisy synthetic observations of albedo and snow depth, generated using the multilayer CryoGrid community model with a full energy balance, are assimilated using two ensemble-based data assimilation schemes: the particle batch smoother and the ensemble smoother. A comprehensive evaluation exercise demonstrates that the joint assimilation of albedo and snow depth improves the simulation skill by up to 86 % 86\% relative to the prior in specific glacier regions. The particle batch smoother excels in representing albedo dynamics, while the ensemble smoother is particularly effective for snow depth under low snowfall conditions. By combining the strengths of both observations, the joint assimilation achieves improved mass balance simulations across different glacier zones using either assimilation scheme. This work underscores the potential of ensemble-based data assimilation methods for refining glacier models by offering a robust framework to enhance predictive accuracy and reduce uncertainties in cryospheric simulations. Further advances in glacier data assimilation will be critical to better understanding the fate and role of Arctic glaciers in a changing climate. \jourvolume \jourissue \jourpubyear 2025 1 Introduction Glaciers are regarded as one of the key indicators of climate change. Over the past three decades, global glacier ice loss has contributed nearly 1 mm annually to sea level rise ( IPCC, 2022 ; Zemp and others, 2019 ) . At the same time, glaciers serve as a critical component of mountain water towers, helping to provide a more consistent and reliable water supply to downstream regions ( Immerzeel and others, 2019 ; Zhang and others, 2023 ) . Arctic glaciers are experiencing an accelerated mass loss ( Rounce and others, 2023 ; Van Pelt and others, 2019 ; Østby and others, 2017 ; Schmidt and others, 2023 ) because warming is amplified in the Arctic at two to four times the global average through various positive feedback mechanisms ( Rantanen and others, 2022 ; Lind and others, 2018 , e.g.) . Freshwater runoff from melting Arctic glaciers can have considerable impacts on ocean circulation and ocean-atmosphere interaction globally ( Pontes and Menviel, 2024 ) , as well as on regional marine biogeochemistry and productivity ( Ezat and others, 2024 ; Hopwood and others, 2020 ) . Thus, accurate knowledge of glacier mass balance is vital for understanding, detecting, and predicting the impacts of climate change. Glacier modeling is a primary method to determine the surface mass balance of glaciers, especially at sites with scarce long-term in situ observations, to reconstruct the past or project the future glacier evolution. Climate-driven glacier models include temperature-index models ( Hock, 2003 ; Marzeion and others, 2012 , e.g.) and energy balance models ( Hock and Holmgren, 2005 ; Westermann and others, 2023 , e.g.) . Temperature-index models approximate the melt rate based on air temperature ( Huss and Hock, 2015 ) , while physically-based energy balance models explicitly calculate the energy fluxes on the glacier surface and therefore provide a more detailed representation of the processes controlling the surface mass balance. The accuracy of glacier models is limited by uncertainties related to meteorological forcing ( Marzeion and others, 2020 ) , incomplete model physics ( Schmidt and others, 2023 ) , and parameter uncertainty ( Rounce and others, 2020 ) . Constraining each uncertainty source remains a significant challenge. Data assimilation methods can incorporate observations into modeling to improve accuracy and constrain simulation uncertainty ( Evensen and others, 2022 ) . In situ and remotely sensed observations can be individually or jointly assimilated into glacier models, leading to a reduction of the aforementioned uncertainties ( Choi and others, 2023 ; Gillet-Chaulet, 2020 ) . The assimilation of ground-based glaciological measurements into glacier mass balance models is gradually becoming a recognized approach for updating glacier model parameters or initial states ( Landmann and others, 2021 ; Sjursen and others, 2023 ) . However, despite this recognition, there are still relatively few studies that have implemented data assimilation in glacier mass balance modeling. Moreover, in situ measurements are available for only a minority of glaciers worldwide, which presents a significant challenge to transfer information to the unmeasured majority of glaciers. In addition to the direct assimilation of mass balance measurements, other quantities that can directly influence mass balance changes, such as remotely sensed albedo or snow depth, can also be ingested within a data assimilation framework. Albedo, defined as the reflectivity of the Earth’s surface to insolation, is a controlling variable in the surface energy balance of glaciers. It significantly impacts the shortwave radiation budget, thereby influencing the rate of melt and overall mass balance of glaciers ( Budyko, 1969 ; Ye and others, 2024 , e.g.) . In a pioneering study, a variational assimilation scheme was used to incorporate moderate resolution imaging spectroradiometer (MODIS) derived albedo into a snowpack model to reconstruct the spatial mass balance distribution for an Alpine glacier ( Dumont and others, 2012 ) . More recently, Sentinel-2 albedo estimates were assimilated into a glacio-hydrological model to improve the simulation of streamflow in two glacierized basins in the Canadian Rockies ( Bertoncini and others, 2024 ) . Snowfall is another major driver of the mass balance, as it is the primary source of glacier mass gain ( Hock, 2003 ; Pramanik and others, 2019 ) . Satellite-based snow depth retrievals, such as from the ICESat-2 laser altimeter, are a potentially globally available constraint on uncertainties in snowfall forcing which is being explored for seasonal snow data assimilation ( Mazzolini and others, 2024 ) . However, to the best of our knowledge, no experiment has explored the joint assimilation of remotely sensed albedo and snow depth into an energy balance model for glacier mass balance simulation. Moreover, the current state of the art in using Bayesian data assimilation to infer glacier surface mass balance has focused on static parameters in temperature index models using relatively costly Markov chain Monte Carlo methods ( Rounce and others, 2020 ; Sjursen and others, 2023 ) . This stands in contrast to other recent cryospheric work on glacier flow ( Brinkerhoff, 2022 ) , ice sheet ( Navari and others, 2021 ) , seasonal snow ( Alonso-González and others, 2022 ) , and permafrost ( Groenke and others, 2023 ) , which employ a greater diversity of modern Bayesian data assimilation (also known as inversion) schemes that allow for the use of more complex models. In this study, we performed twin experiments ( Arnold and Dey, 1986 ; Masutani and others, 2010 ) , also known as synthetic experiments or Observing System Simulation Experiments, to explore the benefits of assimilating albedo and snow depth on glacier mass balance simulations. This allowed us to test the data assimilation workflow in a series of targeted experiments while avoiding challenges of real