Gravitational friction from d’Alembert’s principle

C. Ortiz, R.S. Khatiwada · 2025

Read Gravitational friction from d’Alembert’s principle by C. Ortiz, R.S. Khatiwada (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-07174.txt.

Introduction

Ortiz and Khatiwada derive a friction-like loss for objects moving under gravity in a thin spread-out medium, in a physics paper from 2025. Least action methods shaped modern physics, but they handle only a narrow class of constraints well. Gravity in a sparse medium with broader constraints calls for a different route.

The pair start from a classic principle of virtual work and compute the energy lost by a general particle, then spell out the case for light. They show the effect truly drains energy rather than just shifting it. A second derivation from stress in a continuous medium gives the same result, which strengthens the claim.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Ortiz, R.S. Khatiwada
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-07174

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational friction from d’Alembert’s principle C. Ortiz, R.S. Khatiwada Abstract The least action principle played a central role in the development of modern physics. A major drawback of the principle is that its applicability is limited to holonomic constraints. In the present work, we investigate the energy lost by particles as a result of the gravitational interaction in a homogeneous low-density medium subject to non-holonomic constraints. We perform the calculation for an arbitrary particle and outline the specific result for photons. The energy lost is calculated from first principles based on the principle of virtual work and the d’Alembert principle. Under the formalism mentioned above, the dissipative nature of the effect is established. Furthermore, we show that the results agree with an alternative derivation based on continuum mechanics and the Euler-Cauchy stress principle. Introduction The foundation of classical mechanics was established by Isaac Newton in 1687 [ 1 ] when he formulated the laws of motion. Newton described the dynamics of a system by considering the forces acting on it, which are given by the product of mass and acceleration, also known as the rate of change of momentum. However, the development of variational principles by Lagrange and Hamilton provided a more elegant and powerful framework to describe the dynamics of mechanical systems [ 2 , 3 ] . They reformulated Newton’s ideas in terms of a scalar quantity called the energy of the system. This approach offered several advantages, such as the ability to derive the equations of motion from a single mathematical framework and the insights gained by exploiting symmetries and conservation laws. Nevertheless, variational methods have limitations when applied to systems with nonholonomic constraints [ 4 ] . Holonomic constraints are relations that depend solely on the coordinates and, possibly, on time. Variational methods, which rely on the principle of least action, struggle to handle non-holonomic constraints effectively. To overcome this limitation, the d’Alembert principle emerges as a generalization of Newton’s mechanics. By introducing an inertial force that counterbalances the impressed forces, the d’Alembert principle allows us to achieve equilibrium in an accelerated system. This principle effectively transforms an accelerated system into a static one, allowing us to recast the system in a moving reference frame to a static one, making it compatible with relativistic effects [ 4 ] . One of the key advantages of the d’Alembert principle is its applicability to non-holonomic constraints. Non-holonomic constraints are relations that involve differentials of the coordinates, and possibly time. The d’Alembert principle provides a powerful tool for analyzing systems with such constraints, allowing for a more comprehensive treatment of mechanical systems. In this work, we focus on calculating the loss of energy experienced by a particle that is constrained to move at a constant velocity through an electrically neutral low-density medium. Thus, we only consider the classical gravitational force between particles and the medium.To analyze this situation, we utilize the formalism of the d’Alembert principle. First, we verify the equilibrium of the system employing the principle of virtual work. This principle provides a convenient approach to establish the conditions for equilibrium in systems subject to constraint forces. Once equilibrium is established, we