Derivation and thermodynamically consistent coupling of a Debye-Hückel type energy to a steric electrolyte model and application to the apparent molar volume and phase boundaries

Wolfgang Dreyer, Rüdiger Müller · 2025

Read Derivation and thermodynamically consistent coupling of a Debye-Hückel type energy to a steric electrolyte model and application to the apparent molar volume and phase boundaries by Wolfgang Dreyer, Rüdiger Müller (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-04344.txt.

Introduction

Wolfgang Dreyer and Rüdiger Müller rebuild a piece of electrolyte theory, in a 2025 preprint, on firmer thermodynamic ground. Electrolytes are fluids with dissolved ions, like salt water. The classic Debye-Hückel model describes how ions screen each other electrically. It assumes a fixed electric response from the fluid. Real fluids change that response with mix and temperature. The authors derive a like model that allows the response to vary, without leaning on an artificial charging trick.

Their route runs through a general framework of non-equilibrium electro-thermodynamics. It yields a new consistency rule for how the response must vary with temperature. Folding the new energy term into a model that also counts ion size takes care, since it shifts the pressure. They then test the coupled model on the apparent molar volume of several salts. Checks at phase boundaries round out the study.

Catalog record

CREATORWolfgang Dreyer, Rüdiger Müller
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE136 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-04344

