On the unexpected geometrical origin of the algebra of symmetries

O. Ramírez, Y. Bonder · 2025

Read On the unexpected geometrical origin of the algebra of symmetries by O. Ramírez, Y. Bonder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18829.txt.

Introduction

O Ramírez and Y Bonder explore a puzzle about the symmetries that run gravity and gauge theories. Their 2025 paper notes that two kinds of symmetry, gauge changes and coordinate changes, act on fields in unlike ways. Yet the algebra formed by mixing them closes neatly and does not depend on the fields.

The pair show that this algebra mirrors the Lie bracket of certain vector fields on the principal fiber bundle tied to the theory. That match gives the algebra a direct geometric meaning. They also show the algebra stays the same whatever connection is chosen. A closing example shows how one special connection, tied to Lorentz-Lie changes, simplifies the algebra when spacetime has its own symmetries.

Catalog record

CREATORO. Ramírez, Y. Bonder
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18829

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the unexpected geometrical origin of the algebra of symmetries O. Ramírez, Y. Bonder Abstract The fundamental symmetries in gravity and gauge theories, formulated using differential forms, are gauge transformations and diffeomorphisms. These symmetries act in distinct ways on different dynamical fields. Yet, the commutator of these symmetries forms a closed, field-independent algebra. This work uncovers a natural correspondence between this algebra and the Lie bracket of some vector fields on the principal fiber bundle associated with the physical theory, providing a geometric interpretation of the symmetry algebra. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the symmetry algebra is independent of the connection. Finally, we analyze an example illustrating how a specific connection, associated with Lorentz-Lie transformations, simplifies the symmetry algebra in the presence of spacetime Killing vector fields. 1 Introduction Fields play a central role in theoretical physics, serving as the fundamental mathematical objects in both classical [ 1 ] and quantum theories [ 2 ] . While quantum field theory has achieved remarkable success [ 3 ] , this paper emphasizes the classical aspects of field theories. To define any field theory, we need to provide its field content and the associated action functional. The action governs the dynamics of the fields and it also encodes the symmetries of the theory [ 4 , 5 ] . These symmetries are intimately related with conserved quantities, as shown by Noether’s theorems [ 6 ] . Gauge theories [ 7 ] , renowned for their success in describing the electromagnetism, weak, and strong interactions, are prime examples of field theories exhibiting a symmetry. In this case the symmetry is associated with Lie groups. On the other hand, general relativity in its conventional formalism [ 8 ] , describes spacetime as a pseudo-Riemannian manifold where the fundamental field is the metric tensor. In this case the symmetry of general relativity is its invariance under diffeomorphisms. In 1922, Cartan extended the metric formalism by introducing an independent connection [ 9 ] , triggering the study of numerous alternative gravity theories [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Furthermore, gravity theories can be reformulated using differential forms associated with an internal Lie group, such as the Lorentz group. This approach is referred to as the first-order formalism [ 13 ] and it is particularly useful when the connection is an independent dynamical field. This paper examines the interplay of symmetries in gauge and gravity theories within the first-order formalism. These theories involve two distinct types of fields: regular fields (algebra-valued p -forms) and local connections ( 1 -forms with specific gauge transformation properties). Notably, while these fields transform differently under gauge symmetries, they share an intriguing feature: the symmetry algebra is the same regardless of the field type we act upon. This observation suggests that there exists an underlying geometrical structure. Uncovering such a structure is the main goal of this paper. The paper is organized as follows. In section 2 , we introduce some basic notions within the first-order formalism. Section 3 is the core of the paper and it presents two derivations of the symmetry algebra: the conventional derivation and a new, geometric method that uncovers a connection to Lie brackets of vector fields on principal fiber bundles. Then, in section 4 , we show that the structure we find is independent of the connection and we present an example. The conclusions are summarized in Section 5 . For completeness, we include basic definitions in A , technical identities in B , and key results on fiber bundles in C . Finally, we describe the notation used throughout the paper. Differential forms are employed extensively, omitting spacetime indices. We use the wedge product, exterior derivative, interior derivative, and covariant exterior derivative, we introduce these operations in A . Greek indices \mu,\nu,\rho,\ldots correspond to indexes in the Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} , which is associated with the Lie group G . Summation is implied for any pair of repeated indices. Moreover, we assume that all the objects we consider are smooth. