TRAPPIST-1 d: Exo-Venus, Exo-Earth or Exo-Dead? Journal: ApJL
M.J. Way · 2025
Read TRAPPIST-1 d: Exo-Venus, Exo-Earth or Exo-Dead? Journal: ApJL by M.J. Way (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-00132.txt.
Introduction
Way, a solo author writing under initials in the record, models a small planet around the nearby star TRAPPIST-1 in a 2025 paper. The planet sits near the border between a Venus like world and an Earth like one. Recent work on its sibling planets raised doubt that it holds any thick atmosphere at all.
Assuming it does keep an atmosphere, the author ran three dimensional climate models with a moving ocean. The planet could sit in the habitable zone, but only within a narrow range of conditions. It could equally be a hot Venus like world, a dead airless one, or in transition between states. Such modeling helps observers tell these cases apart with future data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M.J. Way |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-00132
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
TRAPPIST-1 d: Exo-Venus, Exo-Earth or Exo-Dead? Journal: ApJL M.J. Way Abstract TRAPPIST-1 d is generally assumed to be at the boundary between a Venus-like world and an Earth-like world, although recently published works on TRAPPIST-1 b and c raise concerns that TRAPPIST-1 d may be similarly devoid of a substantial atmosphere. TRAPPIST-1 d is also relatively understudied in comparison with TRAPPIST-1 e. The latter has generally appeared to be within the habitable zone of most atmospheric modeling studies. Assuming that TRAPPIST-1 d still retains a substantial atmosphere, we demonstrate via a series of 3D general circulation model experiments using a dynamic ocean that the planet could reside within the habitable zone in a narrow parameter space. At the same time, it could also be an exo-Venus or exo-Dead-type world or in transition between between one of these. Studies like this can help distinguish between these types of worlds. I Introduction The TRAPPIST-1 system ( Gillon et al. 2017 ; Turbet et al. 2020 ; Ducrot et al. 2020 ; Bolmont et al. 2023 ; Agol et al. 2021 , e.g.) is one of the most exciting nearby planetary systems with seven transiting terrestrial planets. It promises to test our theories regarding terrestrial atmospheric evolution in M-dwarf systems, and it has already delivered surprising JWST observations of the two innermost planets ( Greene et al. 2023 ; Zieba et al. 2023 ) . TRAPPIST-1 b and c appear to lack substantial atmospheres, although the results for TRAPPIST-1 c remain under debate ( Lincowski et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Other systems appear to produce similar results for close-in planets, e.g. GJ 367b ( Zhang et al. 2024 ) and GL 486b Weiner Mansfield et al. 2024 . One of the key ingredients for traditional terrestrial planet habitability studies is whether the planet possesses surface water reservoirs. The TRAPPIST-1 system rocky planets may be amenable to substantial water delivery ( Raymond et al. 2006 ; Raymond et al. 2007 , e.g.) . In addition, there is no evidence of any large outer planets that may block water delivery ( Sabotta et al. 2021 ; Teske 2022 , e.g.) , although other studies show that outer planets may enhance the impact rates of asteroids for solar system terrestrial planets ( Horner & Jones 2008 , e.g.) . The water mass fraction of TRAPPIST-1 d remains difficult to constrain ( Agol et al. 2021 ; Unterborn et al. 2018 ; Quarles et al. 2017 ) alongside the amount of water that may have condensed out on the surface assuming a temperate climate. There are a number of studies that raise concerns about the ability of planets to retain surface water in TRAPPIST-1-type systems orbiting ultracool dwarf stars, where the magma ocean ( Moore et al. 2023 , e.g.) and atmospheric escape (due to a number of processes) play