A note on spontaneous symmetry breaking in the mean-field Bose gas
Andreas Deuchert, Phan Thành Nam, Marcin Napiórkowski · 2025
Read A note on spontaneous symmetry breaking in the mean-field Bose gas by Andreas Deuchert, Phan Thành Nam, Marcin Napiórkowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-19402.txt.
Introduction
Andreas Deuchert, Phan Thành Nam, and Marcin Napiórkowski prove a sharp link between condensation and symmetry breaking in a mean-field Bose gas, in a paper from 2025. The gas sits in a three-dimensional torus with weak pairwise interaction scaled by particle count. Temperatures are set at the condensation transition scale.
They show spontaneous breaking of the phase symmetry occurs exactly when Bose-Einstein condensation holds. Condensation here means the one-particle density matrix of the thermal state has one huge eigenvalue. The equivalence is an if-and-only-if result, so neither phenomenon can occur without the other in this regime. The proof clarifies a foundational point in quantum statistical physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andreas Deuchert, Phan Thành Nam, Marcin Napiórkowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-19402
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A note on spontaneous symmetry breaking in the mean-field Bose gas Andreas Deuchert, Phan Thành Nam, Marcin Napiórkowski Abstract We consider the homogeneous Bose gas in the three-dimensional unit torus, where N N particles interact via a two-body potential of the form N − 1 v ( x ) N^{-1}v(x) . The system is studied at inverse temperatures of order N − 2 / 3 N^{-2/3} , which corresponds to the temperature scale of the Bose–Einstein condensation phase transition. We show that spontaneous U ( 1 ) U(1) symmetry breaking occurs if and only if the system exhibits Bose–Einstein condensation in the sense that the one-particle density matrix of the Gibbs state has a macroscopic eigenvalue. 1 Introduction and main results 1.1 Spontaneous symmetry breaking and quasi-averages Spontaneous symmetry breaking plays a pivotal role in understanding complex phenomena across various domains of physics, from condensed matter systems to high-energy particle interactions. Generally, it refers to a situation when a symmetry of the Hamiltonian or Lagrangian of a system is not present in the state under consideration - usually a ground state or a thermal equilibrium state. In this note, we shall investigate symmetry breaking in a system of weakly interacting bosons. In non-relativistic quantum many-body systems, the associated symmetry is the U(1) symmetry corresponding to particle number conservation of the underlying many-body Hamiltonian (cf. ( 1.8 )). It is well-known in statistical mechanics that many phase transitions are accompanied by symmetry breaking. As has been shown in the seminal papers of Bose and Einstein [ 8 , 18 , 19 ] , the ideal (non-interacting) Bose gas undergoes the Bose–Einstein Condensation (BEC) phase transition, characterized by a macroscopic occupation of a single quantum state (cf. Sections 1.4 and 1.5 for a brief reminder). For interacting systems, BEC has been observed in alkali gases in experiments led by Ketterle [ 25 ] and by Cornell and Wieman [ 12 ] , but its theoretical understanding remains challenging. Mathematically, it has been shown to occur for simplified models, in particular in the so-called mean-field scaling. The main result of this paper shows that the BEC phase transition in the mean-field Bose gas is indeed equivalent to the breaking of the U(1) symmetry of the underlying many-body system. While the definition of Bose-Einstein condensation (cf. ( 1.16 )) is rather simple, a rigorous description of symmetry breaking is a bit more subtle. In order to explain it, let us focus on a translation-invariant system. In this case, the macroscopically occupied single particle quantum state in the condensed phase corresponds to the zero momentum mode, i.e. the expected number of particles with zero momentum \langle a^{*}_{0}a_{0}\rangle (cf. ( 1.5 ) and ( 1.6 ) for a definition of creation and annihilation operators) becomes proportional to the total number of particles in the system. This makes the zero momentum mode the most relevant one and, as suggested by Bogoliubov [ 5 ] , justifies to treat them classically by replacing the operators a_{0} and a_{0}^{*} by c -numbers and