Probabilistic construction of some extremal p p -groups
Sean Eberhard, Luca Sabatini · 2025
Read Probabilistic construction of some extremal p p -groups by Sean Eberhard, Luca Sabatini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-05821.txt.
Introduction
Sean Eberhard and Luca Sabatini build extreme examples of finite p-groups, the groups whose size is a power of a prime. A group is called ab-maximal when every smaller subgroup has a strictly smaller share of abelian structure, and d-maximal when every smaller subgroup needs fewer generators. Earlier work set bounds on how large the abelian quotient of such a group can be, and left open whether the bounds can actually be met.
The authors answer with random constructions, producing infinitely many groups of class two that hit the bounds exactly for every prime. Their method rests on the degeneracy of random alternating bilinear maps on subspaces. In the ab-maximal case they also compute the odds: among groups of the given shape, the share that are ab-maximal sits close to one over e. The results close questions raised by two earlier teams.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sean Eberhard, Luca Sabatini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-05821
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probabilistic construction of some extremal p p -groups Thanks: The authors are supported by the Royal Society. Sean Eberhard, Luca Sabatini Abstract . A p p -group G G is called ab-maximal if | H : H ′ | < | G : G ′ | |H:H^{\prime}|<|G:G^{\prime}| for every proper subgroup H H of G G . Similarly, G G is called d d -maximal if d ( H ) < d ( G ) d(H)<d(G) for every proper subgroup H H of G G , where d ( H ) d(H) is the minimal number of generators of H H . If G G is ab-maximal and nonabelian then | G : G ′ | ≥ p 3 | G ′ | |G:G^{\prime}|\geq p^{3}|G^{\prime}| , while if G G is d d -maximal and p ≠ 2 p\neq 2 then | G : G ′ | ≥ p 2 | G ′ | |G:G^{\prime}|\geq p^{2}|G^{\prime}| . Answering questions of González-Sánchez–Klopsch and Lisi–Sabatini, for all p p we construct infinitely many ab-maximal p p -groups of class 2 2 with | G : G ′ | = p 3 | G ′ | |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{3}|G^{\prime}| , and infinitely many d d -maximal p p -groups of class 2 2 with | G : G ′ | = p 2 | G ′ | |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{2}|G^{\prime}| . The construction is probabilistic and based on the degeneracy of random alternating bilinear maps on subspaces. It is notable however that in the ab-maximal case we do not have a high-probability result but rather in a suitable sense the proportion of class- 2 2 groups with | G : G ′ | = p n |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{n} and | G ′ | = p n − 3 |G^{\prime}|=p^{n-3} that are ab-maximal is close to 1 / e 1/e (where e e is the base of the natural logarithm). 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 20D15, 15A63 1. Introduction If G is a finite group, we write d(G) for the minimal size of a generating set. We call G d -maximal if d(H)<d(G) for every proper subgroup H of G . This terminology was introduced by Kahn in [ 12 ] . Although d -maximal groups are not nilpotent in general [ 15 ] , in this paper we only consider d -maximal p -groups. In this case d(G)=\log_{p}|G:G^{\prime}G^{p}| , so the condition above can equivalently be written as |H:H^{\prime}H^{p}|<|G:G^{\prime}G^{p}| for all H<G . Laffey [ 13 ] proved that if G is a d -maximal p -group with p odd then G has class at most two, and G/G^{\prime} and G^{\prime} are both elementary abelian. A closely related concept is ab-maximality. We say that a finite group G is ab-maximal if |H:H^{\prime}|<|G:G^{\prime}| for every proper subgroup H of G . It was observed in [ 22 ] that ab-maximal groups are nilpotent of class at most two, and that every group of order n contains an ab-maximal subgroup of order at least n^{c/\log\log n} for some constant c>0 . This result is sharp even if we replace “ab-maximal” with “solvable”, and motivates the study of ab-maximal groups in greater detail. For a group of prime exponent, d -maximality and