Non-parametric estimation of net survival under dependence between death causes
Oskar Laverny, Nathalie Grafféo, Roch Giorgi · 2025
Read Non-parametric estimation of net survival under dependence between death causes by Oskar Laverny, Nathalie Grafféo, Roch Giorgi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09273.txt.
Introduction
Oskar Laverny and co-authors loosen a hidden assumption in cancer survival math in a 2025 paper. Registry studies often lack the true cause of death. A classic estimator fills that gap by assuming causes act independently. That assumption can never be tested from the data itself.
Their broader estimator allows causes to lean on each other instead. Math for its spread and for group comparison tests comes with it. Simulations show how much the old assumption can skew results. A colon cancer registry case study puts the method to work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oskar Laverny, Nathalie Grafféo, Roch Giorgi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 92 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09273
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Non-parametric estimation of net survival under dependence between death causes Oskar Laverny, Nathalie Grafféo, Roch Giorgi Abstract Relative survival methodology deals with a competing risks survival model where the cause of death is unknown. This lack of information occurs regularly in population-based cancer studies. Non-parametric estimation of the net survival is possible through the Pohar Perme estimator. Derived similarly to Kaplan-Meier, it nevertheless relies on an untestable independence assumption. We propose here to relax this assumption and provide a generalized non-parametric estimator that works for other dependence structures, by leveraging the underlying stochastic processes and martingales. We formally derive asymptotics of this estimator, providing variance estimation and log-rank-type tests. Our approach provides a new perspective on the Pohar Perme estimator and the acceptability of the underlying independence assumption. We highlight the impact of this dependence structure assumption on simulation studies, and illustrate them through an application on registry data relative to colorectal cancer, before discussing potential extensions of our methodology. 1 Introduction Survival analysis deals with the modeling of time-to-event data, in particular under censorship [ 7 , 25 , 13 ] . The tools developed in this field are nowadays crucial in medical research, when investigating the impact of certain diagnosis and/or treatment of diseases on the patient’s overall survival. The main practical output is the statistical estimation of the death probability across time, possibly conditionally on covariates [ 31 , 29 ] . The theory also provides analytical tools (test statistics, asymptotics, etc.) to help practitioners analyze their datasets and identify important variables affecting the survival of their patients. Not technically restricted to human lifetime, survival analysis is a fundamental tool in many fields, from operational research and actuarial sciences to chemistry, biostatistics, and of course medical science. In population-based cancer studies, the reported cause of death – assumed binary, death from the studied cancer or from other causes – is usually unavailable or unreliable in the available datasets. The relative survival methodology [ 39 , 33 ] takes this particularity into account to evaluate the excess mortality – due to cancer – by assuming the general population mortality rates to be known, extracted from population life tables. The methodology allows epidemiologists to estimate an excess mortality with respect to cancer only. It also allows comparing the excess mortality of groups with different populational distributions (e.g., for spatial, temporal, or age disparities within and between cohorts) with proper statistical tools (asymptotic results, tests, etc.). Many national and international health agencies use it to report cancer statistics: the World Health Organization (WHO), the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), the FRANCIM network in France [ 9 , 14 ] , or international research programs EUROCARE [ 8 , 10 ] at European level or CONCORD [ 12 , 5 ] . They provide excess mortality estimates in their periodic reports and publications, do cross-country comparisons, trend analysis, and highlight potential areas of improvement for public health decision-making. By overcoming unreliable cause-of-death reportings, the methodology offers practical insights for equity, policy, and clinical cares. Let us now describe a relative survival problem formally, following e.g., [ 24 ] . Consider