A Framework for Measuring the Quality of Infrastructure-as-Code Scripts
Pandu Ranga Reddy Konala 2 , Vimal Kumar 2 , David Bainbridge 2 , Junaid Haseeb 2 · 2025
Read A Framework for Measuring the Quality of Infrastructure-as-Code Scripts by Pandu Ranga Reddy Konala 2 , Vimal Kumar 2 , David Bainbridge 2 , Junaid Haseeb 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-03127.txt.
Introduction
Scripts that build whole computer systems from code now run much of modern software work, and bad scripts fail in costly ways, yet judging their quality has had no shared yardstick. Pandu Ranga Reddy Konala and co-authors propose one in a 2025 paper, shown on the Ansible family of tools. They ran the framework over a large public library of shared scripts.
Scores split by trait: metadata and error handling have improved over time, while polish traits like sophistication and automation slipped. The framework turns those traits into repeatable measures that teams can track release by release. The authors offer it as a base for standards in this young field, where a common score is the first step toward scripts that builders can trust at scale.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pandu Ranga Reddy Konala 2 , Vimal Kumar 2 , David Bainbridge 2 , Junaid Haseeb 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-03127
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Framework for Measuring the Quality of Infrastructure-as-Code Scripts Pandu Ranga Reddy Konala 2 , Vimal Kumar 2 , David Bainbridge 2 , Junaid Haseeb 2 Abstract Infrastructure as Code (IaC) has become integral to modern software development, enabling automated and consistent configuration of computing environments. The rapid proliferation of IaC scripts has highlighted the need for better code quality assessment methods. This paper proposes a new IaC code quality framework specifically showcased for Ansible repositories as a foundation. By analyzing a comprehensive dataset of repositories from Ansible Galaxy, we applied our framework to evaluate code quality across multiple attributes. The analysis of our code quality metrics applied to Ansible Galaxy repositories reveal trends over time indicating improvements in areas such as metadata and error handling, while highlighting declines in others such as sophistication and automation. The framework offers practitioners a systematic tool for assessing and enhancing IaC scripts, fostering standardization and facilitating continuous improvement. It also provides a standardized foundation for further work into IaC code quality. Keywords: Infrastructure as Code, Code Quality Framework, Ansible, IaC Scripts, Configuration Management, Software Quality, Code Quality, Software Maintainability, Code Standardization, Repository Analysis, DevOps Practices, Automation I INTRODUCTION Infrastructure as Code (IaC) has revolutionized IT infrastructure management by treating configurations as version-controlled, executable code, enabling automation, scalability, and consistency. However, as IaC becomes integral to software development, specific quality attributes are needed, since traditional standards like ISO/IEC 25010:2011 (Systems and software Quality Requirements and Evaluation — SQuaRE) [ 1 ] are designed for application software and do not fully address the unique characteristics of IaC. In this paper, we introduce an IaC quality framework consisting of nine categories, as presented herein, aligned with the aforementioned ISO/IEC 25010:2011 standard. This framework builds on and differentiates from prior work by Rahman and Williams [ 2 ] , Dalla Palma et al. [ 3 ] , and Begoug et al. [ 4 ] by tailoring the categories to the specific context of IaC. These categories—Metadata, Code Structure, Code Sophistication, Code Maintainability, Code Security, Function and Purpose, Error Handling, Automation, and Code Integration—provide a comprehensive framework that encompasses all identified IaC code attributes while remaining grounded in established principles. We validated the framework through empirical analysis of repositories from Ansible Galaxy [ 5 ] , which highlighted notable trends in IaC script quality. This analysis affirms the relevance of the proposed categories and demonstrates its practical applicability in evaluating real-world IaC scripts. We present this investigation into the relationship between the attributes and IaC quality assessment practices in the form of five key research questions (RQs). ⚫ RQ1: What mechanisms are currently employed by IaC tools to evaluate the quality of their scripts, and how consistent are these methods across the different tools? ⚫ RQ2: How do existing IaC code quality attributes map to the characteristics defined in the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 standard, and what are the limitations of this mapping? ⚫ RQ3: Which specific IaC code quality categories can be developed to accommodate all identified IaC code attributes