ab-maximality are equivalent. Trivial examples include elementary abelian groups and extraspecial groups, and it is natural to ask how large the derived subgroup can be in these groups in general. In the literature, this has been asked a couple of times [ 9 , 14 ] . For example, Question C in [ 14 ] asks whether every ab-maximal group G satisfies |G:G^{\prime}|\geq|G|^{\delta} for some fixed \delta>0.5 . We answer this question in the negative. Theorem 1.1 . For each prime p and n\geq 160 , there exists an ab-maximal p -group G (of exponent p if p\neq 2 ) such that |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{n} and |G^{\prime}|=p^{n-3} . In general if G is a nonabelian ab-maximal p -group then |G:G^{\prime}|\geq p^{3}|G^{\prime}| , so the multiplicative gap p^{3} is the smallest possible. The inequality n\geq 160 is just a convenience, and needed mainly if p=2 . If p\geq 13 it suffices to take n\geq 12 . In truth we expect n\geq 6 is sufficient for all p . To prove the above theorem we use standard ideas to reduce to a question in linear algebra, which we solve using probabilistic methods. This is not the first time that wild p -groups of class two have been constructed using a random alternating map. For example, using essentially this idea Ol’shanskii [ 19 ] showed the existence of groups of order p^{n} where all abelian subgroups have order at most p^{m} where m\sim\sqrt{8n} . See also [ 5 ] or [ 10 , Theorem 1.9] for applications of the same method. Notably, however, Theorem 1.1 is not obtained from a high-probability result, but rather we show roughly that a random candidate p -group (namely, a p -group G of Frattini class two and |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{3}|G^{\prime}| ) is ab-maximal with probability close to 1/e . In linear algebraic terms, the basic reason for this curious result is that a random alternating bilinear map B\colon\mathbb{F}_{p}^{n}\times\mathbb{F}_{p}^{n}\to\mathbb{F}_{p}^{n-3} has a number of totally isotropic 3 -dimensional subspaces that is asymptotically distributed as a Poisson distribution. Using the same method we construct d -maximal groups with large derived subgroup. This case is a bit easier and in fact we do obtain a high-probability result. In particular we give a complete positive answer to Question 4.5 in [ 9 ] . Theorem 1.2 . For each prime p and n\geq 2 , there exists a d -maximal p -group G such that |G:G^{\prime}|=p^{n} and |G^{\prime}|=p^{n-2} . 2. Extremal ab-maximal and d -maximal groups 2.1. ab-maximal groups Recall that a finite group G is called ab-maximal if |H:H^{\prime}|<|G:G^{\prime}| for all proper subgroups H of G . (Here G^{\prime}=[G,G] denotes the derived subgroup of G .) These groups are called \gamma_{2} -maximal in [ 14 ] , with reference to the more general notion of w -maximality introduced in [ 9 ] . In this subsection p is a prime and G is a nonabelian ab-maximal p -group. We do not require p to be odd. The following result of Thompson [ 23 ] is crucial. See [ 14 ] *Lemma 2.9 for a wide generalization. Theorem 2.1 (Thompson) . Let G be an ab-maximal p -group. Then G^{\prime}\leqslant Z(G) . It is trivial that |G:G^{\prime}|>|Z(G)| , and a slightly more involved argument provides the following sharp inequality. Lemma 2.2 . Let G be a nonabelian ab-maximal p -group. Then |G:G^{\prime}|\geq|Z(G)|p^{3} . Proof. Let A<G be a maximal abelian subgroup. Then C_{G}(A)=A and Z(G)<A . We claim that A/Z(G) is noncyclic. Otherwise, A=Z(G)\langle a\rangle for some a\in A , and A=C_{G}(A)=C_{G}(a) . Moreover |a^{G}|\leq|G^{\prime}| (since a^{G}\subseteq aG^{\prime} ), so |A|=|C_{G}(a)|=|G|/|a^{G}|\geq|G:G^{\prime}| , in contradiction with the ab-maximality of G . Therefore A/Z(G) is noncyclic and |A:Z(G)|\geq p^{2} . Thus by ab-maximality we have |G:G^{\prime}|>|A|\geq|Z(G)|p^{2} , which implies |G:G^{\prime}|\geq|Z(G)|p^{3} . ∎ Remark 2.3 . Lemma 2.2 conflicts with some statements in [ 9 ] *Section 4. In fact there is a mistake in [ 9 ] *Example 4.4. With reference to the notation in that example, the subalgebra \left\langle e_{1},e_{3},z_{1},z_{2}\right\rangle\leq L is abelian,