On likelihood-based analysis of the gravitationally (de)lensed CMB

Julien Carron · 2025

Read On likelihood-based analysis of the gravitationally (de)lensed CMB by Julien Carron (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-02399.txt.

Introduction

Julien Carron sharpens the study of bent cosmic background light in a 2025 paper. Gravity from matter bends the cosmic microwave background as it travels, which blurs its fine print. Undoing that bend by likelihood methods can pull far more signal from sharp new maps.

Carron derives the best summary statistics for the bent data and names the role of each term. The terms line up with parts of the classic quadratic estimator frame. Pros and cons of live methods are weighed in that light, with fixes for one used in a recent telescope study. Paths to import the older frame's checks into new methods close the work.

Catalog record

CREATORJulien Carron
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-02399

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On likelihood-based analysis of the gravitationally (de)lensed CMB Julien Carron Abstract By reducing variance induced by gravitational lensing, likelihood-based de-lensing techniques have true potential to extract significantly more information from deep and high-resolution Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data than traditional methods. We derive here optimal data compression statistics for the lensed CMB, and clarify the role of each term, demonstrating their direct analogs in the quadratic estimator (QE) framework. We discuss in this light pros and cons of practical implementations, including the MUSE approach as used in the latest SPT-3G cosmological analysis, and give improvements. We discuss pathways for porting the large robustness and redundancy toolbox of the QE approach to beyond-QE with simple means. I Introduction The Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) provides one of the most powerful observational windows into the early universe and fundamental physics. The study of gravitational lensing of the CMB, caused by the large-scale distribution of matter along the line of sight, has become an important tool in modern cosmology. Lensing encodes valuable information about the intervening matter distribution, enabling precision constraints on the growth of structure over cosmic time Lewis and Challinor 2006 ; Carron et al. 2022 ; Madhavacheril et al. 2023 ; Ge et al. 2024 ; Ade et al. 2019 . Removal of the lensing signal (‘de-lensing’) is absolutely essential for best constraints on a background of primordial gravitational waves Ade et al. 2021 ; Abazajian et al. 2022 ; Belkner et al. 2023 , and can also help significantly a variety of other science targets Green et al. 2016 ; Coulton et al. 2020 ; Hotinli et al. 2022 ; Abazajian et al. 2016 . Traditional analyses of CMB lensing rely heavily on quadratic estimators (QEs) Okamoto and Hu 2003 ; Hu and Okamoto 2002 ; Maniyar et al. 2021 , which provide an often efficient, computationally affordable and well-understood way to reconstruct the lensing potential from CMB maps. However, it has long been well-known that likelihood-based, ‘beyond-QE’ approaches can, in principle, extract additional information by exploiting more optimally the statistical anisotropies of the observed lensed CMB Hirata and Seljak 2003a ; Hirata and Seljak 2003b . Likelihood-based methods offer superior signal recovery for deep and high-resolution data, where delensing plays a key role in achieving optimal inference, by reducing sample variance. Despite their theoretical advantages, practical implementations of likelihood-based reconstruction remain computationally challenging and require a careful understanding of robustness and systematic effects. In this work, we revisit in a more rigorous manner, and with the help of the much greater understanding of quadratic estimators we have now, the structure of CMB likelihood gradients and their associated spectra, and the implications for optimized spectrum analysis. We clarify the interpretation of likelihood gradients and of the likelihood curvature, showing that each term has a direct QE analog. We discuss practical implementations of these ideas, including the Marginal Unbiased Score Expansion (MUSE) method, which has been employed in the latest SPT-3G cosmological analysis Ge et al. 2024 . By revisiting these techniques within our framework, we suggest refinements that improve robustness and interpretability. