Effects of Curved Superconducting Magnets on Beam Stability in a Compact Ion Therapy Synchrotron

H.X.Q. Norman, R.B. Appleby, E. Benedetto, S. L. Sheehy · 2025

Read Effects of Curved Superconducting Magnets on Beam Stability in a Compact Ion Therapy Synchrotron by H.X.Q. Norman, R.B. Appleby, E. Benedetto, S. L. Sheehy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-04617.txt.

Introduction

Hannah Norman and co-authors study curved magnets for a compact cancer treatment machine, in a 2025 paper. The machine is a ring that steers carbon ions for therapy. Strong curved magnets made with superconductors could shrink the ring and cut the number of magnets needed, but their fields are hard to model well.

Standard models treat the field in a straight frame, which fails for a strongly curved magnet. The team built a three-dimensional field model of a curved magnet design and placed it in a model of a twenty-seven metre ring. They then tracked the beam over many turns to test long-term stability. Their method lets designers tune both magnet and ring together. The work aims to improve how future ion therapy sites perform in daily use.

Catalog record

CREATORH.X.Q. Norman, R.B. Appleby, E. Benedetto, S. L. Sheehy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-04617

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of Curved Superconducting Magnets on Beam Stability in a Compact Ion Therapy Synchrotron H.X.Q. Norman, R.B. Appleby, E. Benedetto, S. L. Sheehy Abstract Superconducting, curved magnets can reduce accelerator footprints by producing strong fields ( > > 3 T 3\text{\,}\mathrm{T} ) and reducing the total number of magnets through their capability for combined-function multipolar fields, making them an attractive choice for applications such as heavy ion therapy. There exists the problem that the effect of strongly curved harmonics and fringe fields on compact accelerator beam dynamics is not well represented: existing approaches use integrated cylindrical multipoles to describe and model the fields for beam dynamics studies, which are invalid in curved coordinate systems and assume individual errors cancel out over the full machine. In the modelling of these machines, the effect of strongly curved harmonics and fringe fields on compact accelerator beam dynamics needs to properly included. An alternative approach must be introduced for capturing off-axis fields in a strongly curved magnet, which may affect long-term beam stability in a compact accelerator. In this article, we investigate the impacts of deploying a curved canted-cosine-theta (CCT) superconducting magnet in a compact medical synchrotron for the first time. We develop a method to analyse and characterise the 3D curved fields of an electromagnetic model of a CCT developed for the main bending magnets of a 27 m 27\text{\,}\mathrm{m} circumference carbon ion therapy synchrotron, designed within the Heavy Ion Therapy Research Integration Plus European project, [ 1 ] and the CERN Next Ion Medical Machine Study (NIMMS). The fields are modelled in the compact synchrotron in MAD-X/PTC to study their effects on beam dynamics and long-term beam stability. The insights gained through the methods presented allow for the optimisation of both magnet and synchrotron designs, with the potential to impact the operational performance of future ion therapy facilities. Preprint: AAPM/123-QED Preprint: AAPM/123-QED Key Highlight Summary \bullet A tool is developed to sample field maps from strongly curved magnet models in OPERA 3D and recover multipoles and field gradients, validating the gradient calculation method. \bullet 3D curved field gradients of a CCT magnet are modelled in tracking simulations of a compact medical synchrotron model for the first time. \bullet Representing field gradients as discretely sampled fields along the magnet length instead of using integrated fields drastically reduced the dynamic aperture to 25 \% . \bullet Synchrotron can store \epsilon_{x,y} = 5\text{\,}\text{$\mu$}\mathrm{m} , 3.3\text{\,}\text{$\mu$}\mathrm{m} carbon ions for 2048 turns despite the addition the strongly curved field gradients, with the dynamic aperture recovered after tuning of higher order field gradients. I Introduction Designs of next generation particle therapy facilities are focused on improving patient accessibility and clinical outcomes, while reducing cost and ensuring sustainability [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Much attention is given to the reduction of machine physical footprints and power consumption, while