for this three random times E,P and C , respectively the times, from diagnosis, to death from the studied cause (E stands for ”Excess”), to death from other causes (P stands for ”Population”) and to censorship. Denote the time to death from any cause by O=E\wedge P (O stands for ”Overall”, while the symbol \wedge denotes the minimum). In relative survival setting, times E,P,O and the cause of death indicatrix \mathbbm{1}{\left\{E\leq P\right\}} are not observed: only the time to event T=O\wedge C and the censoring indicatrix \Delta=\mathbbm{1}{\left\{T\leq C\right\}} are observed, together with a vector of covariates \bm{X} . This separates relative survival settings from standard competing risks setting (where \mathbbm{1}{\left\{E\leq P\right\}} would also be observed). Note that we cannot distinguish a death due to the studied cancer from a death due to other causes. A first standard assumption in the net survival literature is that the distribution of P\;|\;\bm{X} (other causes of death, differentiated along the covariates) is known and can be derived from a reference population life table for each individual. This requires assuming that the prevalence of deaths due to the interesting cause (the excess mortality) in these life tables is sufficiently small to be negligeable. To simplify the exposition, assume that the rest of the model (that is the distributions of E , C , and the dependence structure between (E,P,C) ) does not depend on covariates \bm{X} . Relative survival’s goal is to estimate the distribution of E , and this distribution only: distributions of P , C , and the dependence structure of (E,P,C) are considered nuisances. Let (\bm{X}_{i},P_{i},E_{i},C_{i},O_{i}=P_{i}\wedge E_{i},T_{i}=O_{i}\wedge C_{i},\Delta_{i}=\mathbbm{1}{\left\{T_{i}\leq C_{i}\right\}})_{i\in 1,...,n} be an i.i.d n -sample of these random variables. Note that only (\bm{X}_{i},T_{i},\Delta_{i}) are observed: we thus let \left(\Omega,\mathcal{A},\left\{\mathcal{F}_{t},t\in\mathbb{R}_{+}\right\},\mathbb{P}\right) be the associated filtered probability space, where the filtration corresponds to our observations: \mathcal{F}_{t}=\sigma\left\{\bm{X}_{i},\left(T_{i},\Delta_{i}\right):T_{i}\leq t,\;\forall i\in 1,..,n\right\}. Survival analysis usually considers the different times, in particular T and C , to be independent. Relaxation of this hypothesis is an active field of research, see [ 15 , 17 , 19 , 18 , 16 ] for recent developments. Relative survival analysis is no outlier and commonly assumes that E,P and C are mutually independent. If the epidemiological interpretation makes this assumption hard to justify – the reasons causing death by the studied disease are related to the reasons causing other deaths, and even to the reasons causing loss of follow-up and therefore censorship – it is still very practical and simplifies drastically the estimation process. This assumption is therefore central in the literature, and this is the assumption we want to challenge here in the case of relative survival. We consider in this paper a relaxation of the independence assumption that only assumes independent censorship, of the form (E,P)\perp\!\!\!\perp C , while the dependence structure of (E,P) has to be taken into account. We express this dependence structure through the survival copula \mathcal{C} of the random vector (E,P) (see [ 36 ] or more recently [ 20 ] ). Our assumption writes: \left(\mathcal{H}_{\mathcal{C}}\right):\;S_{E\wedge P}(t)=\mathcal{C}\left(S_{E}(t),S_{P}(t)\right). (1) In particular, denoting \Pi(u_{1},u_{2})=u_{1}u_{2} the bivariate independence copula, the standard assumption writes simply \left(\mathcal{H}_{\Pi}\right) . This dissection of the dependence structure of (E,P,C) is crucial to match closely the nature of the observations: we have more statistical information on the joint distribution of (O,C) (recall O=E\wedge P ) than on the joint distribution of (E,P) . More precisely, the joint distribution of (O,C) is tied to the observations \left(T_{i},\Delta_{i}\right)_{i\in 1,...,n} exactly as in a classical censored survival problem. The supposed independence of the censorship is there only to simplify our expressions. On the other hand, the dependence structure of (E,P) is completely unattainable from our observations, and we must rely on an assumption \left(\mathcal{H}_{\mathcal{C}}\right) – but any copula will do. There are a few standard non-parametric estimators of the distribution of E under \left(\mathcal{H}_{\Pi}\right) in the literature, starting in the 1960s with the seminal work of Ederer [ 22 , 21 ] , Hakulinen [ 30 ] in the 1980s, and more recently Pohar Perme [ 39 ] in 2012. However, groundings and justifications of these estimators