Model dependence in SMEFT
Alakabha Datta · 2025
Read Model dependence in SMEFT by Alakabha Datta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-04634.txt.
Introduction
Alakabha Datta and colleagues argue for a generic basis in effective field theory fits, in work from 2025. When a flavour puzzle appears, studies often add a few hand picked operators to explain it. Those studies are usually done in a down or up basis that ties weak and mass states together by assumption.
In such bases, the unseen rotation matrices drop out of the fit by design. A generic weak basis makes no alignment claim and keeps those matrix parts in view. Fits can then test the puzzle and extract the rotation matrices at once. In full form the path could rebuild the Yukawa matrices from data. The authors present this as a cleaner base for flavour work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alakabha Datta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-04634
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Model dependence in SMEFT Alakabha Datta Abstract UdeM-GPP-TH-25-303 a : Department of Physics and Astronomy, 108 Lewis Hall, University of Mississippi, Oxford, MS 38677, USA b : Département de Physique, de Génie Physique et d’Optique, Université Laval, Québec, QC, Canada G1V 0A6 c : Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545, USA d : Physique des Particules, Université de Montréal, 1375, ave Thérèse-Lavoie-Roux, Montréal, QC, Canada H2V 0B3 e : Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA (August 9, 2026) Abstract We point out that, although SMEFT is constructed to be model-independent, this holds only if complete sets of operators are used. SMEFT analyses that focus on subsets of operators are only semi-model-independent. They probe classes of ultraviolet models, opening a window to the underlying new physics. This model dependence originates from the need to choose a weak basis, usually taken to be the down or up basis. This naturally leads to the introduction of a third SMEFT weak basis, the generic basis, which interpolates between the above two bases. Due to its generality, we argue that the generic weak basis is the most natural for new physics. In the down and up weak bases, only a specific product of the two transformation matrices from the weak to the mass basis is observable – the CKM matrix. However, in the generic weak basis, both transformation matrices are measurable in principle, possibly up to some phases. Introduction — Although the standard model (SM) of particle physics has been enormously successful in describing the physics up to energy scales of O({\rm TeV}) , it is not complete: it cannot explain a number of observations (e.g., neutrino masses, dark matter, the baryon asymmetry of the universe, etc.). We therefore conclude that there must be physics beyond the SM. The LHC has searched for new particles for many years, but none have been observed. This implies that this new physics (NP), whatever it is, must be heavy (or extremely weakly coupled). One approach to analyzing such NP is to build models. Another approach uses model-independent effective field theories (EFTs). When the NP is integrated out, one obtains the Standard Model EFT, SMEFT [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . This EFT obeys the SM gauge symmetry, SU(3)_{C}\times SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y} and contains only SM particles. The leading-order (dimension-4) terms in SMEFT are those of the SM; higher-order terms are suppressed by powers of the NP scale \Lambda . As SMEFT is valid above the weak scale, its operators are defined in the weak basis. That is, they are written as functions of the fermions q_{i}^{0} (LH quark doublets), \ell_{i}^{0} (LH lepton doublets), u_{i}^{0} , d_{i}^{0} and e_{i}^{0} (all three RH singlets), i=1,2,3 . (Here, LH and RH denote left- and right-handed, and the superscript 0 indicates the weak basis.) The [U(3)]^{5} “symmetry” — It is often said that SMEFT possesses a [U(3)]^{5} “symmetry,” where one U(3) describes transformations of the three generations of q_{i}^{0} among themselves, and the other U(3) s act similarly on \ell_{i}^{0} , u_{i}^{0} , d_{i}^{0} and e_{i}^{0} [ 4 ] . However, this is not precise – the SMEFT Hamiltonian is not invariant under these transformations. Rather, each operator is transformed into a number of other operators, producing a new Hamiltonian with the same operators as the original one, but in which the new coefficients are linear combinations of the old coefficients. The new Hamiltonian is therefore equivalent to the first Hamiltonian. To see this explicitly, consider the semileptonic SMEFT operator, {\cal O}^{(1)}_{\ell q}=C^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prst}\,(\bar{\ell}_{p}^{0}\gamma_{\mu}\ell_{r}^{0})\,(\bar{q}_{s}^{0}\gamma^{\mu}q_{t}^{0})~. (1) To simplify things, we focus only on transformations of the quark fields. For a given (p,r) , the Hamiltonian is {\cal