On a generalization of Godbersen’s conjecture
Jan Kotrbatý · 2025
Read On a generalization of Godbersen’s conjecture by Jan Kotrbatý (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-02149.txt.
Introduction
Jan Kotrbatý wrote a 2025 math note on a conjecture in convex geometry. The catalog title carries a funding note, but the note itself concerns the difference body of a convex shape: the set of all gaps between pairs of its points. A known inequality bounds that set's volume, and Godbersen's conjecture claims a sharper bound using the shape and its mirror image.
Kotrbatý proposes a wider version covering higher-order difference bodies, which stack the construction further. He proves the wider claim for a well-behaved class called anti-blocking bodies. He also links the bound to a product operation on certain measures, giving a second form of the same claim. Notes like this inch a long-open problem forward in the cases that can be settled.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jan Kotrbatý |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-02149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On a generalization of Godbersen’s conjecture Thanks: Supported by Charles University grants PRIMUS/24/SCI/009 and UNCE/24/SCI/022. Jan Kotrbatý Abstract . The long-standing Godbersen’s conjecture asserts that the Rogers–Shephard inequality for the volume of the difference body is refined by an inequality for the mixed volume of a convex body and its reflection about the origin. The conjecture is known in several special cases, notably for anti-blocking convex bodies. In this note, we propose a generalization of Godbersen’s conjecture that refines Schneider’s generalization of the Rogers–Shephard inequality to higher-order difference bodies and prove our conjecture for anti-blocking convex bodies. Moreover, we relate the conjectured inequality to the higher-rank mixed volume defined by the author and Wannerer which leads to an equivalent formulation in terms of the Alesker product of smooth, translation invariant valuations. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 52A40, 52A39, 52B45, 52B12 1. Introduction The difference body DK of a convex body K\subset\RR^{n} is, by definition, the Minkowski sum of K with its reflection -K about the origin. Due to a classical result of Rogers and Shephard [ 23 , 24 ] , the volume of the difference body is bounded above in terms of the volume of K as follows: (1) \displaystyle\vol_{n}(DK)\leq{2n\choose n}\vol_{n}(K). Besides bodies with empty interior, equality in ( 1 ) is attained if and only if K is a simplex. When restricted to convex bodies, the Lebesgue measure \vol_{n} polarizes with respect to the Minkowski addition. This yields a unique n -linear symmetric function V , called mixed volume, satisfying V(K,\dots,K)=\vol_{n}(K) , see Section 2 for an explicit definition. Expanding the left-hand side of ( 1 ) by linearity and the right-hand side using the identity {2n\choose n}=\sum_{k=0}^{n}{n\choose k}^{2} , one obtains an inequality between sums of length n+1 . It was conjectured by Godbersen [ 13 ] in 1938 that the inequality in fact holds term-wise. More precisely, denoting k copies of the same convex body K by K[k] , one has the following: Conjecture 1.1 (Godbersen) . For each convex body K\subset\RR^{n} and each 0\leq k\leq n one has (2) \displaystyle V(-K[k],K[n-k])\leq{n\choose k}\vol_{n}(K). Moreover, if 0<k<n and \interior K\neq\emptyset , equality holds if and only if K is a simplex. Conjecture 1.1 is known only in certain special cases. The case k\in\{0,n\} is trivial. The case k\in\{1,n-1\} follows from a result of Schneider [ 28 ] . For general k , the conjecture was verified for bodies of constant width by Godbersen [ 13 ] . Much more recently, Artstein-Avidan, Sadovsky, and Sanyal [ 8 ] gave a proof for anti-blocking bodies which was generalized to locally anti-blocking bodies by Sadovsky [ 25 ] . Artstein-Avidan, Einhorn, Florentin, and Ostrover [ 6 ] proved a related statement that in particular implies ( 2 ) up to a factor \sqrt{n} . Very recently, their result was improved by Artstein-Avidan and Putterman [ 7 ] . A different generalization of the Rogers–Shephard inequality was considered by Schneider [ 27 ] . Observing that DK=\{x\in\RR^{n}\mid K\cap(K+x)\neq\emptyset\} , Schneider defined for each p\in\NN the higher-order difference body D_{p}K=\{(x_{1},\dots,x_{p})\in(\RR^{n})^{p}\mid K\cap(K+x_{1})\cap\cdots\cap(K+x_{p})\neq\emptyset\} and