delivering high intensity beams (1 \times 10^{10} particles per extraction cycle) to enable efficient treatment delivery [ 6 , 7 ] . These critical changes will improve access to particle therapy, which could benefit around 10% of radiotherapy patients [ 8 ] , but is far less available than conventional radiotherapy [ 9 ] . One factor behind the low number of facilities is the high running and building costs associated with the accelerator and supporting beam delivery technology, as their physical and technical demands are too high for retrofitting into existing facilities. The accelerator alone can typically have a large footprint (e.g. 75\text{\,}\mathrm{m} circumference for some medical synchrotrons [ 10 , 4 ] ) and high power consumption, due to dependency on normal conducting magnets. Reducing the footprint and power consumption requires magnets that exhibit both superconducting (SC) fields ( > 3\text{\,}\mathrm{T} ) and strong curvature (e.g. 1.89\text{\,}\mathrm{m} bending radius for 0.3\text{\,}\mathrm{m} aperture radius). Introducing curvature introduces complexity to the design and operation of the magnets and accelerator: the additional field components arising from curvature can negatively impact beam quality and stability during acceleration [ 11 ] , if they are not properly taken into account and compensated. For medical applications, acceptable limits on field quality must be determined by beam dynamics studies to comply with performance and safety measures during operation and treatment. This requires the exact field content of the magnet to be well-known for implementation in the accelerator. A caveat lies in the method of field characterisation: fields inside the magnet body are typically described in terms of 2D transverse cylindrical multipoles (Eq. III.1 in Section III ), which are integrated over the magnet length and represented as such in particle tracking codes [ 12 ] . A curved magnet necessitates the use of field gradients, as cylindrical multipoles are mathematically invalid in curved coordinate systems (see Ref. [ 13 ] ) and in the magnet ends, where the field is no longer translation-invariant. As such, integrated multipoles are insufficient to represent 3D curved magnetic fields and to gauge the full effect of curvature on the beam dynamics. As shown in Refs. [ 14 , 13 , 15 ] , 2D and 3D field derivatives are valid for describing the fields in straight and curved coordinate systems (see Section III ), and are already specified in beam optics codes [ 16 ] . These provide a straightforward translation from the magnetic field content to the accelerator. The aim of this study is to understand how both the curvature and the field composition of a curved, combined-function (CF), canted-cosine-theta (CCT) coil-based magnet can impact the beam dynamics and stability in a compact medical synchrotron. While the influence of curvature has been analysed for this magnet type on the field content and quality [ 17 ] and on the beam dynamics in a compact ring [ 18 ] , the two aspects have not been studied together in the context of a medical synchrotron. To explore these effects, we develop general tools (further detailed in Sections III , IV ) that perform field sampling and gradient calculations for implementation in the accelerator. We investigate the suitability of a strongly curved ( 90\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree} ), CCT coil-dominated magnet with CF quadrupole layers for the bending sections in a compact medical synchrotron: a project within the HITRI-plus initiative [ 1 ] , which has produced novel accelerator designs for a planned ion therapy facility in South Eastern Europe [ 19 ] . The strong fields ( 3.5\text{\,}\mathrm{T} ) and CF layers attributed to the unique geometry of the CCT (detailed in Section II ) enable reduction of the accelerator circumference to 27\text{\,}\mathrm{m} . Our method employs finite element software [ 20 ] to simulate a model of the magnet for field analysis. We develop tools ( [ 21 , 22 ] ) to analyse and characterise the fields using gradients for direct implement by beam optics codes [ 16 , 23 ] , using which we simulate particle tracking in the synchrotron lattice. From the results, we set limits on the higher order gradients that would otherwise drive strong resonances, leading to instabilities in the ring over more turns. Subsequently the suitability of the accelerator design for future facilities is determined. II Magnet Models A CCT configuration has been established as an attractive solution for a compact

Read the complete text