important roles ( Lammer et al. 2011 ; Bolmont et al. 2017 ; Airapetian et al. 2020 ; Fleming et al. 2020 ; Krissansen-Totton 2023 ; Gialluca et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Yet in order to be “habitable” a planet needs to condense water out on the surface at the end of the magma ocean phase. For TRAPPIST-1 d some models may not be favorable ( Hamano et al. 2015 ; Turbet et al. 2023 , e.g.) alongside that of Venus or Venus-like worlds ( Turbet et al. 2021 ) . TRAPPIST-1 d has an orbital period of \sim 4.05 Earth days ( Gillon et al. 2017 ; Agol et al. 2021 ) . Assuming that it is tidally locked, this puts the planet in a fast rotator regime ( Yang et al. 2014 ; Kopparapu et al. 2016 ; Way et al. 2018 , e.g.) . For TRAPPIST-1 d its Rossby number (Rossby radius of deformation divided by the planet’s radius) is \sim 1 putting it in the fast rotating regime, whereas values for simulations like those of Yang et al. 2019 are much greater than 1 putting them in the slow regime (day length > 32 Earth days). For slow rotators (e.g., < 32 Earth days; Yang et al. 2014 ; Way et al. 2018 ) the substellar cloud feedback may keep the planet cool even at quite high insolations, but that feedback is muted in TRAPPIST-1 d. Regardless, TRAPPIST-1 d’s insolation S0X \sim 1.115–1.143 S ⊕ ( Gillon et al. 2017 ; Turbet et al. 2020 ; Agol et al. 2021 ) places it near the boundary of the inner edge of the habitable zone in 1D studies ( Kopparapu et al. 2013 ; Kopparapu et al. 2014 ; Kopparapu et al. 2016 ; Lincowski et al. 2018 , e.g.) . Part of the lack of detailed studies of TRAPPIST-1 d’s hypothetical climate (in comparison with that of TRAPPIST-1 e) may be a misconception about its mass and the higher insolation originally published in Gillon et al. 2017 . While it is less massive than Earth (0.3–0.41 M ⊕ ; Gillon et al. 2017 ; Turbet et al. 2020 ; Agol et al. 2021 ), it is 3–4 times the mass of Mars (0.107 M ⊕ ) 1 1 1 https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/marsfact.html . Its mass places it just inside the collisional atmosphere side of the cosmic shoreline ( Zahnle & Catling 2017 ) . While TRAPPIST-1 e studies place it within the habitable zone ( Wolf 2017 ; Turbet et al. 2018 ; Lincowski et al. 2018 ; Lin et al. 2021 ; Krissansen-Totton 2023 , e.g.) recent 3D GCM studies find that TRAPPIST-1 d is likely an exo-Venus ( Wolf 2017 ; Turbet et al. 2018 ) , although Turbet et al. 2018 do state that “if TRAPPIST 1d is able somehow to sustain a thick, highly reflective water cloud cover near the substellar region, it could sustain surface liquid water global oceans.” However, as mentioned above, TRAPPIST-1 d is in the fast rotator regime of atmospheric dynamics; hence, such a substellar cloud deck needs to be tested. For example, Kopparapu et al. 2017 Table 1 for a 2600K stellar type with an orbital period of 4.07 (very close to TRAPPIST-1 d’s 4.05) they state that their model top H 2 O mixing ratio (1 mb) is “runaway, no water-loss limit.” This is also demonstrated in Figures 2, 3 and 4 from the same work. This is in contrast to the earlier work by Yang et al. 2013 who appear to have used the incorrect orbital period (60 days) in their baseline M-star (3400 K) simulations and used an older version of the NCAR model than Kopparapu et al. 2017 (the former using CAM3 and the latter CAM4; see Figure 2 in Kopparapu et al. 2017 ). A 60-day orbital period will place this particular planet in the slow rotator regime. Finally, in a 3D GCM study, Kopparapu et al. 2017 state that TRAPPIST-1 d “is likely in a runaway state” based on their analysis. A number of studies have examined effects such as tidal dissipation and resultant surface heating fluxes ( Barr et al. 2018 ; Makarov et al. 2018 ; Dobos et al. 2019 ; Bansal et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Barr et al. 2018 estimate modest tidal heating