Flow rate from a vertical silo with a tilted orifice Journal: Powder Technology

Ryan Kozlowski, Luis A. Pugnaloni · 2025

Read Flow rate from a vertical silo with a tilted orifice Journal: Powder Technology by Ryan Kozlowski, Luis A. Pugnaloni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-02306.txt.

Introduction

Ryan Kozlowski and Luis Pugnaloni tilt a silo mouth to steer grain flow in a 2025 paper. Grain flow from bins is key to plants that store seed, sand, and powders. Tilting the whole bin works to slow flow, but plants can not oft tilt a fixed bin.

In flat bin tests, turning just the mouth slowed the flow, though less than a full tilt. Grain sized ridges by the mouth made the drop match past tilt results in full. Fast films tracked grain speed, still zones, and slip zones by the mouth. Creep of grains sideways along slip zones drives the model they build.

Catalog record

CREATORRyan Kozlowski, Luis A. Pugnaloni
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-02306

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Flow rate from a vertical silo with a tilted orifice Journal: Powder Technology Ryan Kozlowski, Luis A. Pugnaloni Abstract The flow of dry granular materials from silos is of great practical interest in industry and of theoretical import for understanding multiphase dynamics. Recent studies have demonstrated that one way to control the rate of flow from a silo is to tilt it. However, this may not be practical in many industrial applications. Here, we demonstrate in experiments of quasi-2D silo discharge of monodisperse grains that the flow rate can be modulated by rotating the orifice – through elevating and shifting one side of the base – instead of tilting the entire silo. We use high-speed image analysis to track the average motion of grains in the silo. We first show that the flow rate decreases with orifice angle, but that this decrease is not as strong as when a silo is tilted or when a lateral orifice is used. However, with the addition of a grain-sized ridge on each side of the orifice, the flow rate collapses with prior tilted-silo results. We then characterize the flow velocity of grains exiting the orifice and highlight key features of the stagnant zones and slip zones on each orifice side. Finally, we model our results based on these measurements, demonstrating the importance of horizontal creep along slip zones next to the orifice and the narrowest opening cross-section through which the material flows. These findings reveal a simple method for controlling both flow rate and direction, and highlight the importance of both dynamics within and geometry of the stagnant zones near the orifice. † † graphicalabstract: † † highlights: Vary orifice angle of quasi-2D silo by elevating one orifice edge. Flow rate, average packing fraction, and average flow fields with high-speed imaging. Effect of fixed grain placed on each orifice edge to minimize boundary slipping. Horizontal creep at each orifice edge plays vital role in flow rate. Stagnant zone constrains flow upstream from orifice for steep enough angles. 1 Introduction In many natural and industrial systems, particulate matter is driven through constricted openings, such as fine particles flowing through porous media [ 1 ] , gas hydrates flowing in pipelines [ 2 ] , pedestrians exiting a room [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] , logs moving down a river [ 6 ] , or suspension particles navigating microfluidic channels [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Gravity-driven flows of granular materials [ 11 ] through a confined orifice in a silo are especially prevalent in industrial and geophysical systems, for example in the processing and transport of pharmaceuticals [ 12 ] and food products [ 13 , 14 ] and debris flows through harm-mitigating slit dams [ 15 ] . Characterizing the flow rate and clogging behaviors of granular materials in silos is therefore important both for developing efficient practices [ 12 , 16 ] and robust models of the rheology of intermittent dense granular flows. A large body of research confirms that the flow rate of dry, gravity-driven granular materials is described by the Beverloo Rule [ 17 , 18 ] , an empirical relationship for the flow rate of the material Q based on dimensional analysis relating the relative size of grains d to the orifice size D : Q=C\rho_{\rm B}\sqrt{g}(D-kd)^{f/2}, (1) where f=3 in two-dimensional (2D) silos and f=5 in three-dimensional (3D) silos, C is a dimensionless parameter that is largely independent of details of the granular material [ 19 ] , k is a parameter characterizing the so-called “empty annulus” accounting for steric limitations of grain flow near the orifice edges [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , \rho_{\rm B} is the bulk density of the granular material in the silo, and g is the free-fall acceleration. For a flat-bottomed, upright silo, Beverloo’s rule has successfully been modeled from first principles by considering energy balance in the silo [ 23 , 19 ] . Experiments have shown that the flow rate of grains depends on a variety of factors related to the geometry of the container, including container dimensions [ 24 ] , hopper angle [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] , orifice shape [ 29 ] , the presence of multiple orifices [ 30 ] , and whether the orifice is on the bottom of the silo or on a side-wall [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] . Ref. [ 33 ] even found, surprisingly, that the Beverloo’s rule power law exponent 5/2 for a lateral orifice in a 3D silo becomes linear —not the expected 3/2 — when the silo width is narrowed to approach a quasi-2D silo as the spacing confining the grains to a monolayer becomes a relevant lengthscale. The use of lateral orifices, or more generally orifices tilted away from the horizontal, is important in a variety of industrial settings. For example, one may need to modulate the direction of flow by tilting the opening or silo and then adjusting the flow rate with the orifice opening size. And in some cases, the spatial constraints of an existing industrial setup may actually prevent effective discharge from a bottom opening. The first relationship between Q and the inclination angle \theta of the orifice above the horizontal was posed by Franklin and Johanson based on measurements for a few orientations: Q(\theta)=Q_{0}\frac{\cos\theta_{\rm S}+\cos\theta}{\cos\theta_{\rm S}+1}, where the angle of the stagnant zone of the granular material is denoted by \theta_{\rm S} and Q_{0} is the flow rate at \theta=0^{\circ} [ 36 ] . A dependence on \cos\theta would suggest that the horizontal projection of the orifice determines the flow rate of the material, but since flows are observed to occur even for \theta>90^{\circ} , this is at best an incomplete, empirical model. Recent studies examining a more robust range of silo angles [ 37 , 38 ] find that more elaborate models are necessary to capture Q(\theta) [ 39 ] . In particular, Ref. [ 40 ] examined a 2D tilted silo and modeled Q(\theta) by considering the flow of side streams of the material along stagnant zone surfaces or, when tilted steeply enough, along one of the confining orifice walls. Despite their success in describing tilted silo discharge rates, the recently proposed models of Refs. [ 39 ] and [ 40 ] are not fully physically motivated: Ref. [ 39 ] can only treat the regime \theta>90^{\circ} semi-empirically, while Ref. [ 40 ] proposes an empirical relationship for average outpouring flow speed with \theta . Moreover, the validity of existing model predictions has not been tested in other geometric configurations where the orifice is tilted without utilizing a side-wall or tilting an entire silo (where preparation protocol —whether grains are poured prior to tilting, or if they are poured after tilting— may be an important factor). In this work, we present experiments studying the discharge of grains from a quasi-2D silo with varying orifice orientation by elevating one side of the bottom boundary vertically above the other while holding constant the edge-to-edge distance. This is a novel approach to tilting the orifice that may be more practically implemented than drilling new holes or tilting

Read the complete text