Order-Preserving outer automorphisms of free and surface groups
Jonathan Johnson and Khanh Le · 2025
Read Order-Preserving outer automorphisms of free and surface groups by Jonathan Johnson and Khanh Le (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18847.txt.
Introduction
Jonathan Johnson and Khanh Le classify order-preserving symmetries in a mathematics paper from two thousand twenty-five. Free groups and surface groups can carry bi-orders, total orders respected by multiplication on both sides. The question is which finite groups of outer automorphisms keep such an order intact.
The authors give a complete answer for non-abelian free groups and for bi-orderable surface groups. They add a fresh criterion for automorphisms coming from braid actions. With it, they build examples whose underlying permutation is a full cycle. That settles a question posed by Kin and Rolfsen, in the affirmative. The work ties group orderability to braid dynamics in a precise way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonathan Johnson and Khanh Le |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18847
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Order-Preserving outer automorphisms of free and surface groups Jonathan Johnson and Khanh Le Abstract . We give a complete classification of finite subgroups of outer automorphisms that preserve bi-orders on non-abelian free groups and bi-orderable surface groups. We also give another new criterion for an outer automorphism of F n F_{n} induced by the action of an n n -strand braid to preserve a bi-order on F n F_{n} in terms of the Burau representation of B n B_{n} . Using the new criterion, we produce examples of order-preserving braids whose underlying permutation is a full cycle, which answers in affirmative a question of Kin and Rolfsen. 1. Introduction A group G is bi-orderable if it admits a total order \prec that is invariant under both left and right multiplication. That is, if g\prec h in G , then fg\prec fh and gf\prec hf for any f\in G . We call this total order a bi-order on G . Alternatively, a bi-order on a group G can be given by specifying a subset P of G that satisfies the following properties: (1) G=P\sqcup\{1\}\sqcup P^{-1} , (2) P\cdot P\subset P , (3) gPg^{-1}\subset P for all g\in G . The set P determines a total order \prec on G by g\prec h\text{ if and only if }g^{-1}h\in P, and is called a positive cone of G . If the total order \prec is known only to be left-invariant then \prec is called a left-order on G . The group G is then said to be left-orderable. The theory of orderable groups has attracted recent attention due to their connections with low-dimensional topology in the context of the L-space conjecture which concerns left-orderability of the fundamental group of rational homology 3-spheres, see [ BGW13 , Juh15 ] . Bi-orderability of the fundamental group of 3-manifolds has also been considered since the formulation of the L-space conjecture. In particular, Boyer, Rolfsen and Wiest gave a classification of Seifert fibered spaces with bi-orderable fundamental groups [ BRW05 ] . Perron and Rolfsen give a sufficient criterion for the fundamental groups of a fibered 3-manifolds to be bi-orderable in terms of the monodromy of the fiber [ PR06 , PR03 ] . Continuing on the theme of studying bi-orderability of 3-manifold groups, Kin and Rolfsen initiated the study of bi-orderability of the complement of a braided link, which is the mapping torus of a homeomorphism of an n -punctured disk induced by a braid in B_{n} [ KR18 ] . These are natural examples of fibered 3-manifold groups whose monodromy satisfies a necessary condition by [ CR12 ] for the 3-manifold group to be bi-orderable. In their article, Kin and Rolfsen classified the complement of braided link with bi-orderable fundamental group among those with finite-order monodromy [ KR18 , Theorem 4.10] and gave more examples of ones with non-bi-orderable fundamental group. In this paper, we continue the investigation into bi-orderability of groups arising in low-dimensional topology by looking at mapping torus of free and surface groups. Many groups are known to be bi-orderable: torsion-free abelian groups [ Lev42 ] , free groups [ Mag35 ] and fundamental