Note on single-trace EYM amplitudes with MHV configuration
Zhirun Li, Yi-Jian Du · 2025
Read Note on single-trace EYM amplitudes with MHV configuration by Zhirun Li, Yi-Jian Du (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18832.txt.
Introduction
Li and Du generalize a formula for scattering amplitudes that mix gravity with a force like the strong interaction, in this 2025 note. The setting is a tidy corner where most particles share the same spin orientation. Earlier work covered amplitudes with one or two gravitons in a single trace.
In those cases, each graviton behaves like a pair of gluons traveling together. The new result extends that swap to the general single-trace case. Any tree-level amplitude of this kind can be rebuilt from pure gluon amplitudes. Each graviton is simply traded for its gluon pair. The authors present the formula as a compact tool for amplitude calculations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhirun Li, Yi-Jian Du |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18832
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Note on single-trace EYM amplitudes with MHV configuration Zhirun Li, Yi-Jian Du Abstract In the maximally-helicity-violating (MHV) configuration, tree-level single-trace Einstein-Yang-Mills (EYM) amplitude with one and two gravitons have been shown to satisfy a formula where each graviton splits into a pair of collinear gluons. In this paper, we extend this formula to more general cases. We provide a general formula which expresses tree-level single-trace MHV amplitudes in terms of pure gluon amplitudes, where each graviton turns into a pair of collinear gluons. 1 Introduction In four dimensional spacetime, tree-level single-trace maximally-helicity-violating (MHV) amplitudes of Einstein-Yang-Mills (EYM) theory have been shown to satisfy the Selivanov-Bern-De Freitas-Wong Selivanov:1997aq ; Selivanov:1997ts ; Bern:1999bx (SBDW) formula, which expresses the amplitude via a generating function. On another hand, Cachazo-He-Yuan (CHY) Cachazo:2013gna ; Cachazo:2013hca ; Cachazo:2013iea formula gives a general approach to EYM amplitudes, which is independent of the dimension of spacetime and the helicity configuration. In four dimensions, the CHY formula has been shown to provide a spanning forest formula (first proposed in gravity, along the line of Nguyen:2009jk , Hodges:2012ym and Feng:2012sy ) for the single-trace MHV amplitude Du:2016wkt , which was further proven to be equivalent with the SBDW formula Du:2016wkt and was generalized to double-trace MHV amplitudes Tian:2021dzf via the recursion expansion formula Fu:2017uzt ; Chiodaroli:2017ngp ; Teng:2017tbo ; Du:2017kpo ; Du:2017gnh . From another perspective, as pointed out in earlier literatures Stieberger:2009hq ; Chen:2010sr ; Stieberger:2014cea ; Stieberger:2015qja ; Stieberger:2015kia , each graviton in an EYM amplitude could be considered as a pair of collinear gluons which carry the same momentum and the same helicity. Particularly, inspired by the SBDW formula, Chen:2010sr pointed out that the single-trace MHV amplitude with one and two gravitons can be explicitly expressed in terms of the MHV amplitudes where each graviton splits into a pair of collinear gluons Chen:2010sr . This explicit formula of the single-trace MHV amplitudes was not extended into cases with an arbitrary number of gravitons yet. In this note, we take a small step forward in this direction: we provide a general formula for single-trace MHV amplitudes where each graviton splits into a pair of collinear gluons. When the number of gravitons is one or two, this formula turns back into the known results Chen:2010sr . We hope this approach may provide a new insight for the study of helicity amplitudes in EYM. The structure of this note is arranged as follows. In section 2 , a helpful review of spinor-helicity formalism and the SBDW formula is presented. We study the amplitude with three gravitons in section 3 and sketch the general proof in section 4 . Further discussions and conclusions are presented in section 5 . 