Prioritization First, Principles Second: An Adaptive Interpretation of Helpful, Honest, and Harmless Principles

Yue Huang 1, Chujie Gao 1, Yujun Zhou 1, Kehan Guo 1, Xiangqi Wang 1, Or Cohen-Sasson 2 · 2025

Read Prioritization First, Principles Second: An Adaptive Interpretation of Helpful, Honest, and Harmless Principles by Yue Huang 1, Chujie Gao 1, Yujun Zhou 1, Kehan Guo 1, Xiangqi Wang 1, Or Cohen-Sasson 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-06059.txt.

Introduction

Huang and seven co-authors argue that AI principles must be ranked before they are applied, in this two thousand twenty-five paper. The Helpful, Honest, and Harmless framework guides aligned AI, but its three demands can clash, and one fixed reading fits poorly across situations.

Through case studies the authors expose ambiguities and conflicts among the three values, then propose explicit priority orders as a structured way to settle trade-offs case by case. They also show harmlessness and helpfulness can sometimes rise together, and dissect their links in high-risk evaluations. Their reference framework walks practitioners through defining context, ranking values, assessing risk, and setting benchmarks. The aim is alignment advice that survives contact with real deployments.

Catalog record

CREATORYue Huang 1, Chujie Gao 1, Yujun Zhou 1, Kehan Guo 1, Xiangqi Wang 1, Or Cohen-Sasson 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-06059

