Cosmic shear nulling as a geometrical cosmological probe: Methodology and sensitivity to cosmological parameters and systematics

David Touzeau, Francis Bernardeau, Karim Benabed, Sandrine Codis · 2025

Read Cosmic shear nulling as a geometrical cosmological probe: Methodology and sensitivity to cosmological parameters and systematics by David Touzeau, Francis Bernardeau, Karim Benabed, Sandrine Codis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-02246.txt.

Introduction

David Touzeau and three co-authors develop a geometry test for cosmology in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Weak lensing surveys map how gravity bends light from distant galaxies. The bending patterns hold symmetries that depend only on the shape of the universe's expansion. Checking that these patterns cancel where they should is called a null test. The authors build a full method around tomographic cosmic shear nulling.

They show what the test can pin down, above all how distances grow with redshift. They also probe its weak spots, such as magnification bias and errors in galaxy distance bins. In a survey like the coming Euclid mission, the test performs well. Pure geometry checks, free of growth assumptions, add trust to cosmology results.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Touzeau, Francis Bernardeau, Karim Benabed, Sandrine Codis
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-02246

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmic shear nulling as a geometrical cosmological probe: Methodology and sensitivity to cosmological parameters and systematics David Touzeau, Francis Bernardeau, Karim Benabed, Sandrine Codis Abstract Tomographic weak lensing surveys contain intrinsic symmetries that depend solely on the geometric structure of the Universe. These symmetries can be revealed through null tests and verifying their validity provides constraints on cosmological parameters that govern the background evolution—particularly the redshift dependence of the angular diameter distance. This forms the foundation of the tomographic cosmic shear nulling test introduced in this work. We describe how this test can be implemented, what aspects of cosmology it can constrain, and its specific efficiency in doing so. We also assess its sensitivity to astrophysical effects—such as magnification bias and reduced shear corrections—as well as to observational systematics, including errors in the mean redshift of source bins. Our results show that, in a survey configuration comparable to that of Euclid, this null test can yield complementary constraints on key cosmological parameters such as Ω m , w 0 {\Omega_{\rm m},{\rm w}_{0}} . However, due to its subdominant constraining power compared to standard 3 × \times 2pt analysis and through the identification of a required precision of order 10 − 3 10^{-3} on the mean redshift of the bins, we conclude that nulling would better be used as a photometric redshift calibration probe or consistency check. In combination with standard weak lensing and galaxy clustering analysis, it would then offer a promising route to better control systematics and improve the precision of future cosmological measurements. I Introduction Modern observational cosmology and investigations of large-scale structures, dark energy, and dark matter rely on large-scale galaxy surveys such as KiDS [ 11 , 6 ] , DES [ 3 , 2 ] , LSST [ 1 ] , and Euclid [ 27 ] , which use cosmic shear as a weak lensing probe. Weak lensing is a large-scale gravitational effect induced by small matter density variations along the trajectory of photons and manifesting through small deformations of galaxy shapes, as opposed to strong lensing which appears through multiple images and Einstein rings. This effect is expressed through a deformation matrix containing a convergence \kappa and a two-component shear \gamma^{\alpha} which are, by definition, supposed to be small. The latest generations of surveys pave the way for tomographic explorations, first described in Ref. [ 16 ] . This strategy allows us to probe different redshifts and therefore different epochs of the expansion of the Universe, thanks to the increased level of precision of these surveys. In particular, the recently launched Euclid [ 27 ] satellite opens a new era for weak lensing analysis using tomography thanks to its precision in redshift, the large sky area covered, its shear measurement accuracy, and its high galaxy density. Thus, the latest generation of surveys leads to a new level of precision in the study of notably dark energy, which requires the development of optimal statistical tools and methodologies to extract cosmological information from these rich datasets. In this context, any possible gain in precision, reduction of uncertainties, or further tests of systematics (which can induce biases and inconsistencies in the cosmological inference pipeline) is highly valuable. In this paper, we propose nulling—via the so-called Bernardeau-Nishimichi-Taruya (BNT) transform [ 7 ] applied to cosmic shear maps—as a new cosmological probe, only based on the geometry of space-time. Standard weak lensing convergence maps get contributions from every gravitational lens all along the line of sight modulated with an efficiency that depends on the background cosmology and peaks at roughly the mean comoving distance. The BNT transform is a simple linear combination of the maps based only on space-time geometry that allows us to build a new tomographic construction for which the transformed convergence maps do not get contributions from low-redshift lenses. Although the BNT transform is not the first nulling method to be developed on the cosmic shear [ 17 , 20 , 28 , 29 ] , the BNT transform is the only one that puts forward a full nulling property at the level of convergence maps that is fully based on theoretical assumptions. A now well-explored consequence of this transformation is that it reduces scale mixing in the projection effects. It therefore makes it possible to build observables with reduced sensitivity to small-scale physics including gravitational nonlinearities and poorly controlled baryonic effects. Such a separation of scales is implemented in Refs. [ 34 , 33 , 14 ] and appeared as an optimal solution to bypass such difficulties. Reference [ 8 ] also shows that the BNT transform can give access to baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) features in cosmic shear observations. This methodology is also implemented for CMB lensing and line intensity mapping in Refs. [ 13 , 26 ] . However, in this paper, we propose a completely different approach for the exploitation of the BNT transform. We do not consider it as a way to build better-behaved observables. We consider the nulling property of the BNT transformed maps as a direct manifestation of the geometric structure of space-time, which can therefore be exploited as a fundamental cosmological probe. So, what we propose here is a null test of the BNT transformed cosmic shear maps. The idea is as follows: BNT transformed cosmic shear maps do not receive contributions from low-redshift lenses and therefore should have vanishing correlation, within noise level, with any low-redshift tracers of the large-scale structure. The aim of this article is to show that nulling as a new cosmological test is worth implementing in the context of current and upcoming weak lensing surveys with precise enough source redshift distributions. In Sec. II , we recap the formalism of the BNT transform and derive the equations governing the proposed null test (including adequate cross-spectra). Section III gives the specifications and Euclid-like context of our study. Then, in Sec. IV , we investigate the effect of higher-order corrections such as the reduced shear and magnification bias, by means of bispectrum corrections. Section V gives the resulting cosmological constraints, correlations, and degeneracies of the system. Finally, in Sec. VI , we investigate photometric redshift errors as a systematic effect. In Sec. III , we also address the similarities and differences of our approach with the so called shear ratio approach, introduced in Ref. [ 18 ] and applied in Refs. [ 28 , 29 ] , which exploits some partial nulling properties. II Nulling cosmic shear observables II.1 Nulling tomographic cosmic shear maps The BNT transform was introduced in Ref. [ 7 ] as a nulling technique to build linear combinations of cosmic shear maps that are only sensitive to a restricted redshift range. This procedure is purely geometrical and thus scale independent and independent of the power spectrum or matter density contrast. It can be thought of as a way to reorganize the information contained in cosmic shear observables so as to separate information between the maps, hence disentangling the small physical scales at low redshifts from the large physical scales at larger redshifts within a given light-cone aperture. In a standard tomographic analysis of weak lensing, we work with a set of convergence maps in redshift bins with indices i=1,\dots,N_{z} . The

Read the complete text