Strengthening by softening: rigidity increase of a curved sheet from nonlinear regime of deformation

Nino Quillent-Elinguel and Thomas Barois · 2025

Read Strengthening by softening: rigidity increase of a curved sheet from nonlinear regime of deformation by Nino Quillent-Elinguel and Thomas Barois (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-02159.txt.

Introduction

Nino Quillent-Elinguel and Thomas Barois found in 2025 a paradox of thin sheets: loosening the clamp that holds a curved sheet can make it harder to bend. Curvature already stiffens a sheet far beyond its flat self. Their bench tests and simulations trace the extra strength to the geometry of that curvature.

Softening the rim lets the sheet redistribute its shape under load, recruiting more of the curvature's built-in resistance. A second surprise followed: an open curved sheet can out-resist a closed cylinder of the same size. The authors frame both effects as compliance working for, not against, the structure. The result may inform shells and panels that must be light yet stubborn. It also warns designers that tighter is not always stronger.

Catalog record

CREATORNino Quillent-Elinguel and Thomas Barois
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-02159

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strengthening by softening: rigidity increase of a curved sheet from nonlinear regime of deformation Nino Quillent-Elinguel and Thomas Barois Abstract It is well-known that a thin sheet held in a rigid circular clamp has a larger flexural strength than when it is flat. Here, we report that the flexural strength of curved sheets is further increased with a softening of the clamping condition. This unexpected compliance effect relates to the geometrical properties of curvature-induced rigidity that we observe in controlled experiments and further analyze with numerical simulations. In addition, we identify another compliance effect in which opened curved sheets can be more resistant to bending than closed cylinders of same dimensions. Thin sheets are mechanical structures presenting a rich phenomenology Audoly and Neukirch 2005 ; Marder et al. 2007 ; Audoly and Pomeau 2010 ; Vandeparre et al. 2011 ; Reis 2015 ; Holmes 2019 ; Croll et al. 2019 ; Siéfert et al. 2021 due to the geometrical effects arising from the large mismatch between small thicknesses and comparatively large sizes. For a rectangular sheet of length L , width W and thickness t , the scaling relations t\ll W and t\ll L make that the sheet naturally favors bending deformations over stretching deformations Rayleigh 1888 . A consequence of this is the possibility to induce stiffening of floppy sheets Pini et al. 2016 : by imposing a curvature in a given direction, the bending in the other direction becomes energetically expensive because it requires stretching. Curvature-induced rigidity is found in different contexts such as tape springs Calladine and Seffen 2020 , folded strips Walker and Seffen 2019 , plant leaves Moulia et al. 1994 ; Moulia 2000 ; Wei et al. 2023 , egg geometry Lazarus et al. 2012 , fins Nguyen et al. 2017 and wings MacPhee et al. 2022 stiffening, actuators Wu et al. 2021 , wavy walls O’Neill 1980 and pizza slice manipulation Taffetani et al. 2019 . When thin sheets are curved, the structural failure Peterson et al. 1968 ; Singer et al. 2002 under loads usually follows a different phenomenology than the bulk material failure. The failure of shells under bending or compression loads is often not a failure of the material itself but the result of the growth of a buckling mode predicted by a linear stability analysis Houliara and Karamanos 2010 ; Hutchinson 2010 ; Rotter et al. 2014 ; Virot et al. 2017 ; Gerasimidis et al. 2018 ; Gerasimidis and Hutchinson 2020 . In the post-buckling regime, curved sheets exhibit some form of crumpling Ben Amar and Pomeau 1997 ; Witten 2007 , which takes the form of a more or less complex network of singularities Cerda and Mahadevan 1998 ; Chaïeb et al. 1998 ; Cerda et al. 1999 ; Gottesman et al. 2015 ; Chopin and Kudrolli 2016 ; Audoly and Hutchinson 2020 and ridges Lobkovsky 1996 ; DiDonna 2002 ; Venkataramani 2003 ; Andresen et al. 2007 ; Cambou and Menon 2011 ; Fuentealba et al. 2015 . The formation of this type of structures was studied for compaction Blair and Kudrolli 2005 ; Vliegenthart and Gompper 2006 ; Sultan and Boudaoud 2006 ; Balankin et al. 2010 ; Nasto et al. 2013 ; Gottesman et al. 2018 ; Abramian et al. 2020 ; Bense and van Hecke 2021 , indentation Boudaoud et al. 2000 ; Vaziri and Mahadevan 2008 ; Vella et al. 2012 or in other situations Roman and Pocheau 2012 ; Barois et al. 2021 . Figure 1: a) Question addressed in this work: what is the optimal structure to support a force F a distance L ? b) Rectangular sheet of width W and thickness t held in a circular clamp of radius R=25 mm. L_{cl} is the distance between the inner circular cylinder and the external part of the clamp. L=25 mm is the distance between the clamp and the applied force. L_{end} is the distance between the applied force and the free end of the sheet. n points to the location of the stress focusing singularities for collapsed sheets. c) Collapse forces as a function of the normalized width W/2\pi R that quantifies the portion of the circular clamp covered by the sheet. The forces are applied by masses hanging under gravity. L_{cl}=0 mm corresponds to a rigid clamp and L_{cl}=6 mm is for a compliant clamp. The question we address is this work is illustrated in figure 1 a: what is the optimal structure that can support a static load F at a horizontal distance L of a rigid wall? With the classical Euler-Bernoulli beam theory as a starting approach, it seems that, first, there is no need for the structure to expand beyond the distance L and, second, the anchoring of an optimal structure with the rigid wall should be as rigid as possible. We will show that these two intuitive ideas are wrong for model structures in the non-linear regime of curvature-induced rigidity. We consider a simple mechanical structure obtained by curving a piece of rectangular thin sheet, as shown in figure 1 b. The sheets are initially flat and rectangular with thickness t=0.2 mm and width W . The circular clamp is a rigid cylinder of radius R=25 mm and the curved sheet configuration is obtained by pressing the sheet against the rigid cylinder with a hose clamp. The distance L_{cl} denotes the shift in position between the hose clamp and the cylinder. L_{cl}=0 mm is the rigid clamping condition for which the sheet is forced to lie on a circle at the end of the clamp. L_{cl}>0 mm is a soft clamp condition in which the sheet is circular without applied load but in the presence of loads, the sheet can slightly move away from the inner cylinder. The free-standing length of the sheet is L+L_{end} where L_{end} is the distance between the position of the applied force and the free edge of the sheet. The distance L is the effective length between the end of the clamp and the location of the applied force. The load is applied by hanging a mass to a hook passing through a small hole. For long sheets, the persistence length Lobkovsky and Witten 1997 ; Mahadevan et al. 2007 ; Barois et al. 2014 ; Matsumoto et al. 2018 ; Bhaskar and Jose 2021 ; Audoly and Neukirch 2021 of the transverse curvature scales as L_{p}\sim W^{2}/\sqrt{Rt} . Here, we are interested in the regime of curvature-induced stiffening L<L_{p} , which means that, in the absence of applied forces, the sheets are sufficiently short for the transverse curvature to be strictly positive for the whole sheet. In figure 1 c, we represent the measured collapse force F_{c} as a function of the width normalized by the perimeter W/2\pi R for 3 sets of data. The reference set of data with triangle symbols is for the force applied through a hole placed as close as possible to the end of the sheet ( L_{end}=1 mm) and a rigid clamp L_{cl}=0 mm. The first data point is for W/2\pi R = 0.16. Below this value, the sheet is floppy because W is not large enough for the sheet to be

Read the complete text