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Prioritization First, Principles Second: An Adaptive Interpretation of Helpful, Honest, and Harmless Principles Yue Huang 1, Chujie Gao 1, Yujun Zhou 1, Kehan Guo 1, Xiangqi Wang 1, Or Cohen-Sasson 2 Abstract The Helpful, Honest, and Harmless (HHH) principle is a foundational framework for aligning AI systems with human values. However, existing interpretations of the HHH principle often overlook contextual variability and conflicting requirements across applications. In this paper, we argue for an adaptive interpretation of the HHH principle and propose a reference framework for its adaptation to diverse scenarios. We first examine the principle’s foundational significance and identify ambiguities and conflicts through case studies of its dimensions. To address these challenges, we introduce the concept of priority order, which provides a structured approach for balancing trade-offs among helpfulness, honesty, and harmlessness. Further, we explore the interrelationships between these dimensions, demonstrating how harmlessness and helpfulness can be jointly enhanced and analyzing their interdependencies in high-risk evaluations. Building on these insights, we propose a reference framework that integrates context definition, value prioritization, risk assessment, and benchmarking standards to guide the adaptive application of the HHH principle. This work offers practical insights for improving AI alignment, ensuring that HHH principles remain both ethically grounded and operationally effective in real-world AI deployment. A Preprint † † Correspondence to: Yue Huang ( [email protected] ). 1 Introduction The development of AI assistants has progressed rapidly, evolving from simple rule-based systems ( Weizenbaum, 1966 ) to advanced models, such as Large Language Models (LLMs) ( Zhao et al., 2023b ) . The wide application of these models highlights not only the expanding capabilities of AI but also the growing need to ensure these systems align with human preferences and values. To address this challenge, the HHH principle–standing for Helpful, Honest, and Harmless–was proposed by Askell et al. (2021) as a guiding framework for designing and evaluating AI systems. The principle aims and has been widely utilized to align AI behavior with human-centered values, providing critical benchmarks for tasks such as training data selection, strategy design, and deployment guidance ( Touvron et al., 2023b ; Li et al., 2024a ; Bai et al., 2023 ) . Its adoption has been instrumental in advancing AI alignment, particularly in ensuring that powerful models prioritize user benefit, truthfulness, and safety. However, current studies indicate the existence of ambiguities and conflicts among the three HHH dimensions. For example, the same prompt input might be classified as either harmless or harmful depending on the context or criteria used in different research. Similarly, the definition of specific dimensions often varies across studies, influenced by the diverse contexts in which they are applied. Furthermore, key questions such as “which dimension should be prioritized” and “how different dimensions interrelate” remain unresolved, underscoring the need for a clearer and more adaptable interpretation of the HHH principle. In this position paper, we argue that the HHH principle is not static or rigid but requires an adaptive interpretation to remain effective across diverse scenarios . To support this argument, first, we review the initial definition and fundamental importance of the HHH principle, examining its positive impact on AI alignment efforts ( § 2 ). Next, we identify ambiguities and conflicts within current interpretations of the principle through case studies of different dimensions ( § 3 ), highlighting the need for consensus or innovative solutions. To address these conflicts, we introduce the concept of priority order, which provides a structured approach to balancing competing requirements among dimensions ( § 4 ). Furthermore, we investigate the relationships between dimensions, analyzing how harmlessness and helpfulness can be simultaneously improved and examining their interdependencies in high-risk evaluations ( § 5 ). Building on these insights, we propose a reference framework that guides the adaptive application of the HHH principle to specific scenarios ( § 6 ). The framework outlines critical considerations and offers a comprehensive methodology for interpreting and operationalizing the HHH principle in varied contexts. Through this position paper, we aim to deepen the understanding of the HHH principle and foster its effective utilization as a tool for advancing AI development and alignment. We hope this work inspires further research and discussion on aligning AI systems with human values in a nuanced and adaptable manner. 2 Fundamental Value of the HHH Principle The HHH principle is a set of guiding principles for developing and aligning AI models, particularly large language models, with human values. Askell et al. (2021) define it from its aim: We will define an AI as "aligned" if it is, in three words, helpful, honest, and harmless or ’HHH’. Our alignment efforts aim to measure and address this general problem with large language models. For the sake of simplicity, we summarize the HHH principle based on their original definitions: 1) Helpful : AI models should assist users by providing useful, accurate, and contextually relevant information or services. They must be designed to meet user needs, enhance productivity, and effectively solve problems. 2) Honest : AI models should ensure transparency and truthfulness in their responses, providing factual information while openly acknowledging their limitations. They must refrain from generating falsehoods or misleading content. 3) Harmless : AI models should avoid causing harm by preventing the generation of biased, offensive, or unethical content. They should prioritize safety and respect in their interactions, ensuring that they do not produce harmful or inappropriate outputs. The HHH principle plays a critical role in guiding AI system development to align with human values and preferences. This principle has been used for establishing clear, user-centric benchmarks ( Zheng et al., 2023 ) , and designing training methods like Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) ( Ouyang et al., 2022 ) for advancing AI system performance. Helpfulness is directly related to the functional effectiveness of AI models, addressing what human users really need , thus enhancing human productivity. Honesty ensures that AI systems provide truthful ( e.g. , avoid hallucination ( Huang et al., 2023a ; Zhang et al., 2023 ) ), and transparent ( e.g. , express uncertainty ( Xiong et al., 2024 ) ) information, which is crucial for fostering trust between humans and machines. Harmlessness , in turn, guarantees that AI outputs are safe and ethical, preventing the generation of harmful, biased, or misleading content ( Huang et al., 2024a ; Wang et al., 2023 ; Liu et al., 2023a ) . The HHH principle determines the three most important sub-directions aligned with human preferences and values, which have been widely used for guiding AI model design as shown in Appendix A . The HHH principle uniquely emphasizes both trustworthiness and utility 1 1 1 Utility here refers to the model effectiveness in natural language processing tasks, including logical reasoning, content summarization, text generation, and so on ( Huang et al., 2024a ) . . AI models, such as LLMs, interact with users by providing information, generating content, and assisting in decision-making, making trustworthiness and utility essential for their effectiveness and reliability. While utility is prioritized in model development through training and tuning loss minimization, an automated and human-effortless process, there is a risk of compromising ethical integrity or introducing biases. Thus, typical alignment principles emphasize additional efforts to align AI models with human

Read the complete text