On uniqueness of functions in the extended Selberg class with moving targets

Jun Wang, Qiongyan Wang, Xiao Yao · 2025

Read On uniqueness of functions in the extended Selberg class with moving targets by Jun Wang, Qiongyan Wang, Xiao Yao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09091.txt.

Introduction

Uniqueness theorems say exactly when two number-theory functions must be the same function. Jun Wang, Qiongyan Wang and Xiao Yao study functions in the extended Selberg class, a broad family that includes many prized examples. Instead of comparing the functions at fixed target values, they subtract a moving target: a flexible third function that itself varies. They ask when the two shifted functions having the same zeros forces them to be identical.

Under a stated limit on how fast the moving target may grow, they prove the two functions must indeed coincide, zeros counted with multiplicity. They also build examples showing the growth limit cannot simply be dropped. Their proof uses a fresh strategy borrowed from complex dynamics, based on special directions first used to study Julia sets. The authors suggest the method may serve other problems in value-distribution theory.

Catalog record

CREATORJun Wang, Qiongyan Wang, Xiao Yao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09091

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On uniqueness of functions in the extended Selberg class with moving targets Thanks: The first author was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No.11771090). The third author was supported by National Key R&D Program of China (2020YFA0713300) and NSFC of China(No.11901311). Jun Wang, Qiongyan Wang, Xiao Yao Abstract . We study the question of when two functions L 1 , L 2 L_{1},L_{2} in the extended Selberg class are identical in terms of the zeros of L i − h ⁡ ( i = 1 , 2 ) L_{i}-h(i=1,2) . Here, the meromorphic function h h is called moving target. With the assumption on the growth order of h h , we prove that L 1 ≡ L 2 L_{1}\equiv L_{2} if L 1 − h L_{1}-h and L 2 − h L_{2}-h have the same zeros counting multiplicities. Moreover, we also construct some examples to show that the assumption is necessary. Compared with the known methods in the literature of this area, we developed a new strategy which is based on the transcendental directions first proposed in the study of distribution of Julia set in complex dynamical system. This may be of independent interest. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 11M36, 30D20. 1. Introduction and main results This paper concerns the uniqueness problem related to moving targets for L -functions, which are Dirichlet series with the Riemann zeta function as the prototype. The Selberg class \mathcal{S} of L -functions consists of all Dirichlet series L(s)=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}{a(n)\over n^{s}} of a complex variable s with a(1)=1 , satisfying the following axioms (see [ 15 , 17 ] ): (i) Ramanujan hypothesis. a(n)\ll n^{\varepsilon} for any \varepsilon>0 . (ii) Analytic continuation. There exists a non-negative integer k such that (s-1)^{k}\emph{L}(s) is an entire function of finite order. (iii) Functional equation. \emph{L}(s) satisfies a functional equation of type \Lambda_{\emph{L}}(s)=\omega\overline{\Lambda_{\emph{L}}(1-\overline{s})}, where \Lambda_{\emph{L}}(s)=\emph{L}(s)Q^{s}\prod\limits_{j=1}^{K}\Gamma(\lambda_{j}s+\mu_{j}) with the constants Q,\lambda_{j},\mu_{j},\omega having Q>0,\lambda_{j}>0,\rm{Re}\,\mu_{j}\geq 0 and |\omega|=1 . (iv) Euler product. \emph{L}(s) has a product representation \emph{L}(s)=\prod\limits_{p}\emph{L}_{p}(s) , where the product is over all primes p , and \emph{L}_{p}(s)=\exp\left(\sum\limits_{j=1}^{\infty}\frac{b(p^{j})}{p^{js}}\right) with coefficients b(p^{j}) satisfying b(p^{j})\ll p^{j\theta} for some \theta<\frac{1}{2} . The extended Selberg class, denoted by \mathcal{S}^{\sharp} , is the set of all Dirichlet series \emph{L}(s) satisfying only the axioms (i)-(iii) (see [ 17 ] ). The degree d_{L} of L(s) is defined to be d_{L}=2\sum\limits_{j=1}^{K}\lambda_{j}, where K and \lambda_{j} are the numbers in the axiom (iii). The poles of \Gamma(\lambda_{j}s+\mu_{j}) occur at points s=-\frac{m+\mu_{j}}{\lambda_{j}}(m=0,1,2,\cdots) , which are also zeros of L(s) with the possible exception of s=0 . All these zeros have non-positive real part, and may have multiplicity greater than one. They are so-called “trivial” zeros of L(s) , see [ 4 ] . Throughout this paper, what we call an \emph{L} -function