while drawing inspiration from ISO/IEC 25010:2011? ⚫ RQ4: How does the proposed IaC code quality framework perform when applied to real-world IaC repositories, and what insights can be gained? ⚫ RQ5: In what ways can the proposed IaC code quality framework enhance the assessment of IaC scripts in practice? II BACKGROUND This section establishes a foundation for analyzing IaC quality, focusing on tools for managing IT infrastructures. It compares IaC tools such as Ansible, Terraform, Chef, and Puppet, examining their features and assessing their suitability in various contexts. By evaluating their strengths and limitations, the section provides insights into tool usage and discusses methodologies for code quality evaluation and assurance. It also compares frameworks and scoring mechanisms to explore their influence on IaC quality management. IaC is categorized into three areas [ 6 ] that automate IT processes: Infrastructure Provisioning automates allocation and management of hardware resources, with tools like Terraform and AWS CloudFormation [ 7 ] enabling resource deployment. Configuration Management automates software infrastructure configuration; tools such as Ansible, Chef, and Puppet codify system configurations, reducing errors and enhancing reproducibility. Image Building standardizes machine and container images; tools like Packer [ 8 ] create machine images, while Docker [ 9 ] enables containerization for application portability. In summary, IaC tools automate provisioning, configuration, and image building, improving efficiency and reliability in IT operations. II-A COMPARING EXISTING IaC TOOLS AND PRACTICES ⚫ RQ1: What mechanisms are currently employed by IaC tools to evaluate the quality of their scripts, and how consistent are these methods across the different tools? IaC tools employ mostly rudimentary mechanisms to evaluate script quality, but these mechanisms also differ across platforms and categories, indicating a lack of standard assessment methodologies as shown in Table I . For instance, repositories such as Ansible Galaxy, Puppet Forge, and Chef Supermarket implement quality control measures, but their implementation and transparency vary. Configuration management tools incorporate custom scoring systems to ensure quality control in maintaining IaC repositories. Notably, infrastructure provisioning and image building tools typically lack these mechanisms or have assessments that are less common. TABLE I: IaC Software Tools Repository & Quality Scoring Metrics IaC Categories IaC Software Tools Repository Quality Scoring Metrics Infrastructure Provisioning Terraform [ 10 ] Terraform Registry [ 11 ] None CloudFormation (AWS) None None Azure Resource Manager (ARM) Templates [ 12 ] Azure Quickstart Templates [ 13 ] Pass/Fail Google Cloud Deployment Manager [ 14 ] None None Configuration Management Ansible [ 15 ] Ansible Galaxy Scale of 0-5 points Puppet [ 16 ] Puppet Forge [ 17 ] Scale of 0-100% Chef [ 18 ] Chef Supermarket Scale of 0-100% SaltStack (Salt) [ 19 ] SaltStack Formula [ 20 ] None Image Building Packer None None Docker Docker Verified Publisher Program The analysis of quality scoring systems across various IaC platforms, detailed in Table II , reveals heterogeneity in assessment practices and a lack of collective standardization. This variation poses challenges for comparability and consistency, potentially impacting user trust and assessment reliability. This highlights the need for standardized, transparent, and comprehensive quality metrics for IaC tools. Implementing a unified quality assessment approach would facilitate informed decision-making and enhance the reliability and efficiency of the IaC ecosystem. TABLE II: Comparison of Quality Scoring Systems across Ansible Galaxy, Puppet Forge, Chef Supermarket, Azure, and Docker Feature Ansible Galaxy Puppet Forge Chef Supermarket Azure Docker Scoring Method Weighted combination of community and quality scores, based on user surveys. Automated evaluation for code formatting and malware checks. Community-defined quality metrics, including publication status and platform support. Compliance checks against Azure best practices. Docker Security Scanning and Docker Verified Publisher Program. Scoring Scale Point based scoring ranging from 0 to 5.0 for both Community and Quality Scores. Percentage based scoring. Percentage based scoring. Binary Pass/Fail assessment. None Evaluation Tools yamllint [ 21 ] , ansible-lint [ 22 ] , import-time checks. VirusTotal for binary security checks. Foodcritic [ 23 ] for cookbook evaluation. Azure Policy, ARM Template Test Toolkit. Docker Scout for vulnerability analysis. Score Components Community input, Syntax Score, Metadata Score. Code formatting, security checks. Publication status, collaboration, licensing, platform support. Compliance with Azure standards, security checks, resource optimization. Security vulnerabilities, image integrity, publisher verification. Critique