Impact of Nanoscopic Impurity Aggregates on Cavitation in Water

Marin Šako, Roland R. Netz, Matej Kanduč · 2025

Read Impact of Nanoscopic Impurity Aggregates on Cavitation in Water by Marin Šako, Roland R. Netz, Matej Kanduč (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-19039.txt.

Introduction

Marin Sako, Roland Netz, and Matej Kanduc study bubble formation in stretched water in a 2025 paper. Pure water should resist tearing far beyond what labs observe. That gap between theory and experiment has puzzled physicists for years. Tiny oil droplets, too small to see, are the suspects here.

Simulations joined classic nucleation theory to test the idea. Pure water in the model held up to very high tension. A single oil droplet only nanometers wide cut that limit sharply. The new limit matched values from careful experiments. Even highly purified water likely hides such droplets, the authors argue. Those traces thus cap the strength any real sample can show. The lesson reaches beyond water to nucleation at large. Nonpolar residues, however tiny, can govern when a metastable system breaks.

Catalog record

CREATORMarin Šako, Roland R. Netz, Matej Kanduč
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-19039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Impact of Nanoscopic Impurity Aggregates on Cavitation in Water Marin Šako, Roland R. Netz, Matej Kanduč Abstract The stability of water against cavitation under negative pressures is a phenomenon known for considerable discrepancies between theoretical predictions and experimental observations. Using a combination of molecular dynamics simulations and classical nucleation theory, we explore how nanoscopic hydrocarbon droplets influence cavitation in water. Our findings reveal that while a macroscopic volume of absolutely pure water withstands up to − - 120 MPa of tension, introducing a single nanoscopic oil droplet, merely a few nanometers in radius, brings this cavitation threshold to around − - 30 MPa, closely matching the values typically observed in highly controlled experiments. The unavoidable presence of nanoscopic hydrophobic impurities, even in highly purified water used in experiments, imposes a practical limit on achieving the theoretical tensile strength in realistic settings. More broadly, our study highlights the profound impact of nonpolar residues on nucleation phenomena and enhances our understanding of metastability in real-world systems. KEYWORDS: cavitation, bubble, droplet, water, oil, molecular dynamics simulation \captionsetup font=small † † affiliation: Jožef Stefan Institute, Jamova 39, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia † † affiliation: Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana, Jadranska 19, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia † † affiliation: Fachbereich Physik, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin 14195, Germany † † affiliation: Jožef Stefan Institute, Jamova 39, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia † † email: [email protected] 1. Introduction Liquids can be brought into a metastable state relative to their vapor in two ways: either by superheating them beyond their boiling temperature or by stretching them below their saturated vapor pressure. Eventually, they will revert to equilibrium through the nucleation of vapor bubbles, a phenomenon known as cavitation. The ability of a liquid to withstand mechanical tension and maintain negative pressures highlights the cohesive forces among its molecules. Water is a paradigmatic example, owing to its exceptional cohesion due to hydrogen bonds Caupin and Herbert (2006) . The phenomenon of negative pressures in liquids may seem counterintuitive at first, yet it commonly occurs in nature. A famous example is the sap in plants, reaching negative pressures as deep as - 10 MPa Stroock et al. (2014) , which helps it to ascent against gravity. Octopuses and squids utilize negative pressures in their suckers for effective adhesion Smith (1991) , whereas ferns exploit negative pressure for spore dispersal through a catapult-like mechanism Noblin et al. (2012) . In porous media, soil, and microfluidic capillaries, water can experience tension because of curved air–water interfaces or evaporation Wheeler and Stroock (2008) ; Pagay et al. (2014) ; Vincent et al. (2014) . When cavitation bubbles form under tension, they collapse violently when the tension is released, generating microjets and shock waves, which can damage nearby surfaces, causing erosion in turbomachinery or harm biological tissues Dular et al. (2004) ; Reuter et al. (2022) ; Adhikari et al. (2015) ; Peters et al. (2015) . Conversely, cavitation is the basis of