Revisiting Euclidean Alignment for Transfer Learning in EEG-Based Brain-Computer Interfaces

Dongrui Wu · 2025

Read Revisiting Euclidean Alignment for Transfer Learning in EEG-Based Brain-Computer Interfaces by Dongrui Wu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09203.txt.

Introduction

Dongrui Wu, writing alone in a 2025 paper, revisits a method that lines up brain-wave data across people so brain-computer links need less setup per user. Brain waves differ a lot from person to person and day to day, so each new user usually faces a long tuning session. The method, Euclidean alignment, reshapes each person's data so groups overlap better before the decoder learns.

Wu explains the steps and their correct use, surveys where the method has been applied since 2020, and notes its extensions. Trials across thirteen task types had shown it works well and runs fast. New users of the method get a clear guide and pointers to open questions.

Catalog record

CREATORDongrui Wu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09203

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revisiting Euclidean Alignment for Transfer Learning in EEG-Based Brain-Computer Interfaces Dongrui Wu Abstract Due to large intra-subject and inter-subject variabilities of electroencephalogram (EEG) signals, EEG-based brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) usually need subject-specific calibration to tailor the decoding algorithm for each new subject, which is time-consuming and user-unfriendly, hindering their real-world applications. Transfer learning (TL) has been extensively used to expedite the calibration, by making use of EEG data from other subjects/sessions. An important consideration in TL for EEG-based BCIs is to reduce the data distribution discrepancies among different subjects/sessions, to avoid negative transfer. Euclidean alignment (EA) was proposed in 2020 to address this challenge. Numerous experiments from 13 different BCI paradigms demonstrated its effectiveness and efficiency. This paper revisits EA, explaining its procedure and correct usage, introducing its applications and extensions, and pointing out potential new research directions. It should be very helpful to BCI researchers, especially those who are working on EEG signal decoding. I Introduction Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) enable direct communication between the brain and external devices, which can be used in text input [ 1 ] , device control [ 2 ] , neuro-rehabilitation [ 3 ] , emotion recognition and regularization [ 4 ] , speech decoding [ 5 ] , restoring walking abilities [ 6 ] , etc. It is an important component of Brain Initiatives/Projects all over the world, particularly China [ 7 ] and the IEEE 1 1 1 https://brain.ieee.org/ . It was selected by Nature as one of seven technologies to watch in 2024 [ 8 ] , and again one of eight technology events to watch for in 2025 [ 9 ] , and also selected by IEEE Computer Society in 2025 as one of “ 22 breakthrough technologies set to redefine industries and shape the future of our world for decades to come ” [ 10 ] . According to the input signals, BCIs can be broadly classified into invasive ones and non-invasive ones. The former use surgery to implant electrodes into the brain, which are mainly used for patients. Non-invasive BCIs do not need surgery, and hence are more convenient and preferred by able-bodied users. Electroencephalogram (EEG) is the most frequently used input signal for non-invasive BCIs. EEG signals exhibit both intra-subject variability (non-stationarity), e.g., the same subject may have different EEG responses to the same stimulus in different sessions, and inter-subject variability (individual differences), i.e., different subjects may have significantly different EEG responses to the same stimulus. As a result, it is very challenging, if not impossible, to design an EEG-based non-invasive BCI system that is plug-and-play and fits all subjects. Usually, for each new subject, we need to collect some subject-specific calibration data to tailor the parameters of the decoding algorithm, which is time-consuming and user-unfriendly. Transfer learning (TL), which utilizes data/knowledge from other subjects (sessions) to facilitate the calibration for a new subject (session), has been extensively used in EEG-based BCIs to expedite