groups of closed surfaces except for the real projective plane and the Klein bottle [ RW01 ] . New examples of orderable groups can be constructed from known examples using group extensions. Before stating the construction, we observe that given a bi-orderable group G , the group \Out(G) acts on the set of all bi-orders of G , \BiO(G) , via: [\varphi]\cdot P=\varphi(P) where \varphi\in\Aut(G) and P a positive cone of a bi-order on G . The action is well-defined since positive cones of every bi-order of G is invariant under conjugation by G . We also recall that given any short exact sequence of groups, 1\to K\to G\xrightarrow{\pi}Q\to 1, we have an associated action \rho:Q\to\Out(K) given by \rho(q)(k)=gkg^{-1}\text{ where }\pi(g)=q for any q\in Q , k\in K . Now we state a well-known construction of a bi-orderable group using group extensions: Proposition 1.1 . Let G be an extension of two bi-orderable groups K and Q . In particular, we have the following short exact sequence of groups 1\to K\to G\to Q\to 1 where K and Q are bi-orderable groups. Let \rho:Q\to\Out(K) be the action associated to the short exact sequence. If there exists a bi-order P\in\BiO(K) such that \rho(Q) fixes P , then G is bi-orderable. Due to Proposition 1.1 , we have the following concept. Given a bi-orderable group K , a subgroup of \Out(K) is order-preserving if it fixes a bi-order in \BiO(K) . It is natural to ask Question 1.2 . Given a bi-orderable group G , which subgroups of \Out(G) are order-preserving? The first result in our paper is a complete characterization of order-preserving finite subgroups of \Out(G) when G is either a non-abelian free group or the fundamental group of a closed surface group except for the real projective plane and the Klein bottle. In [ BRW05 ] , the authors proved that all closed surfaces except for \mathbb{RP}^{2} and the Klein bottle are precisely the closed surfaces with bi-orderable fundamental groups. For convenience, we refer to the set of fundamental groups of closed surfaces, other than the real projective plane and the Klein bottle, as bi-orderable surface groups . Theorem 1.3 . Let G be either a finitely generated non-abelian free group or a bi-orderable surface group. Let us denote by \pi:\Aut(G)\to\Out(G) the canonical quotient map in the following short exact sequence: 1\to G\to\Aut(G)\to\Out(G)\to 1. Suppose that H\leq\Out(G) is a finite subgroup. Then H is order-preserving if and only if the full preimage \pi^{-1}(H) under \pi is torsion-free. Theorem 1.3 is a generalization of Kin and Rolfsen’s classification of order-preserving periodic braids [ KR18 , Theorem 4.10] . Khramtsov gave an algorithm that, given a free-by-finite group, the algorithm decomposes the group as the fundamental group of a finite graph of finite groups [ Khr95 , Theorem 1] . Using this algorithm and Theorem 1.3 , we have the following corollary: Corollary 1.4 . Let G be a finitely generated non-abelian free group. There exists an algorithm that: given any finite subgroup H of \Out(G) , the algorithm will out put YES if H is order-preserving and NO otherwise. We also remark that the method of proving Theorem 1.3 yields a construction that provides new examples of infinite-order order-preserving outer automorphism of finitely generated non-abelian free groups and bi-orderable surface groups. See Corollary 2.2 for the construction. The second result in our paper gives a new criterion for an infinite-order outer automorphism of a finitely generated free group to be order-preserving. To motivate this result, we recall a criterion which guarantees that an automorphism is order-preserving, due to Perron and Rolfsen [ PR03 , Theorem 2.6] . Let G be a rank- n free group. Each automorphism \varphi\in\Aut(G) induces a map in \varphi_{\mathrm{ab}}\in\GL_{n}(\mathbb{Z}) on the abelianization of G . Composing with the inclusion map \GL_{n}(\mathbb{Z})\subset\GL_{n}(\mathbb{C}) produces a representation \rho:\Aut(G)\to\GL_{n}(\mathbb{C}) . Perron and Rolfsen proves the following sufficient condition for an element in \Aut(G) to be order-preserving. Theorem 1.5 ( [ PR03 , Theorem 2.6] ) . If for \varphi\in\Aut(G) all the eigenvalues of \rho(\varphi)=\varphi_{\mathrm{ab}} are real and positive, then \varphi