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we review the structure of CMB likelihood gradients, and their relationship to traditional QE methods. Section III presents a detailed analysis of lensing spectrum estimation, including realization-dependent debiasing and beyond-QE lensing biases. We do this by manipulating the lensing spectrum score function. In Section IV, we discuss practical approaches, focusing on either modeling of the score likelihood, or instead the iterative MUSE framework, along with potential improvements. Finally, Section VI summarizes our findings and implications for beyond-QE CMB lensing analyses. We do not attempt to review here quadratic estimators. See for example Ref. Maniyar et al. 2021 , which derives them in different ways, and references therein. Quadratic estimator theory, including of realization-dependent debiasing, also follows from this work evaluated in the absence of delensing. II CMB Likelihood gradients We start by introducing some statistical tools. II.1 Score functions Let X be the CMB data and \bm{\theta} parameters of interest (e.g. the lensing potential or the unlensed CMB field at some location, their power spectrum at some multipole, a cosmological or nuisance parameter…) In this paper we consider log-likelihood derivatives. The behavior of the linear response s_{\theta_{i}}({X},\bm{\theta})\equiv\partial_{\theta_{i}}\ln p({X}|\bm{\theta}) (1) obviously contains relevant information on \theta_{i} . This can be formalized: the functions s_{\theta} is called the score . After picking a set of fiducial values for the parameters entering the score, these functions can be viewed as summary statistics. Provided the chosen fiducial values are close to the truth, they present in fact a lossless compression of the data, in the precise sense that the score covariance matrix is equal to the Fisher matrix. This allows in principle reduction of the entire data set to N numbers, where N is the number of parameters Carron and Szapudi 2013 ; Alsing and Wandelt 2018 . This can be illustrated simply with the case of isotropic Gaussian fields, also useful later on. If \kappa is an isotropic Gaussian field with spectrum C_{L} , then the spectrum score is s_{C_{L}}=\frac{2L+1}{2C_{L}^{2}}\left(\hat{C}_{L}-C_{L}\right) (2) with \hat{C} the (pseudo-)power \hat{C}_{L}\equiv\frac{1}{2L+1}\sum_{M=-L}^{L}|\kappa_{LM}|^{2}. (3) Up to a multiplicative and additive constant, s_{C_{L}} is the empirical power – the empirical spectrum carries the entire information content in a Gaussian field. Some comments: 1. Obviously the score is rarely as simple or practical than this example, but may still be used to try and design efficient observables, by approximating it with something usable (‘ s^{\text{USABLE}} ’). If the approximation captures the relevant elements, one will then make a good job at inference, by computing this observable from the data and building a likelihood for it. 2. The score always vanishes in the mean, provided the fiducial model matches the truth (as can be seen clearly in Eq. ( 2 ), where \left\langle s_{C_{L}}\right\rangle=0 in for consistent fiducial model)). This suggests another approach, potentially useful for example when the construction of the score statistic or it approximation heavily depends on a fiducial value for the parameters of interests: One may solve for \bm{\theta} by requesting consistency with simulations, by solving for \bm{\theta} the following equations s^{\text{USABLE}}({X},\bm{\theta})=\left\langle s^{\text{USABLE}}({S},\bm{\theta})\right\rangle_{{S}|\bm{\theta}}, (4) where the average on the right-hand side is over realizations of the data conditioned on \bm{\theta} . In the CMB and CMB lensing context relevant to this paper, this is how the MUSE Millea and Seljak 2022 framework works. The average can virtually never be computed analytically, so this approach obviously also requires the ability to generate large enough sets of simulations of good enough fidelity. Again, inference will be good if these conditions are met and s^{\text{USABLE}} a sensible approximation to the score. 3. Finally, the prefactor (2L+1)/2C_{L}^{2} in Eq. ( 2 ) is the inverse well-known variance of the spectrum statistic \hat{C}_{L} : whenever the score can be treated as linear in the parameter of interest, the latter is always inverse-variance weighted. A less trivial example is that of CMB lensing (and other) quadratic estimators, for which the normalization (the inverse response) is identical in the fiducial model to the reconstruction noise (‘ N^{(0)}_{L} ’) Hu and Okamoto 2002 ; Maniyar et al. 2021 . We now turn to the lensed CMB

Read the complete text