the calibration [ 11 ] . An important consideration in TL is how to reduce the EEG data distribution discrepancies among different subjects (sessions) to avoid negative transfer [ 12 ] . Euclidean Alignment (EA) [ 13 ] was proposed in 2020 to address this challenge. It uses two simple, efficient and closed-form formulas to align the raw EEG trials from different subjects/sessions, greatly facilitating TL [ 14 ] . It also inspires some other EEG data alignment approaches, e.g., label alignment (LA) [ 15 ] . The EA paper has been cited 283 times in WoS and 405 times in Google Scholar (as of May 3, 2025), ranking 2/344 of all papers published in IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 2 2 2 https://webofscience.clarivate.cn/wos/alldb/summary/fd21b6a6-bdf1-4dcd-bae6-45d4041b195f-014738bfd9/times-cited-descending/1 (TMBE) in 2020, and 3/1872 of all papers published in IEEE TBME 3 3 3 https://webofscience.clarivate.cn/wos/alldb/summary/5e219ca8-1532-4637-a27d-6c70f9cbbca2-014738a148/times-cited-descending/1 between 2020 and 2025. It was one of the only two Highly Cited Papers of IEEE TBME in 2020. It was also the number one contributor to the 2022 impact factor (4.6) of IEEE TBME 4 4 4 https://jcr.clarivate.com/jcr-jp/journal-profile?journal=IEEE%20T%20BIO-MED%20ENG&year=2022&fromPage=%2Fjcr%2Fhome , among all 695 citable items published in 2020 and 2021. After five years of the publication of the EA paper, we now have deeper and more comprehensive understanding on how to properly use EA. Its applicable BCI paradigms have also been greatly expanded. This paper revisits the EA approach, explaining its procedure and correct usage, introducing its applications and extension, and pointing out potential new research directions. It should be very helpful to BCI researchers, especially those who are working on EEG signal decoding. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Section II introduces the procedure, correct usage, and applications of EA. Section III introduces an extension of EA, and some related EEG data alignment approaches. Section IV points out potential future research directions. Finally, Section V draws conclusions. II Euclidean Alignment (EA) This section introduces the EA approach [ 13 ] . It was inspired by Riemannian alignment [ 16 ] proposed in 2018 in IEEE TBME, which has been cited 272 times in WoS 5 5 5 https://webofscience.clarivate.cn/wos/alldb/summary/bbb3db2d-ab56-4291-8b2e-884a88511745-015ed46b9e/times-cited-descending/1 and 386 times in Google Scholar (as of may 3, 2025) and is one of the five Highly Cited Papers of IEEE TBME in 2018. Riemannian alignment has demonstrated promising performance in seven different BCI paradigms, as shown in Table I . TABLE I: Classification accuracy improved by Riemannian alignment in 7 different BCI paradigms. Note that different publications generally used different datasets. No. BCI Paradigm Classifier Accuracy (%) Reference w/o RA w/ RA Improvement 1 Motor Imagery MDM 38.84 63.76 24.92 Zanini et al., IEEE TBME 2018 [ 16 ] GM-4 41.58 64.18 22.60 MDM 50.14 66.21 16.07 He and Wu, IEEE SMC 2019 [ 17 ] MDM 64.81 66.82 2.01 Kumar et al., BCI 2019 [ 18 ] FgMDM 68.94 71.10 2.16 MDM 57.18 70.91 13.73 He and Wu, IEEE TBME 2020 [ 13 ] FBCSP-LDA 69.00 70.00 1.00 Xu et al., FHN 2020 [ 19 ] ShallowNet 71.00 72.00 1.00 EEGNet 70.00 72.00 2.00 EEGNet 69.70 71.40 1.70 Xu et al., JNE 2021 [ 20 ] EEGNetv4 67.40 70.30 2.90 MDM 57.02 72.45 15.43 Zhang et al., CMPB 2021 [ 21 ] MDM 57.18 70.91 13.73 Liang et al., IEEE IROS 2021 [ 22 ] MDM 56.00 70.00 14.00 Li et al., IEEE Access 2021 [ 23 ] MDM 57.18 70.91 13.73 Liang et al., ICIEA 2022 [ 24 ] EEGNet 53.45 57.93 4.48 Zoumpourlis and Patras, BCI 2022 [ 25 ] MDM 32.75 50.93 18.18 Xia et al., IEEE TBME 2022 [ 26 ] MDM 75.70 76.73 1.03 Pan et al., JNE 2023 [ 27 ] MDM 57.18 70.91 13.73 Liang et al., BSPC 2024 [ 28 ] BaseNet 57.38 63.64 6.26 Wimpff et al., BCI 2024 [ 29 ] EEGNet 72.18 76.42 4.24 Junqueira et al., JNE 2024 [ 30 ] DeepNet 69.27 76.92 7.65 ShallowNet 69.99 74.23 4.24 MDM 57.18 70.91 13.73 Chu et al., JNE 2024 [ 31 ] MDM 54.36 73.57 19.21 Jiang et al., ICASSP 2024 [ 32 ] LDA 52.07 70.64 18.57 CSP-MDM 61.78 87.93 26.15 CSP-LDA 65.71 83.64 17.93 JF-MDM 82.36 94.3 11.94 JF-LDA 80.21 94.36 14.15 2 Event Related Potential MDM 51.43 87.48 36.05 Zanini et al., IEEE TBME 2018

Read the complete text