Balancing service provision by EV aggregator in different TSO-DSO coordination schemes
Hang Nguyen, Phuong Nguyen, Koen Kok · 2025
Read Balancing service provision by EV aggregator in different TSO-DSO coordination schemes by Hang Nguyen, Phuong Nguyen, Koen Kok (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-08782.txt.
Introduction
Hang Nguyen and co-authors study in 2025 how electric vehicle fleets can offer balancing services to the power grid under unlike coordination plans. Aggregators pool many small energy assets so their owners can join markets, and vehicle fleets are a growing source of flexible charging. Grid control sits split between national and local operators, whose moves can clash.
The authors compare a hybrid managed plan with a plan run mainly by the local operator. They model how aggregators react to price shifts and grid requests, and trace effects on a real part of the Dutch network, including steps to ease congestion. The hybrid plan gave the aggregator more benefit in their results. The work helps weigh who should direct flexible vehicles as their numbers grow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hang Nguyen, Phuong Nguyen, Koen Kok |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-08782
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Balancing service provision by EV aggregator in different TSO-DSO coordination schemes Thanks: The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support for this work from the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) funded DEMOSES project. Hang Nguyen, Phuong Nguyen, Koen Kok Abstract The increasing penetration of Distributed Energy Resources (DERs) in the distribution system has led to the emergence of a new market actor - the aggregator. Aggregator serves as a facilitator, enabling flexibility asset owners to access various markets. Among them, electric vehicle (EV) aggregators are gaining more attention due to their expanding use and potential to provide services across multiple markets, particularly in the reserve market. Currently, the transmission system operator (TSO) indirectly utilizes the resources under the management of the distribution system operators (DSO), which can negatively impact the distribution grid. Conversely, adjustments from DSOs can impact service provision to TSO due to the shortage of TSO usage information. These factors highlight the importance of evaluating the service provision from aggregators under different TSO-DSO coordination schemes. This paper focuses on the provision of flexibility from electric vehicles (EVs) aggregators for balancing service in the TSO-DSO hybrid-managed scheme and compares it to the DSO-managed coordination schemes. The behavior of aggregators reacting to price fluctuations and TSO requests under different coordination schemes and simulation scenarios is thoroughly assessed. Additionally, their impact on the grid is analyzed through the DSO’s congestion management process and validated using data from a real part of the Dutch distribution network. Results find that the hybrid-managed coordination scheme gives more benefit to the aggregator than the DSO-managed scheme, and the price paid for the BRP for the deviation has a large impact on the aggregator’s behavior. I Introduction Along with exploiting the potential of distributed energy resources (DERs), providing flexibility services with these sources attracts the attention of many organizations and research groups and has already been implemented in some European countries like France, Finland, Hungary, Estonia, Denmark, Belgium, Romania, etc [ 1 ] . The role of the aggregator - a market participant responsible for bundling flexibility from multiple small customers and producers into a portfolio and offering the combined capacity in other markets [ 2 ] - is becoming increasingly important. Many research studies focus on optimal biding strategies [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] , the provision of services to multiple markets (e.g., spot market, reserve, [ 3 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] congestion management services [ 7 ] or balancing portfolios [ 3 ] ) and the utilization of diverse appliances including electric vehicles (EVs), battery energy storage system (BESS), heat pumps, thermal-controlled load or their combinations. Recently, EV aggregators have been receiving increasing attention due to their expanding use, driven by environmental factors and government incentives. In 2023, the Netherlands was the sixth-largest EV market in Europe with over 300 thousand battery electric vehicles registered and leads in EV infrastructure [ 13 ] . Research on the Dutch situation shows the potential of EV aggregators to provide service in the reserve market [ 10 ] . EV fleets also demonstrate potential to provide flexibility to the internal balancing portfolio [ 3 ] , and congestion management [ 7 ] . The above studies show that EV aggregators have great prospective to provide flexibility services and bring benefits not only for aggregators but also for prosumers and system operators. Therefore, the EV aggregator is investigated in this research to consider its behavior on different market price fluctuations. Moreover, previous research has primarily focused on the aggregator business model when providing service to the transmission system operator (TSO), with limited attention given to the impact on the grid under the management of the distribution system operator (DSO). While an effective approach to leveraging DERs flexibility is enhancing TSO-DSO coordination [ 14 ] . In recent years, this coordination has become a prominent research trend, attracting significant interest from the academic community. Arthur et al [ 15 ] classify the existing coordination into three main schemes (1) TSO-managed; (2) DSO-managed; and (3) TSO-DSO Hybrid. In practice, the DER service provider contracts directly with the TSO in the first model. TSO is the single buyer and is prioritized in accessing DER flexibility and performs economic dispatch of DERs, while the DSO is restricted from accessing resources connected to their network. With less interaction, the implementation of this scheme is straightforward in a centralized manner. However, the distribution network constraints are not considered due to the lack of information. This scheme also poses great computational and modeling challenges to TSO, and a large amount of operational data needs to be shared. Conversely, the DSO-managed model grants the DSO a more prominent role and greater responsibility in optimizing the use of flexibility. The DSO is given priority to aggregate and employ the DER flexibility for managing congestion in their grids, then send the remaining flexibility to the central market. With increasing RES, it becomes more difficult to implement in a decentralized way via DSOs. Moreover, this scheme has the potential DSO conflicts of interest and transfers the computational challenges to DSO. Among these 3 schemes, the Hybrid TSO-DSO managed model appears to be the most balanced option as TSO and DSO manage their own market and allow TSO to use service with DSO’s consent. The aggregator sends their bid to TSO, then TSO asks DSO to validate the bid. This coordination aligns well with the prevailing circumstances in many countries and offers distinct advantages over others by empowering DSOs role and fostering greater social welfare. Therefore, the DSO-TSO hybrid-managed model is one of the schemes selected for investigation in this research. Considering the provision of DERs flexibility from the aggregator within the TSO-DSO coordination schemes offers a broader perspective by highlighting the risk of violating grid constraints when procuring flexibility for the TSO. Therefore, this research constructs a comprehensive model in which an EV aggregator provides multiple services under different TSO-DSO coordination schemes. To the best of the authors’s knowledge, this topic has not been widely explored in the literature. This paper shares some similarities with the 3 papers [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] in using flexibility from the distribution grid via the aggregator while accounting for the TSO-DSO coordination. However, unlike [ 16 ] , this paper models the details of the EV aggregator, improves the DSO model with linearized ACOPF and compares the flexibility provision in 2 different coordination schemes. In [ 17 ] , the authors show that 16% and nearly 52% of the operational cost is reduced for TSO and DSO, respectively. While the aggregator experienced a profit loss of approximately 54% under the DSO-managed model compared to the case without coordination, the study did not explore how the outcomes would differ if the TSO utilized flexibility from the aggregator in the balancing market. Compared with [ 18 ] , this paper models the EV aggregator that considers individual EV to ensure EV energy within the acceptable limit range while providing vehicle-to-grid service and considering the TSO-DSO hybrid-managed model that advances over the DSO-managed coordination scheme. The contributions of this work are as follows: • Modeling the interaction between