Mining Power Destruction Attacks in the Presence of Petty-Compliant Mining Pools

Roozbeh Sarenche, Svetla Nikova, Bart Preneel · 2025

Read Mining Power Destruction Attacks in the Presence of Petty-Compliant Mining Pools by Roozbeh Sarenche, Svetla Nikova, Bart Preneel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-07410.txt.

Introduction

Bitcoin's safety rests on costly puzzles, and the network resets the puzzle's hardness to match the power at hand. Roozbeh Sarenche, Svetla Nikova, and Bart Preneel study attacks that smash part of that power in 2025. Once power is gone, the reset drops the hardness, and the smash can pay for itself.

Three attack forms are weighed where the honest pools will bend a little for gain. Hoarding blocks, the oldest trick, bites harder when honest power is spread thin across many pools. A fresh bribe attack pays small pools to orphan rivals' blocks, and for small pools it can beat hoarding outright. A third form lures power away. The study maps when each attack wins, a chart defenders can use.

Catalog record

CREATORRoozbeh Sarenche, Svetla Nikova, Bart Preneel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE154 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-07410

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mining Power Destruction Attacks in the Presence of Petty-Compliant Mining Pools Roozbeh Sarenche, Svetla Nikova, Bart Preneel Abstract Bitcoin’s security relies on its Proof-of-Work consensus, where miners solve puzzles to propose blocks. The puzzle’s difficulty is set by the difficulty adjustment mechanism (DAM), based on the network’s available mining power. Attacks that destroy some portion of mining power can exploit the DAM to lower difficulty, making such attacks profitable. In this paper, we analyze three types of mining power destruction attacks in the presence of petty-compliant mining pools: selfish mining, bribery, and mining power distraction attacks. We analyze selfish mining while accounting for the distribution of mining power among pools, a factor often overlooked in the literature. Our findings indicate that selfish mining can be more destructive when the non-adversarial mining share is well distributed among pools. We also introduce a novel bribery attack, where the adversarial pool bribes petty-compliant pools to orphan others’ blocks. For small pools, we demonstrate that the bribery attack can dominate strategies like selfish mining or undercutting. Lastly, we present the mining distraction attack, where the adversarial pool incentivizes petty-compliant pools to abandon Bitcoin’s puzzle and mine for a simpler puzzle, thus wasting some part of their mining power. Similar to the previous attacks, this attack can lower the mining difficulty, but with the difference that it does not generate any evidence of mining power destruction, such as orphan blocks. 1 Introduction Bitcoin [ 33 ] was the starting point of the exciting journey into the blockchain and cryptocurrency era. Despite the introduction of many new cryptocurrencies, Bitcoin has maintained the highest market capitalization [ 1 ] and remains the most famous cryptocurrency. Any serious attack that threatens Bitcoin’s progress not only harms Bitcoin users but also impacts users of other cryptocurrencies and blockchain platforms. Although Bitcoin has operated smoothly since its emergence, the absence of a serious attack thus far does not guarantee that its security will not be compromised in the future. Since the introduction of Bitcoin, numerous research papers [ 17 , 16 , 5 ] have analyzed its security and explored potential attacks [ 14 , 38 , 6 , 28 ] that could target it. Identifying potential flaws in Bitcoin’s underlying mechanism and studying possible solutions can not only benefit Bitcoin’s progress but also serve as inspiration for new cryptocurrencies. Several attacks have been introduced in the literature aimed at destroying the efforts of other miners in producing valid blocks, which we refer to as mining power destruction attacks . Examples include selfish mining [ 14 , 38 ] , block withholding [ 37 , 13 ] , power adjusting withholding and bribery selfish mining [ 15 ] , block denial of service (BDoS) [ 31 ] , undercutting [ 11 ] , eclipse attack [ 34 ] , Pitchforks [ 23 ] , and script puzzle distraction attack [ 43 ] . While these attacks differ in their specific methods, they all share the common goal of destroying the mining power of other miners. The intuition behind the profitability of these attacks is the principle that mining rewards are distributed among the participating mining powers in proportion to their contributions to the chain extension. By destroying another miner’s share, the adversary increases its own relative contributions, which consequently boosts its revenue. No mining power destruction attacks can be more profitable than following the honest strategy during the initial difficulty epoch [ 19 , 41 ] . The adversary must wait for the subsequent difficulty adjustment mechanism to observe the impact of these attacks on its revenue. In contrast to attacks like double spending, where the adversary receives revenue immediately upon a successful attack, mining power destruction attacks must be continued for at least two weeks to become profitable. In this paper, we analyze mining power destruction attacks in Bitcoin within the context of petty-compliant mining pools, referred to as a semi-rational setting. The analysis of these attacks in a semi-rational setting differs in two important ways from their analysis in the presence of altruistic mining pools. First, in semi-rational settings, we cannot naively assume that mining pools will always follow honest behavior, especially when they are the victims of an attack. As petty-compliant pools, they may choose to deviate from the honest strategy to defend against mining power destruction attacks and protect their mining efforts. Second, an adversarial mining pool in such settings may carry out incentive manipulation attacks [ 25 ] , such as bribery, to convince non-victim petty-compliant mining pools to adopt its desired strategy, thereby increasing the success likelihood for its mining power destruction attacks. This potential for incentive manipulation allows adversarial mining pools even with a limited share of mining power to effectively attack the network. In this paper, we present a selfish mining analysis from a new perspective and introduce two novel mining power destruction attacks: the bribery and the mining power distraction attacks. Selfish mining attack (Section 3 ): Selfish mining, introduced by Eyal et al. [ 14 ] , is a well-studied attack in the context of Bitcoin. Numerous papers [ 14 , 38 , 19 , 50 , 8 , 40 ] have analyzed the impact of selfish mining on the adversarial block ratio and profitability. However, most of these studies assume that, apart from the adversarial mining nodes, all the remaining mining nodes in the network follow the honest fork choice rule, meaning they always mine on the longest chain or the earliest of the longest forks. Carlsten et al. [ 11 ] introduced the concept of petty-compliant mining nodes, highlighting that, in a fork race, these mining nodes choose the fork that offers the highest return. 1 1 1 [ 11 ] uses the concept of petty-compliant nodes in the undercutting attack analysis, overlooking them in the selfish mining analysis. To the best of our knowledge, the first analysis of selfish mining in the presence of petty-compliant mining nodes was conducted by the authors of [ 9 ] . The authors in [ 9 ] showed that in a semi-rational setting, the mining share threshold for a profitable deviation from the honest strategy is reduced. Despite considering petty-compliant mining nodes, the analysis in [ 9 ] is based on an implicit assumption that each mining node controls only an infinitesimal share of the total mining power, thereby overlooking the presence of any petty-compliant mining pools . A mining pool can be viewed as a group of infinitesimal mining nodes working together. Assuming no petty-compliant mining pools exist, the analysis can simply presume that, during a fork race, if the adversary places a bribe on top of the adversarial fork, almost all the network’s mining power will mine on top of the adversarial fork. This is because the mining nodes that do not adopt the adversarial fork are only those that own a block in the non-adversarial fork, with a total mining share that is infinitesimal. However, when considering the existence of mining pools, the presence of a bribe offered by the adversary does not guarantee that all the network’s mining power will mine on top of the adversarial fork. If a mining pool has already mined a block in

Read the complete text