2 Backgrounds In this section, we provide a brief review of the spinor-helicity formalism in four dimensions Xu:1986xb , as well as the SBDW Selivanov:1997aq ; Selivanov:1997ts ; Bern:1999bx formula and the spanning forest formula Du:2016wkt for single-trace EYM amplitudes. 2.1 Spinor-helicity formalism in four dimensions The momentum k^{\mu}_{i} of each on-shell massless particle i is expressed by two copies of Weyl spinors \lambda_{i}^{a}\widetilde{\lambda}_{i}^{\dot{a}} . We define the spinor products as \displaystyle\left\langle i,j\right\rangle\equiv\epsilon_{a{b}}\lambda_{i}^{a}{\lambda}_{j}^{{b}},~~~~~~~~~~\left[i,j\right]\equiv\epsilon_{\dot{a}\dot{b}}\widetilde{\lambda}_{i}^{\dot{a}}\widetilde{\lambda}_{j}^{\dot{b}}, (2.1) where \epsilon_{{a}{b}} and \epsilon_{\dot{a}\dot{b}} are totally antisymmetric tensors. Apparently, the spinor products are antisymmetric objects under the exchanging of the two spinors. With this expression, the Lorentz contraction of two momenta k^{\mu}_{a} and k^{\mu}_{b} reads: \displaystyle k_{a}\cdot k_{b}=\frac{1}{2}\left\langle a,b\right\rangle\left[b,a\right]. (2.2) More helpful properties in spinor-helicity formalsim are displayed as follows. • Momentum conservation for an n -point amplitude: \displaystyle\sum\limits_{\begin{subarray}{c}i\neq\,j,k\\ i=1\end{subarray}}^{n}\left[j,i\right]\left\langle i,k\right\rangle=0.~~~~ (2.3) • Schouten identity: \displaystyle\left\langle a,b\right\rangle\left\langle c,d\right\rangle=\left\langle a,c\right\rangle\left\langle b,d\right\rangle+\left\langle b,c\right\rangle\left\langle d,a\right\rangle,~~~\left[a,b\right]\left[c,d\right]=\left[a,c\right]\left[b,d\right]+\left[b,c\right]\left[d,a\right]. (2.4) • The eikonal identity resulted by Schouten identity \displaystyle\sum\limits_{i=j}^{k-1}\frac{\left\langle i,i+1\right\rangle}{\left\langle i,q\right\rangle\left\langle q,i+1\right\rangle}=\frac{\left\langle j,k\right\rangle}{\left\langle j,q\right\rangle\left\langle q,k\right\rangle}.~~~~~~~ (2.5) Finally, the n -gluon MHV amplitude A(1,...,n) at tree level satisfies the famous Parke-Taylor formula Parke:1986gb 1 1 1 In this work, we use \sim to neglect the coupling constant and an overall normalization factor. : \displaystyle A(1,...,n)\sim\frac{\langle ij\rangle^{4}}{\langle 12\rangle\langle 23\rangle\cdots\langle n1\rangle}, (2.6) where i , j denote the two negative-helicity gluons and other gluons are supposed to be positive-helicity ones. 2.2 SBDW formula and the spanning forest formula In EYM, there are two possible situations of the tree-level single-trace MHV amplitudes: the ( g^{-},g^{-} ) and ( h^{-},g^{-} ) configurations, which correspond to amplitudes with two negative-helicity gluons, and one negative-helicity gluon plus one negative-helicity graviton. In the following, we focus on the ( g^{-},g^{-} ) configuration. The ( h^{-},g^{-} ) can be studied similarly. The SBDW Selivanov:1997aq ; Selivanov:1997ts ; Bern:1999bx formula expresses the single trace ( g^{-}g^{-} )-MHV amplitude A(1,...,i,...,j,...,N|\mathrm{H}) in EYM as: A(1,...,i,...,j,...,N|\mathrm{H})\sim\frac{\langle ij\rangle^{4}}{\langle 12\rangle\langle 23\rangle\cdots\langle