is a Dirichlet series which belongs to the extended Selberg class \mathcal{S}^{\sharp} . In particular, we do not assume the Euler product axiom. The results obtained in this paper particularly apply to the Selberg class \mathcal{S} . As an extension of the Riemann zeta function, \emph{L} -functions are the important objects in number theory, algebraic geometry etc. Value distribution and uniqueness of \emph{L} -functions have been studied extensively(see e.g. [ 1 , 4 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 17 ] ). Generally, Nevanlinna [ 6 ] proved that any non-constant meromorphic function can be uniquely determined by five values, which is called Five-value Theorem. It means that meormorphic functions f and g are identical when f,g take the same five values at the same points. While for \emph{L} -functions, the number of the values can be reduced to just one when counting multiplicities (see [ 17 , 7 ] ), which is stated in the following theorem. Theorem A . Two L-functions L_{1} and L_{2} are equal if L_{1}-a and L_{2}-a have the same zeros counting multiplicities for a complex number a(\not=1) . Steuding’s original statement has no restriction on a , see [ 17 , Theorem 7.11] . Lately, an example given by Hu and Li [ 7 ] , that is \emph{L}_{1}(s)=1+\frac{2}{4^{s}} and \emph{L}_{2}(s)=1+\frac{3}{9^{s}} , shows that a\not=1 cannot be dropped in Theorem A . When a is replaced by a rational function R(s) , Cardwell and Ye [ 1 ] proved the uniqueness conclusion under the assumption that \lim_{s\rightarrow\infty}R(s)\neq 1. Hu and Li strengthened their result by improving R(s) to a meromorphic function h(s) , see [ 7 , Theorem 3] . Theorem B . Let h be a meromorphic function of finite order such that (1) \lim_{\rm{Re}\,s\rightarrow+\infty}h(s)=a\not=1 ( a may be \infty ). Two L-functions L_{1} and L_{2} are equal if L_{1}-h and L_{2}-h have the same zeros counting multiplicities. Here, the term ‘order’ comes from value distribution theory. The standard notation and well-known theorems in the theory can be found in [ 5 , 6 , 21 ] . Let f be a meromorphic function. Define the proximity function m(r,f) and the integrated counting function of poles N(r,f) by m(r,f):=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{2\pi}\log^{+}|f(re^{i\theta})|d\theta, N(r,f):=\int_{0}^{r}\frac{n(t,f)-n(0,f)}{t}dt+n(0,f)\log r, where \log^{+}x=\max\{\log x,0\} for x>0 , and n(t,f) denotes the number of poles in |z|\leq t counting multiplicity. The sum T(r,f):=m(r,f)+N(r,f) is the Nevanlinna characteristic, then the order \rho(f) and the lower order \mu(f) are defined by \rho(f):=\limsup\limits_{r\to\infty}\frac{\log^{+}T(r,f)}{\log r},\ \ \ \mu(f):=\liminf\limits_{r\to\infty}\frac{\log^{+}T(r,f)}{\log r}. When h is non-constant, the condition (1) in Theorem B is necessary to be kept due to the example in which h can be an arbitrary L -function. Moreover, Hu and Li also constructed an example to show that Theorem B need not hold if h is of infinite order, see [ 7 ] . Here, h can be seen as a moving target. Usually, a moving target of a function is assumed to grow more slowly than the function, then it is called a small function. It is interesting that there is no such growth restriction for h in [ 7 ] , and h may grow more quickly than L_{1} and L_{2} . Moving targets have appeared in Nevanlinna’s version of the second main theorem (SMT) with three small functions. Chuang [ 3 ] obtained the general version of SMT with q(\geq 3) small functions for entire functions in 1964. The meromorphic case was solved by Osgood and Steinmetz independently [ 14 , 16 ] in the 1980’s. It has been open for quite a long time to establish the small function version of SMT truncated to the level 1. Without this tool, Nevanlinna’s strategy in proving Five-value Theorem can not work out the small function version of Five-value Theorem, which was solved by Li and Qiao [ 13 ] with a different approach. Finally, the SMT with small functions truncated to the level 1 was obtained in a remarkable paper of Yamanoi [ 20 ] . According to the Vojta’s dictionary, it seems that the moving target problem has some close and subtle relation with number theory. This is our initial motivation to study the uniqueness problem of L -functions with moving targets. The condition (1) and ‘finite order’ on h seem to be two different ways to describe h , and both of them can not be deleted completely in Theorem B . The question naturally arises as to whether these two requirements could be

Read the complete text