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Action Our starting point is the construction of an action functional for generic theories. We work in N spacetime dimensions. In addition, we consider a collection of p -forms with a algebra index \Psi^{\mu} , which represent general matter fields and/or vielbeins. We employ vielbeins to describe gravity, which are more commonly known as tetrads in the specific case of four-dimensional spacetime [ 8 , chapter 3.4b] . We also work with an arbitrary collection of local connection/gauge fields, with an arbitrary internal Lie group; we denote the local connection fields (or simply gauge fields) by \mathcal{A^{\mu}_{\ \nu}} . Note that, to simplify the notation, we omit the index specifying which field/connection within the collection is used, as done in [ 14 ] . Note that this formalism is extremely general in that it can describe a wide range of theories. To study the dynamics and symmetries of a theory, we need to provide an action. By definition, the action is a spacetime integral of an N -form called the Lagrangian, L . In turn, L , which depends on all relevant fields, must transform as a scalar under gauge transformations. To implement this condition, we assume that L has no free algebra indexes and that it only depends on the local connections through its curvature, F^{\mu}_{\ \nu} , and the covariant exterior derivative of \Psi^{\mu} , \text{D}\Psi^{\mu} ; these objects are defined in A . With these considerations, a generic action takes the form S[\Psi^{\mu},\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu}]=\int\ L[\Psi^{\mu},\text{D}\Psi^{\mu},F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}]. (1) Observe that we do not explicitly consider higher-derivative terms in our analysis. Naively, one might argue that such terms are unnecessary since \text{D}^{2}\Psi^{\mu}=F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}\Psi^{\nu} and \text{D}F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}=0 (see equation ( 62 )). To incorporate higher-order derivatives into the equations of motion, we can employ a Hodge star map [ 15 ] , as argued in the context of the Lovelock theorem [ 16 ] . The Hodge star map, in turn, necessitates the introduction of a (background or dynamical) spacetime metric. In this work, we do not explicitly include such higher-order theories. Nonetheless, their incorporation into our framework is straightforward. We can express the variation of S , as given in ( 1 ), as \displaystyle\delta S \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int\left[\delta\Psi^{\mu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial\Psi^{\mu}}+\delta\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}}+\delta F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}}\right] (2) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int\left\{\delta\Psi^{\mu}\wedge\left[\frac{\partial L}{\partial\Psi^{\mu}}-(-1)^{p}\text{D}\left(\frac{\partial L}{\partial\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}}\right)\right]\right. \displaystyle\left.+\delta\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu}\wedge\left[\Psi^{\nu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}}+\text{D}\left(\frac{\partial L}{\partial F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}}\right)\right]\right\} \displaystyle+\int\text{d}\left(\delta\Psi^{\mu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}}+\delta\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu}\wedge\frac{\partial L}{\partial F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}}\right), (3) where we use \delta F^{\mu}_{\ \nu}=\text{D}\delta\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu} and \delta\text{D}\Psi^{\mu}=\text{D}\delta\Psi^{\mu}+\delta\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu}\wedge\Psi^{\nu} , and the (graded) Leibniz rule for D . We can read off the equations of motion directly from equation ( 3 ). However, these equations are not required for the analysis that follows. Instead, we shift our focus to the symmetries of the theory. 2.2 Symmetries An infinitesimal transformation of the fields, \delta\Psi^{\mu} and \delta\mathcal{A}^{\mu}_{\ \nu} , is a symmetry of the theory if, when inserted into ( 3 ) produces {\delta}S=0 1 1 1 A transformation is a pseudosymmetry if there exists a form B of co-dimension 1 such that {\delta}S=\int\text{d}B ; since the distinction between symmetries and pseudosymmetries is irrelevant for this study, we ignore this distinction. . For instance, in a gauge theory, gauge transformations are considered symmetries of the theory. Moreover, in

Read the complete text