proceed to calculate the work performed by the test particle as it moves through the medium. Furthermore, we explore an alternative method based on the Euler-Cauchy stress principle to investigate the same effect. This approach provides a complementary perspective and allows for a comparison of results obtained using a different formalism. By studying the loss of energy in this specific scenario with non-holonomic constraints, we aim to deepen our understanding of the d’Alembert principle and its application in analyzing the dynamics of constrained systems. The insights gained from this investigation contribute to the broader field of classical mechanics and provide valuable knowledge for various branches of physics and engineering. Results The principle of virtual work states that, for any given mechanical system in equilibrium, it is necessary and sufficient that the total virtual work of all the forces involved vanishes, \delta\omega\equiv\Sigma_{\nu=1}^{N}{\bf{F}_{\nu}^{e}\delta q_{\nu}}=0. (1) By considering a reaction force created by the motion, force of inertia, d’Alembert generalized the principle of virtual work to dynamical systems. Thus, any position of a system in motion may be regarded as an equilibrium position if we add the force of inertia, {\bf I_{\nu}}=-m_{\nu}{\bf a_{\nu}} , to the impressed force, \bf F_{\nu} , acting on particle of mass m_{\nu} , [ 5 ] \delta\omega=\Sigma_{\nu=1}^{N}({\bf{F}_{\nu}+{\bf I}_{\nu})\delta q_{\nu}}=0. (2) This means that the reaction forces determined by the d’Alembert principle in dynamical conditions are the same reaction forces of a static system [ 4 ] . For a free particle, the effective force, {\bf{F}_{\nu}^{e}}={\bf{F}_{\nu}+{\bf I}_{\nu}} , is zero and, if subject to a given constraint, equal to the negative the force of reaction, that is {\bf{F}_{\nu}^{e}}={\bf{F}_{\nu}+{\bf I}_{\nu}=-\bf R_{\nu}} . For ideal constraints, the virtual work due to the corresponding forces of reaction is zero \delta\omega=\Sigma_{\nu=1}^{N}{\bf{R}_{\nu}\delta q_{\nu}}=0. (3) It follows that for ideal constraints, reaction forces must be perpendicular to the allowed virtual displacements. Gravitational friction For a particle in a homogeneous and isotropic medium, the contributions of all forces due to the medium are cancelled out. For a static particle, the aforementioned condition can be sustained with the usual Newtonian mechanics, but this is not the case for a moving particle. Under this phenomenon, the total work done by the particle is not done at the expense of its kinetic energy, as by definition the particle is limited to move at a constant velocity, and thus the constraint equation can be regarded as g({\bf r,v},t)={\bf r-v}t=0 . The energy loss of the particle is due to the gravitational interaction with the medium. Since this involves non-holonomic constraints, we must rely on the principle of virtual work and the d’Alembert principle. In a dynamical system, the principle of virtual displacement requires that \sum F_{i}=0 be satisfied for any time, t , at a given position r_{i}=r_{0i} , where the velocity is set to zero, v_{i}=0 . The aforementioned implies that the formulation is valid even if the displacement involves physically infinite velocities, as the actual motion of the body is not taken into account [ 4 ] . To calculate the work done by the particle on the medium, we partition the system into three regions, one of them given by the generated plane where the particle lies orthogonal to its displacement, \partial{\Omega}=\{(r,x,\phi)\mid r=r_{0}\} ; another region above the plane, \Omega_{+}=\{(r,x,\phi)\mid r>r_{0}\} , and the other below it, \Omega_{\_}=\{(r,x,\phi)\mid r<r_{0}\} . Figure 1: Geometrical configuration of the system Due to the symmetry of the configuration, the force on a particle due to the matter content in the upper region, \Omega_{+} , is canceled out by the force due to the one in the lower region, \Omega_{-} , that is, F_{r^{+}}+F_{r^{-}}= 0 . Only the impressed force {\bf\bf F_{\nu}={F}}_{\partial{\Omega}} due the region in the plane \partial{\Omega} , orthogonal to the particle displacement, is left out. Given the constraint, g({\bf r,v},t)={\bf r-v}t=0 , the acceleration vanishes, thus, the force of inertia disappears, {\bf I}_{\nu}=0 . So for any virtual displacement we have \delta w=\Sigma{(\bf{F}}_{\partial\Omega})\cdot\delta{\bf r}=-\Sigma{\bf R}\cdot\delta{\bf r}. (4) The only forces involved are those due to the virtual displacement of the particle away from the original

Read the complete text