thus equating \langle a^{*}_{0}a_{0}\rangle and |\langle a_{0}\rangle|^{2} . As the latter quantity cannot be non-zero in any state that has a fixed number of particles (or more generally in any state that preserves the total number of particles), it serves as a marker of spontaneous symmetry breaking. In order to mathematically implement those ideas, Bogoliubov [ 6 , 7 ] designed a limiting procedure that nowadays goes under the name of Bogoliubov’s quasi averages and has found applications in various fields of physics. It consists of the following two steps. First, in order to make the expectation value of a_{0} possibly non-zero, one adds to the many-body Hamiltonian a perturbation \lambda\sqrt{V}(a_{0}^{*}+a_{0}) that breaks particle number conservation (here V is the volume of the system). Let us denote by \langle\cdot\rangle_{\lambda} the expectation value in such a perturbed state. One then considers the double limit \lim_{\lambda\to 0}\lim_{V\to\infty}\frac{|\langle a_{0}\rangle_{\lambda}|^{2}}{V} and says that a non-zero value means that the symmetry is broken in the system. We stress the order of limits, which means that one first takes the macroscopic limit and only later ’removes’ the symmetry breaking perturbation. Here, we also assume the macroscopic limit to be the thermodynamic limit , as originally considered by Bogoliubov. Note that the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality implies that \frac{|\langle a_{0}\rangle_{\lambda}|^{2}}{V}\leq\frac{\langle a^{*}_{0}a_{0}\rangle_{\lambda}}{V} and thus spontaneous symmetry breaking implies BEC in the sense of a macrosopic occupation of the zero momentum mode. Note, however, the dependence of the right-hand side on \lambda . In 2005 Lieb, Seiringer and Yngvason in [ 30 ] , and, independently, Sütő in [ 41 ] proved that in the limit V\to\infty there is equality in the above equation for almost every \lambda . Those works were inspired by the result of Ginibre [ 22 ] , which gave the first rigorous justification of the c -number substitution. In [ 30 ] the authors have also shown that if there is BEC in the usual sense, then there is spontaneous symmetry breaking, i.e. \lim_{V\to\infty}\frac{\langle a^{*}_{0}a_{0}\rangle_{\lambda=0}}{V}\leq\lim_{\lambda\to 0}\lim_{V\to\infty}\frac{|\langle a_{0}\rangle_{\lambda}|^{2}}{V}. (1.1) A different approach that uses operator algebraic tools and correlation inequalities can be found in [ 20 ] . See also [ 39 ] for a generalization to nonhomogeneous systems. Note that all these statements are conditional in the sense that proving BEC in the thermodynamic limit remains a major open problem in mathematical physics. While the problem in the thermodynamic limit remains open, one can ask the same question in other scaling regimes that are easier to handle. In the present paper, we are interested in the mean-field scaling, where N particles in the unit torus interact via an interaction potential of the form N^{-1}v(x-y) . This model corresponds to the physical situation of a weakly interacting gas, where the interaction energy per particle is proportional to the spectral gap of the one-body kinetic operator. The zero-temperature properties of this model are rather well understood: the ground state exhibits BEC [ 26 , 32 , 9 ] , while the excited states are well described by Bogoliubov theory [ 40 , 23 , 13 , 27 , 35 ] . We will focus on systems at positive temperatures that are comparable to the critical temperature of the BEC phase transition. In this case, an exhaustive description of the Gibbs state of the (translation-invariant) mean-field Bose gas has been given in [ 14 ] ; see also [ 17 , Section 1.6] for a discussion of the accuracy of Hartree theory in the trapped system. However, symmetry breaking in the spirit of (1.1) has not yet been explained in great detail, and fulfilling this task is the main purpose of our paper. The remaining part of the introduction will be devoted to a detailed description of the model and a precise formulation of the main results. Notation We write a\lesssim b to say that there exists a constant C>0 independent of the relevant parameters (for instance, the particle number or the inverse temperature) such that a\leq Cb holds. If a\lesssim b and b\lesssim a we write a\sim b , and a\simeq b means that the leading orders of a and b are equal in the limit considered. In case the constant