lithotripsy, a medical procedure that uses acoustic shock waves to break down kidney stones and other calcifications within the body, the exact mechanism of which is still debated Coleman and Saunders (1989) ; Caupin and Herbert (2006) . The study of water under tension and cavitation, dating back to the 17th century Caupin and Herbert (2006) , has inspired researchers to understand not only the metastable phase diagram of water and its thermodynamic anomalies, but also shed light on the nature of first-order transitions as a fundamental phenomenon Caupin (2015) . Cavitation inception, a key process in this scope, is the stochastic nucleation of a vapor bubble. The interplay between the volume and surface energies of the bubble creates an energy barrier that has to be surmounted by the thermal fluctuations within the system. This concept forms the cornerstone of Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) Debenedetti (1996) , which suggests that water at room temperature should sustain negative pressures between about - 120 and - 160 MPa for extended periods of time Fisher (1948) ; Caupin (2005) ; Caupin and Herbert (2006) ; Caupin and Stroock (2013) ; Azouzi et al. (2013) . However, in less controlled experiments, cavitation in water occurs near saturated vapor pressure (around 2 kPa), preventing it from reaching a significantly metastable state. The prevalent understanding is that cavitation initiates at the weak points within a liquid, such as hydrophobic surfaces, impurities, and especially pre-existing bubbles Harvey et al. (1944) ; Atchley and Prosperetti (1989) ; Jones et al. (1999) , Indeed, purifying and degassing water enhances its sustainability against tension and allows it to withstand considerable negative pressures. However, even the most rigorous purification methods combined with acoustic cavitation or shock waves techniques that avoid solid boundaries seem to consistently reach a threshold of only about - 30 MPa Caupin and Herbert (2006) ; Caupin and Stroock (2013) ; Caupin (2015) ; Lauterborn and Mettin (2023) , which is by a factor of 4–5 below theoretically predicted values. A notable exception involves microsized inclusions in minerals, similar to the Berthelot tube method Zheng et al. (1991) ; Alvarenga et al. (1993) ; Azouzi et al. (2013) , where negative pressures up to - 140 MPa can be achieved, though the reasons for this are not fully understood. A prevailing hypothesis attributes the gap between theory and experiment to nanoscale nuclei suspended even in highly purified water, as achieving absolute purity in large liquid volumes is practically impossible Roger and Cabane (2012) ; Maali et al. (2017) ; Gao et al. (2021) ; Zhang et al. (2021) . Nevertheless, it remains uncertain whether such trace contaminants meaningfully contribute to the cavitation of macroscopic systems, given that their minute amounts may have a limited influence on the entire system. While testing this “contamination hypothesis” via experiment is 2. Results and discussions 2.1. Homogeneous cavitation in absolutely pure water CNT is foundational in the study of homogeneous cavitation, offering a framework to understand the transition from a metastable to a stable phase in liquids Caupin and Herbert (2006) ; Azouzi et al. (2013) ; Menzl et al. (2016) . CNT posits that cavitation inception occurs with the stochastic formation of a bubble within the bulk liquid, which occurs under substantial negative pressures. The free energy of an expanding spherical cavity of radius r under negative pressure p is expressed as G_{\textrm{w}}(r)=4\pi\gamma(r)r^{2}+\frac{4}{3}\pi pr^{3} (1) where the first term is associated with the free energy of creating the bubble interface and the second term to the work gained by performing the volume expansion against the ambient pressure. Achieving accurate quantitative agreement with molecular simulations requires considering the impact of interface curvature on surface tension, \gamma(r) , as highlighted before Menzl et al. (2016) ; Kanduč et al. (2020) . We describe the curvature-dependent surface tension as \gamma(r)=\gamma_{\mathrm{w}}(1+2\delta_{\mathrm{w}}/r) , where \gamma_{\mathrm{w}} is the surface tension of the flat water–vapor interface and \delta_{\mathrm{w}} the Tolman length. This expression represents the first-order Taylor expansion of Tolman’s original expression Tolman (1949) , which is applicable in scenarios of small curvatures ( r\gg|\delta_{\mathrm{w}}| ). Equation 1 neglects the effect of vapor inside the cavity, which is reasonable given that the typical cavitation pressures are much higher in magnitude (tens of MPa) than the saturated vapor pressure at room

Read the complete text