proved that (3) \displaystyle\vol_{pn}(D_{p}K)\leq{pn+n\choose n}\vol_{n}(K)^{p} with equality if and only if K is a simplex (unless \interior K=\emptyset ). An alternative proof of ( 3 ) was recently given by Haddad, Langharst, Putterman, Roysdon, and Ye [ 14 ] who also extended Schneider’s generalization of the difference body to other important convex-geometric constructions and proved the respective inequalities. Functional versions of these inequalities were subsequently proven by Langharst, Sola, and Ulivelli [ 20 ] and by Langharst, Putterman, Roysdon, and Ye [ 19 ] . It is easily seen that the (original) Minkowski sum presentation of DK generalizes to the higher-order difference bodies. Namely, one has D_{p}K=\Delta_{p}K-K^{p} , where \Delta_{p}:\RR^{n}\to(\RR^{n})^{p} is the diagonal embedding and K^{p}=K\times\cdots\times K the p -ary Cartesian power of K , see Proposition 3.1 . Motivated by this observation, we propose—in the same way as Godbersen’s conjecture refines the Rogers–Shephard inequality—the following refinement of Schneider’s inequality: Conjecture 1.2 . For each convex body K\subset\RR^{n} , 0\leq k\leq n , and p\in\NN one has (4) \displaystyle V(-\Delta_{p}K[k],K^{p}[pn-k])\leq{n\choose k}\vol_{n}(K)^{p}. Moreover, if 0<k and \interior K\neq\emptyset , equality holds if and only if K is a simplex. Observe that Conjecture 1.2 subsumes Godbersen’s conjecture for p=1 . In this connection, let us also mention that a different generalization of Conjecture 1.1 was proposed in [ 6 ] . The fact that ( 4 ) implies ( 3 ) follows at once from multilinearity of the mixed volume and an elementary combinatorial identity, see Section 3 . The generalizing procedure can be further iterated using that K^{p}=\sum_{j=1}^{p}\iota_{j}K , where \iota_{j}:\RR^{n}\to(\RR^{n})^{p} is the inclusion into the j -th factor, along with another combinatorial identity. This leads us to the following more fundamental conjecture that strengthens Conjecture 1.2 : Conjecture 1.3 . Let K\subset\RR^{n} be a convex body. For any p\in\NN , 0\leq k\leq n , and 0\leq k_{i}\leq n , i=1,\dots,p , such that k_{1}+\cdots+k_{p}=k one has (5) \displaystyle V(-\Delta_{p}K[k],\iota_{1}K[n-k_{1}],\dots,\iota_{p}K[n-k_{p}])\leq{n\choose k}{k\choose k_{1},\dots,k_{p}}\frac{(n!)^{p}}{(pn)!}\vol_{n}(K)^{p}. Moreover, if k_{i}<n for all i , 0<k , and \interior K\neq\emptyset , equality holds if and only if K is a simplex. Our main result establishes these conjectures for the class of anti-blocking convex bodies. Recall that a convex body is called anti-blocking if it is contained in the positive orthant and its projection to each coordinate subspace equals the section with the subspace, see Section 2 . Theorem 1.4 . Conjecture 1.3 (and hence Conjecture 1.2 ) is true if the convex body K is assumed to be anti-blocking. The proof of Theorem 1.4 depends on the dual Bollobás–Thomason inequality recently proven by Liakopoulos [ 21 ] and on the characterization of its equality cases due to Boroczky, Kalantzopoulos, and Xi [ 11 ] . Let us also mention that other geometric inequalities for (locally) anti-blocking bodies were proven by Artstein-Avidan, Sadovsky, and Sanyal [ 8 ] , Manui, Ndiaye, and Zvavitch [ 22 ] , and Sanyal and Winter [ 26 ] . A new, fruitful approach to geometric inequalities was recently discovered to be based on Alesker’s algebraic theory of valuations [ 1 , 2 , 9 ] . A central object here is the algebra \Val^{\infty}(\RR^{n}) of smooth, translation invariant valuations, see Section 2 for a precise definition. As prominent examples of such valuations are mixed volumes with fixed convex bodies that have smooth boundary and positive curvature, it turns out that various inequalities between mixed volumes can be formulated in terms of the Alesker product or the Bernig–Fu convolution on \Val^{\infty}(\RR^{n}) . A notable example is the array of quadratic inequalities broadly generalizing the Alexandrov–Fenchel inequality discovered recently by Bernig, the author, and Wannerer [ 17 , 10 ] by proving the hard Lefschetz theorem and Hodge–Riemann relations for the algebra \Val^{\infty}(\RR^{n}) . For other results of this type see [ 18 , 16 , 4 ] . Motivated by these developments, we observe that the left-hand side of ( 5 ) is an instance of the mixed volume of rank p defined by the author and Wannerer [ 16 ] . Using that higher-rank mixed volumes appear as coefficients in the Alesker product of (the usual) mixed volumes, we finally show that the