N1\rangle}S(i,j,\mathrm{H},\{1,...,N\}) (2.7) where 1 , …, N are gluons arranged in a fixed ordering, \mathrm{H}=\{n_{1},...,n_{M}\} are gravitons which are independent of color orderings. The negative-helicity gluons are supposed to be i and j . The S(i,j,\mathrm{H},\{1,...,N\}) factor is generated by an exponential generating function, particularly \displaystyle S(\mathrm{H};\{1,...,N\}) \displaystyle=\quantity(\prod\limits_{m\in\mathrm{H}}\frac{d}{da_{m}})\exp[\sum\limits_{n_{1}\in\mathrm{H}}a_{n_{1}}\sum\limits_{l\in\mathrm{G}}\psi_{ln_{1}}\exp[\sum\limits_{n_{2}\in\mathrm{H},n_{2}\neq n_{1}}a_{n_{2}}\psi_{n_{1}n_{2}}\exp(...)]]\Bigg|_{a_{m}=0}, (2.8) in which \psi_{ab}\equiv\frac{[ab]\langle a\xi\rangle\langle a\eta\rangle}{\langle ab\rangle\langle b\xi\rangle\langle b\eta\rangle} (2.9) where \xi , \eta are arbitrarily chosen reference spinors and \mathrm{G} is the gluon set. In this note, we set \xi=1 and \eta=N when studying the ( g^{-},g^{-} ) configuration. It was shown in Du:2016wkt that S(\mathrm{H};\mathrm{G}) could be expanded by spanning forest form. Particularly: S(\mathrm{H};\mathrm{G})=\sum\limits_{F\in\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{G}}(\mathrm{G}\cup\mathrm{H})}\quantity(\prod\limits_{ab\in E(F)}\psi_{ab}), (2.10) where we have summed over all possible forests F , where gluons and gravitons are considered as vertices, and the gluons are considered as the root set. Each edge ab is dressed by \psi_{ab} , and multiply all such edges in a given forest F together. In the case of ( h^{-},g^{-} ), the formulas ( 2.7 ) ( 2.8 ) and ( 2.10 ) are slightly changed Bern:1999bx ; Du:2016wkt ; Tian:2021dzf via (i). replacing i,j in ( 2.7 ) by the negative helicity graviton and the negative-helicity gluon, (ii). replacing the gravitons set H in ( 2.8 ) and ( 2.10 ) by the positive-helicity graviton set \mathrm{H}^{+} , while the root set is still the gluon set. (ii). introducing an extra minus (-1) . 3 Amplitudes with three gravitons In this section, we extend the study of one and two graviton single-trace MHV amplitudes Chen:2010sr , where each gravition is presented as a pair of collinear gluons, to the cases with an arbitrary number of gravitons. We demonstrate this by the example with three gravitons in the current section, and then provide a general formula in the next section. Figure 1: All possible topologies of spanning forests for the three-graviton example. The a , b and c refer to different gravitons. According to ( 2.7 ) and ( 2.10 ), the MHV amplitude with gluons 1 , …, N and three gravitons n_{1} , n_{2} , n_{3} is presented by \displaystyle A(1,...,N|n_{1},n_{2},n_{3})\sim\frac{\langle ij\rangle^{4}}{\langle 12\rangle\langle 23\rangle\cdots\langle N1\rangle}\,S_{3}, (3.1) where S_{3} is the abbreviation of the factor ( 2.10 ) with three gravitons. Specifically, S_{3} is expressed as \displaystyle S_{3}= \displaystyle\psi_{1}\psi_{2}\psi_{3}+\psi_{1}\psi_{2}(\psi_{13}+\psi_{23})+\psi_{1}\psi_{3}(\psi_{12}+\psi_{32})+\psi_{2}\psi_{3}(\psi_{21}+\psi_{31}) (3.2) \displaystyle+\psi_{1}(\psi_{12}\psi_{23}+\psi_{13}\psi_{32}+\psi_{12}\psi_{13})+\psi_{2}(\psi_{21}\psi_{13}+\psi_{23}\psi_{31}+\psi_{21}\psi_{23}) \displaystyle+\psi_{3}(\psi_{31}\psi_{12}+\psi_{32}\psi_{21}+\psi_{31}\psi_{32}), which are characterized by all possible spanning forests with structures Fig. 1 . Each \psi_{ab} ( a\neq b,a,b=1,2,3 ) in the above expression is defined by ( 2.9 ) and is associating to an edge in the graphs Fig. 1 , while the \psi_{i} ( i=1,2,3 ), associating to the graviton n_{i} , is defined by \psi_{i}\equiv\sum\limits_{l\in\mathrm{G}}\psi_{ln_{i}}. (3.3)