H}=\sum_{s,t}C^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prst}\,(\bar{\ell}_{p}^{0}\gamma_{\mu}\ell_{r}^{0})\,(\bar{q}_{s}^{0}\gamma^{\mu}q_{t}^{0})~. (2) This corresponds to nine operators ( s,t=1,2,3 ). We now perform a U(3) transformation on the LH quark fields: q^{\prime 0}=S_{L}^{\dagger}\,q^{0}~. (3) The Hamiltonian becomes \displaystyle{\cal H} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{s,t}C^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prst}\,(\bar{\ell}_{p}^{0}\gamma_{\mu}\ell_{r}^{0})\,(\bar{q}_{i}^{\prime 0}\,(S_{L}^{\dagger})_{is}\,\gamma^{\mu}\,(S_{L})_{tj}\,q_{j}^{\prime 0}) (4) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{i,j}{\tilde{C}}^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prij}\,(\bar{\ell}_{p}^{0}\gamma_{\mu}\ell_{r}^{0})\,(\bar{q}_{i}^{\prime 0}\gamma^{\mu}q_{j}^{\prime 0})~, where {\tilde{C}}^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prij}=(S_{L}^{\dagger})_{is}\,C^{(1)}_{\ell q}|_{prst}\,(S_{L})_{tj}~. (5) We see that, after the transformation, the new Hamiltonian has the same operators as before the transformation, but the new coefficients are linear combinations of the old coefficients. This is what is meant when people refer to a [U(3)]^{5} “symmetry.” We stress that this holds only if all nine SMEFT operators, i.e., all possible values of the weak (generation) indices (s,t) or (i,j) , are involved in the transformations. The down and up bases — As noted above, the dimension-4 operators in SMEFT are those of the SM. Higher-order, non-SM operators can provide new contributions to low-energy processes. Measurements of low-energy observables can therefore give information about the coefficients of these SMEFT operators. Below the weak scale, the physics is described by the Weak Effective Theory (WET), obtained by further integrating out the SM particles heavier than the b quark. The WET operators obey the SU(3)_{C}\times U(1)_{em} gauge symmetry. In order to get information about the SMEFT operators from WET observables, it is necessary to match SMEFT to WET. One complication is that, while the SMEFT operators are defined in the weak basis, the WET operators are in the mass basis. It is therefore necessary to transform between the two bases. For quarks, this is done as follows. The (leading-order) Yukawa terms in SMEFT are as in the SM: {\bar{q}}_{i}^{0}\lambda^{u}_{ij}i\sigma_{2}Hu_{j}^{0}+{\bar{q}}_{i}^{0}\lambda^{d}_{ij}Hd_{j}^{0}~. (6) When the Higgs gets a vacuum expectation value v , breaking the SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y} symmetry to U(1)_{em} , this leads to the up- and down-quark mass matrices M_{u}\equiv\lambda^{u}v and M_{d}\equiv\lambda^{d}v . Each of these is diagonalized by a bi-unitary transformation. For M_{u} , we have (S_{L}^{u})^{\dagger}M_{u}S_{R}^{u}=M_{u}^{diag} . This implies that U_{L}^{0}=S_{L}^{u}U_{L} and U_{R}^{0}=S_{R}^{u}U_{R} , where U\equiv(u,c,t)^{T} and the absence of superscripts indicates the mass basis. Similarly, (S_{L}^{d})^{\dagger}M_{d}S_{R}^{d}=M_{d}^{diag} , so that D_{L}^{0}=S_{L}^{d}D_{L} and D_{R}^{0}=S_{R}^{d}D_{R} , where D\equiv(d,s,b)^{T} . The Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix is V=(S_{L}^{u})^{\dagger}S_{L}^{d} . The diagonalization of both mass matrices can only be done once the electroweak symmetry is broken. Above the weak scale, where SMEFT is valid, we can use the U(3) transformations to diagonalize either \lambda^{d} or \lambda^{u} . We begin with a “generic” SMEFT Hamiltonian in which neither of the Yukawa coupling matrices is diagonal. We can use one U(3) symmetry to transform U_{R}^{0}=S_{R}^{u}U_{R} and another for D_{R}^{0}=S_{R}^{d}D_{R} . The RH quarks in the SMEFT Hamiltonian are now in the mass basis. At the SMEFT level, we can now use another U(3) to transform q^{0}\to S_{L}^{d}q^{0} . This implies that the down-quark Yukawa term {\bar{q}}_{i}^{0}\lambda^{d}_{ij}Hd_{j}^{0}\to{\bar{q}}_{i}^{0}(S_{L}^{d})^{\dagger}_{ik}\lambda_{kl}^{d}(S_{R}^{d})_{lj}Hd_{j}={\bar{q}}_{i}^{0}\lambda_{ij}^{d,diag}Hd_{j} . That is, the down-quark Yukawa coupling matrix has been diagonalized. The upshot is that the LH down-quark weak eigenstates are now the same as the mass eigenstates. In summary, we have q^{0}\to S_{L}^{d}q^{0}~,~\begin{pmatrix}u_{L}^{0}\\ d_{L}^{0}\end{pmatrix}\to\begin{pmatrix}V^{\dagger}\,u_{L}\\ d_{L}\end{pmatrix}~. (7) On the left we show the U(3) transformation applied to q^{0} and on the right we show how the weak eigenstates u^{0}_{L} and d^{0}_{L} are converted to the mass eigenstates u_{L} and d_{L} after symmetry breaking. Alternatively, we can transform q^{0}\to S_{L}^{u}q . This diagonalizes the up-quark Yukawa coupling matrix, so that the LH up-quark weak eigenstates are the same as the mass eigenstates. In this case, we have q^{0}\to S_{L}^{u}q^{0}~,~\begin{pmatrix}u_{L}^{0}\\ d_{L}^{0}\end{pmatrix}\to\begin{pmatrix}u_{L}\\ V\,d_{L}\end{pmatrix}~. (8) Equations ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) are sometimes referred to as the “down-quark convention” and