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Derivation and thermodynamically consistent coupling of a Debye-Hückel type energy to a steric electrolyte model and application to the apparent molar volume and phase boundaries Wolfgang Dreyer, Rüdiger Müller Abstract We derive a Debye-Hückel-like model of the electric ion-ion interaction for non-constant dielectric susceptibility, which does not depend on any kind of charging process due to its foundation in the general framework of non-equilibrium electro-thermodynamics. The derivation, however, leads to a novel thermodynamic consistency condition for the temperature dependence of the susceptibility. Due to its contributions to the total pressure, the consistent coupling of this new contribution to the free energy requires subtle modifications in the derivation of the simple mixture model for electrolytes. The coupled model is then applied to the apparent molar volume for various related monovalent salts over a wider range of salt concentrations and temperatures, and classical tests of the electrolyte theory at phase boundaries are investigated. 1 Introduction Mixing salt in water and observing the change in volume and mass density seems to be one of the simplest experiments imaginable, cf. [ RM64 ] . But even this experiment can reveal shortcomings and limitations of standard continuum models of electrolytes. In particular, frequently used steric Poisson-Boltzmann models, cf. e.g. [ KII96 , BAO97 , KBA07 , DGM13 ] , can not be expected to yield meaningful results in predicting mass density or apparent molar volume of electrolytes, despite the fact that they are developed with the goal to handle volume exclusion effects. In principle, the experiment can be considered as sufficiently explained by the Debye-Hückel theory [ DH23a ] , at least in the limit of strong dilution. Nevertheless, the Debye-Hückel theory is often considered too simplified and, for example, the role of non-constant susceptibility is still actively discussed [ VB14 , SL15 , KMMT18 , SLK23 ] . While classical Debye-Hückel theory is usually considered applicable only for dilute solutions, steric Poisson-Boltzmann like models are designed for concentrated electrolytes. Thus it appears worthwhile to couple both approaches. With the aim of comprehensive and fundamental revision of the modeling within the context of non-equilibrium electro-thermodynamics, the main goals here are: 1. Derivation of a Debye-Hückel-like electric interaction energy that consistently incorporates temperature and concentration dependent susceptibility from the outset. 2. Establishing the non-obvious consistent coupling of the steric simple mixture model with the obtained interaction energy. 3. Incorporating in general incomplete dissociation in order to apply linear material laws for mixtures while still retaining the nonlinear observed behavior. 4. Testing the developed theory over a wider concentration and temperature range using the phenomena of apparent molar volume and phase equilibrium at phase boundaries. 1.1 Some historic background of models Ideal electrolyte theory. The microscopic concept of dissociation of a salt into ions was introduced by Arrhenius [ Arr87 ] and greatly supported by van’t Hoff’s observation of the analogy between diluted electrolyte solutions and osmosis at semi-permeable membranes. Thus, in the early electrolyte theory ideality was expressed by the logarithmic chemical potential inherited from the ideal gases and Ostwald’s mass action law. The theory relied on incomplete dissociation to account for the Kohlrausch square root law observed in conductivity measurements. However, the classical ideal electrolyte model was not able to explain different experimental data consistently. In particular, when assuming the dissociation degree determined by conductivity measurement, then the Ostwald mass action law was not able to yield a reaction constant, cf. [ Red46 ] . We remark that in light of the non-equilibrium thermodynamic theory, which was only developed decades later, equilibrium quantities like the free energy or chemical potentials should not be determined by non-equilibrium properties like the electrolyte conductivity, cf. e.g. [ DGM19 ] . The classical ideal theory leads on a macroscopic scale to a Boltzmann distribution of ions and where ions do not necessarily have to be point charges, but volume exclusion effects can be neglected due to the strong dilution assumption and thus there is no mechanism in the model to limit charge accumulation at strongly charged surfaces. Steric electrolyte models. In the electrochemical double layer, electrolytes are in general concentrated and there is voltage drop over a typically very short distance, giving rise to locally extremely strong electric fields. The standard Poisson-Boltzmann model of ideal electrolytes can adequately account for the action of this electric field on ions but the missing of volume exclusion effects prevent the model to reasonably limit the local boundary layer charge. Therefore, in steric modified Poisson-Boltzmann models a size parameter is added to change the mixing entropy of ideal gases into a lattice gas approach [ KII96 , BAO97 , KBA07 ] . Extensions of lattice gas models to ions of different size have also been developed, cf. e.g. [ CBL+07 , Li09 , LE14 ] and the review in [ ZH18 ] . Instead of the lattice gas approach, in the very general simple mixture model [ DGM13 , LGD16 , DGM18 ] , the mixing entropy accounts for solvation of ions although formally looking identic to the ideal gas case, and adds an elastic energy contribution to the free energy in order to account for elastic interaction of constituents of finite size. In an incompressible limit of the elastic law, the non-ideality is expressed in a dependence of the chemical potentials on the local pressure the model can be reduced to a lattice gas. An axiomatic derivation of the simple mixture is provided in [ BDD23 ] and it is shown that the incompressible limit requires linear dependence of the volume on the mixtures composition. Steric modified Poisson-Boltzmann models which account for the concentration dependence with linear dielectric decrement are proposed in [ BYAP11 , HvRL12 , NA15 , FCBM16 ] and extended to different ion sizes developed in [ GS18 , LM22 ] . For steric models taking into account the dependency of the susceptibility on the strong electric field in the double layer, we refer to [ LM22 ] and references therein. Debye-Hückel theory. Because the double layer screens outer electric fields from the electrolyte bulk, it leaves in equilibrium the bulk electrolyte free of any electric field and the above models of electrolytes reduce to mixtures of uncharged particles, although the electrolytes consists besides of the solvent of negatively charged anions and positive cations. As a way to take electric ion-ion interactions into account within a homogeneous, macroscopically electroneutral electrolyte, Debye and Hückel introduced in 1923 a mean field model [ DH23a ] . They determined the electric energy gained by an arbitrary selected ion under the assumptions that: (i.) the surrounding environment can be described in a continuum way and is solely characterized by its constant susceptibility (ii.) the electrolytic environment can be described by Boltzmann distribution and linearization is admissible. Then, the free energy density is deduced analytically by integrating the inner energy density with respect to temperature. By this it was possible to explain non-ideal behavior at phase boundaries without having to rely on incomplete dissociation. Most important, it was possible to formulate limiting laws for strong dilution, that did not depend on the specific salt, but only on the valency of the ions. The Debye-Hückel theory was rapidly adopted by others and tested in different

Read the complete text