A Systematic Literature Review of Computer Science MOOCs for K-12 education

L.M. van der Lubbe, S.P. van Borkulo, J.T. Jeuring · 2025

Read A Systematic Literature Review of Computer Science MOOCs for K-12 education by L.M. van der Lubbe, S.P. van Borkulo, J.T. Jeuring (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18986.txt.

Introduction

Schools keep adding computer science to the timetable while trained teachers remain scarce, and a systematic review asks whether online courses can fill the gap. The reviewers gathered nineteen papers covering thirteen massive open online courses used with school-age learners between 2014 and 2024. Most courses taught only a slice of the curriculum, usually programming and computational thinking.

A classroom teacher still mattered, guiding and managing students as they worked through the material. Studies of these courses varied widely in aims and methods. The authors conclude the courses can carry real weight in school computing, provided teachers get training and fuller materials are built.

Catalog record

CREATORL.M. van der Lubbe, S.P. van Borkulo, J.T. Jeuring
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18986

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Systematic Literature Review of Computer Science MOOCs for K-12 education L.M. van der Lubbe, S.P. van Borkulo, J.T. Jeuring Abstract Computer science (CS) is increasingly becoming part of the curricula of K-12 education in different countries. However, there are few K-12 CS teachers, and tools to offer K-12 CS education are often limited. Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) might help to temporarily address these challenges, and enable more schools to offer CS education. The goal of this systematic review is to give an overview of how CS MOOCs have been used in K-12 education. Nineteen papers from 2014 to May 2024 were included, describing thirteen different MOOCs. This review summarizes the research performed with these MOOCs and discusses directions for future research. Our findings show that most CS MOOCs target only part of the CS curriculum. When using a MOOC, a classroom teacher has an important role in supporting and managing students as they work in the MOOC. Research evaluating MOOCs is diverse, both in aims and in methods. In conclusion, MOOCs can play a valuable role in K-12 CS education, although additional teacher training to support students might be required. Moreover, additional learning material is needed to cover the full curriculum, as most MOOCs focus on programming and computational thinking. K eywords MOOCs \cdot e-learning \cdot computer science \cdot education \cdot K-12 \cdot systematic review 1 Introduction The rapid pace of digital transformation is reshaping many aspects of our daily lives, influencing how we work, learn, and interact with the world around us [ 6 ] . In this evolving landscape, computational thinking (CT) has emerged as a crucial framework for navigating and harnessing these changes. CT refers to “the thought processes involved in formulating a problem and expressing its solution(s) in such a way that a computer – human or machine – can effectively carry [it] out" [ 68 ] . In today’s digital age, it is increasingly regarded as a fundamental skill, comparable to literacy and numeracy. Closely aligned with CT is computer science (CS), particularly programming, which equips individuals with the tools to understand and shape the world through technology. Recognizing the importance of these skills, many countries, including those in Europe, are incorporating CT and CS into their educational curricula [ 6 , 15 ] . However, this integration faces significant challenges, such as a shortage of adequately trained educators and insufficient teaching tools and resources [ 6 , 57 ] . This paper focuses on Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), which are an increasingly popular means to teach courses online to different audiences, although they mainly target adults. With the lack of CT and CS teachers and of tools and resources in secondary schools, maybe MOOCs can play a role in teaching CS, at least temporarily? We are aware of recent initiatives in this direction in the Netherlands (Co-Teach Informatica 1 1 1 www.//co-teach.nl/ [ 61 ] ), Belgium (eTeacher 2 2 2 www.eteacher.be [ 31 ] ), Slovenia (Project Tomo 3 3 3 www.projekt-tomo.si [ 41 ] ), Portugal (Ensico 4 4 4 https://ensico.pt ), and expect that in many other countries similar initiatives are set up. This review paper aims to give an answer to that question by giving an overview of the state-of-the-art of K-12 CS MOOCs. Koutsakas et al. [36] analysed trends in K-12 MOOCs. In their review, they studied 21 papers published between 2013 and March 2020. The majority of the papers found describe MOOCs for Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) courses, including CS but also for example chemistry or physics. They found that the best way to use a MOOC in a classroom setting is a blended approach. In this paper, we focus solely on K-12 CS MOOCs and closely related topics such as CT and information literacy. Our analysis centers on course organisation (e.g., the duration of the course and hosting platform), their content, and the underlying pedagogical frameworks, with particular attention to the role of teachers. By providing this information, we aim to offer valuable insights for teachers, curriculum designers, and MOOC developers, helping them better understand how MOOCs can be integrated into secondary education. Additionally, we are interested in the research that has been conducted to design or evaluate the described MOOCs. For this reason, we restrict our review to academic publications about MOOCs. Researchers and MOOC designers can use the resulting overview to reuse methods for their own work, as well as to compare their findings with those of previous studies. This paper is organised as follows. Section 2 describes K-12 CS education and different relevant terms used to describe K-12 CS education. Moreover, this section describes MOOCs and their different variants, and their role in K-12 education. Section 3 describes the methods we use for data collection and data analysis of our literature review. Section 4 describes the results of the literature review, which are discussed in Section 5 . Section 6 summarises the most important findings of this literature review, stressing their importance for future research. 2 Background 2.1 K-12 Computer Science Education Computer science includes subjects such as programming, algorithms, data structures, information processing, and computer and network design [ 60 ] . Computer science is sometimes also referred to as computing or informatics [ 6 ] . Another term related to computing is computational thinking [ 67 , 68 ] , which is a way of thinking that can be expressed in programming or coding, but also in unplugged situations. Computational thinking and CS are often closely related in education since learning CT skills is often achieved by learning CS [ 6 ] . The European Union has the ambition that all European citizens be educated in both digital literacy (how to use computers) and informatics (or computer science) [ 19 ] . While digital literacy is often integrated into educational curricula, teaching CS remains a challenge for many educators. Computing education at university level started many decades ago and has since expanded into K-12 education in many countries. The pace of this shift varies significantly by country [ 2 , 15 ] . In some non-European countries, computer science has yet to enter the high school curriculum, while others have already incorporated it in primary education. Integrating computing education into the compulsory curriculum faces several challenges, including the lack of adequately trained teachers and the lack of tools and resources [ 6 ] . CS university students often do not consider a teaching career due to factors such as low salaries and the perceived nature of the job [ 69 ] . To reduce the teacher shortage, in-service teachers from other subjects can be trained and supported to teach CS [ 18 , 61 , 51 ] . When designing computer science education for K-12, a frequently used strategy is to rely on the existing pedagogical approach and curriculum of higher education and adapt this for younger students, for example by using a programming language that is perceived to be easier or omitting complex topics [ 2 ] . However, the pedagogical strategies that work for undergraduates often do not work for high-school students. Armoni [2] recommends that instead of adapting existing programs, it is better to

Read the complete text