Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma

Ramin G. Daghigh 1, Guan-Ru Li 2, Wei-Liang Qian 3,2,4, Stefan J. Randow 5 · 2025

Read Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma by Ramin G. Daghigh 1, Guan-Ru Li 2, Wei-Liang Qian 3,2,4, Stefan J. Randow 5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-05354.txt.

Introduction

Ramin G Daghigh and co-authors trace how a faint bump near a black hole breeds a new family of ringing tones. Black hole quasinormal modes, the tones of a settling hole, prove shaky under small dents to the space around them. Those dents spawn echo modes, tones lined up near the real frequency axis.

As the bump slides away from the hole, the echo tones march toward the real axis together. Their spacing shrinks in step while the classic low tones spiral outward. At one point the echoes seize the lead role. In time records, that handover marks where clean damped ringing gives way to spaced echo pulses. Toy models with split barriers make the logic plain, and full analysis backs its reach. The team argues the pattern is universal for such dented holes.

Catalog record

CREATORRamin G. Daghigh 1, Guan-Ru Li 2, Wei-Liang Qian 3,2,4, Stefan J. Randow 5
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-05354

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma Ramin G. Daghigh 1, Guan-Ru Li 2, Wei-Liang Qian 3,2,4, Stefan J. Randow 5 Abstract It has been shown that black hole quasinormal modes are subject to spectral instability, typically triggered by metric perturbations. These perturbations, which can introduce a minor bump in the effective potential of the wave equation, give rise to a novel branch of asymptotic quasinormal modes, dubbed the echo modes , which lie mainly parallel to the real frequency axis. This study explores the evolution of the echo modes and their interplay with the outward spiral motion observed in low-lying quasinormal modes. As the bump in the effective potential moves away from the central black hole, the echo modes collectively shift toward the real axis, with the spacing between successive modes decreasing uniformly. This collective motion occurs simultaneously with the spiral of the low-lying modes until the echo modes eventually take over the fundamental quasinormal mode. In the time domain, such a takeover coincides with a transition point for the temporal waveform, where the distinction between the original black hole’s ringdown and the echoes becomes clear. This marks a transition in the characteristics of the waveform from primarily damped oscillations, dominated by the damping rate of the fundamental mode, to echo waves, characterized by periodic echo pulses. We argue that this phenomenon is universal by employing analytical and numerical analyses. We first elucidate our arguments using explicit but simplified toy models, where the effective potential barriers are disjoint. The derivations are then generalized to scenarios where perturbations are introduced on top of a black hole metric with a continuous effective potential. The observational implications, particularly the causality dilemma, are elaborated. We show that the echo modes can be extracted by applying the Fourier transform to ringdown waveforms, which can be important for gravitational wave observations. I Introduction The extreme gravity in the vicinity of black holes is one of the most captivating concepts in theoretical physics. The successful detection of gravitational waves from binary black hole mergers by the LIGO and Virgo collaborations [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] has inaugurated a new era for observational astrophysics. This achievement has further inspired many ongoing spaceborne projects, such as LISA [ 5 ] , TianQin [ 6 , 7 ] , and Taiji [ 8 ] , where direct observation of ringdown waveforms has been speculated to be plausible [ 9 ] . Quasinormal modes (QNMs) are the natural vibrational modes of black holes that determine the shape of the observed ringdown waveform. The significance and stability of QNMs, when discontinuities are introduced to the Regge-Wheeler potential, were initially investigated in [ 10 , 11 ] . These investigations were refined and expanded upon in [ 12 , 13 ] , followed immediately by multiple papers on the stability of the QNM spectrum such as [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . There is now strong evidence indicating that the asymptotic QNMs are mainly unstable against metric perturbations [ 14 ] , particularly when discontinuities are introduced to the effective potential of the wave equation in linearized gravity. Spectral instability is not exclusive to high overtones. The authors of [ 18 ] investigated the instability of the fundamental QNM by introducing a perturbative bump to the effective potential. As the bump moves away from the central black hole, the fundamental mode initially spirals away from its original value and later moves, accompanied by other modes in the spectrum, towards the real frequency axis on the complex plane. Recently, we showed that the universality of the initial spiral occurring for low-lying modes can be understood from an analytic perspective [ 19 ] . The proof was given for both truncated effective potentials and those constituted by disjoint potential barriers. Notably, a paradox is related to the QNM instability initially pointed out by Nollert [ 10 ] . On the one hand, as pointed out in [ 18 ] , the modification to the fundamental mode grows with the distance of the perturbative bump from the central black hole. Therefore, the effect is expected to be significant when the perturbative bump is located at a considerable distance from the black hole. On the other hand, an insignificant perturbation planted far away from the physical system of interest is not supposed to affect the observational outcome. Based on numerical calculations of the time-domain waveforms, the obtained ringdown profiles remain largely intact in the presence of small discontinuities [ 10 , 12 , 13 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . Although, intuitively, the instability of the QNM spectrum might imply a significant challenge to black hole spectroscopy [ 22 ] , the time-domain stability of the ringdown waveform seems to indicate otherwise. These results call for a detailed analysis of the feasibility of black hole spectroscopy in the context of spectral instability, which is still lacking in the literature. Interestingly, the above arguments are also in line with a causality dilemma. To elucidate the dilemma, let us explicitly consider the scenario where the bump is disjoint from the effective potential and is placed far away from the black hole horizon. For a pure black hole, the asymptotic QNMs lie parallel to the imaginary axis, while for the perturbed metric, the spectrum is significantly deformed and lines up along the real axis. In other words, the frequency domain Green’s function drastically differs between the two cases. Let us now assume an observer sits at a finite distance from the black hole and detects the emitted gravitational wave signals. Intuitively, one might expect the observer to extract the QNMs from the measured ringdown waveforms successfully and conclude that the asymptotic QNMs are primarily lined up along the real axis. However, this raises the question of how the measured waveform would ever carry information about the perturbative bump before the initial data can interact with the bump causally. Such a causality concern was discussed by Hui et al. [ 23 ] , where the authors tackle the problem elegantly by explicitly evaluating the time-domain waveform from the frequency-domain Green’s function. It was shown that the Green’s function of the perturbed metric can be written as a summation of a geometric series where the first term is identical to the Green’s function of the original black hole. At an earlier instant, specifically, before the initial data could pick up any information on the bump permitted by causality, the time-domain waveform will only receive non-vanishing contributions from the first term of Green’s function. Consequently, the resulting waveform is precisely the same as the original black hole. As time increases, the inverse Laplace transform picks up more and more terms in the series due to Jordan’s lemma, and the waveform becomes gradually deformed, reflecting more contributions from the metric perturbation. This provides a time-dependent picture of how the waveform derives contributions from the underlying Green’s function. Due to the discrete and sequential nature of the formalism, echoes naturally merge, with their period determined by the ratio of consecutive terms in the geometric series and the number of repetitions dictated by the effective inclusion of terms from the summation. The

Read the complete text