Forcing Axioms for Proper Posets Preserving a Topological Property: Consistency Results
Thomas Gilton · 2025
Read Forcing Axioms for Proper Posets Preserving a Topological Property: Consistency Results by Thomas Gilton (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18710.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Gilton, writing solo in 2025, introduces two new forcing axioms in set theory. Forcing axioms are souped-up versions of the Baire category idea: they promise that many dense open sets can be met at once, letting mathematicians build objects with delicate properties.
Gilton's axioms concern building blocks, called proper posets, that preserve two qualities of spaces: being Lindelöf and being countably tight. The paper proves the axioms are consistent, meaning they can hold without contradiction, using Neeman's side-conditions iteration method. The heavy lifting is technical, but the payoff is practical for set theorists: new tools whose uses Gilton saves for a sequel. Consistency proofs like these mark out which mathematical worlds are possible.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas Gilton |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18710
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Forcing Axioms for Proper Posets Preserving a Topological Property: Consistency Results Thomas Gilton Abstract . Forcing axioms are generalizations of Baire category principles that allow one to intersect more dense open sets and to do so in a wider variety of circumstances. In this paper we introduce two new forcing axioms related to posets which preserve topological properties of various spaces, specifically the properties of Lindelöf and countably tight. The focus in this paper is on using Neeman’s side conditions iteration schema ( [ 20 ] ) to prove the consistency of these two forcing axioms. In later work, we will discuss applications of these forcing axioms in more detail. 1. Introduction In a typical Baire category argument, one constructs an object of interest (say, an everywhere continuous, nowhere differentiable function) by refining approximations (dense open sets) and using features of the topology (say, being a compact metric space) to ensure that the dense sets “hone in” on the desired object (i.e., that any countably-many have a non-empty intersection). This is in contrast to constructions where one writes down an explicit formula for the object under consideration (say, the formula for the sawtooth function). Forcing axioms generalize Baire category arguments by allowing the intersection of more (at least \aleph_{1} -many) dense open sets and under a wider variety of circumstances, namely, for posets with various desirable features. Martin’s Axiom was the first of these. \mathsf{MA}(\kappa) asserts that if \mathbb{P} is a poset with the countable chain condition (c.c.c.) and if \left<D_{\alpha}:\alpha<\kappa\right> is a sequence of dense subsets of \mathbb{P} , then there is a filter G\subset\mathbb{P} so that for all \alpha<\kappa , G\cap D_{\alpha}\neq\emptyset . As another example, the Proper Forcing Axiom, abbreviated \mathsf{PFA} , is a substantial strengthening of Martin’s Axiom. It asserts that if \mathbb{P} is a proper poset (we will review this definition later) and if \left<D_{\alpha}:\alpha<\omega_{1}\right> is a sequence of \omega_{1} -many dense subsets of \mathbb{P} , then there is a filter G\subset\mathbb{P} so that for all \alpha<\omega_{1} , D_{\alpha}\cap G\neq\emptyset . Models satisfying forcing axioms are normally obtained by reaching a closure point in a reasonably well-behaved iteration of forcings. Accordingly, constructing such a model involves at least the following two ingredients: (1) the appropriate notion of a “closure point” and (2) an iteration theorem, showing that a desirable property of posets is preserved under a specific kind of iteration. For example, with Martin’s Axiom, one only has to deal with c.c.c. posets of cardinality below the targeted value of the continuum. Thus any regular cardinal \kappa\geq\omega_{2} can act as a closure point. Moreover, a finite-support iteration of c.c.c. posets is still c.c.c. – the classic result of Solovay and Tennenbaum [ 24 ] – giving us the desired iteration theorem. By contrast, in the case of \mathsf{PFA} , one needs a large cardinal (all known proofs to date involve a supercompact) in order to reach the right closure point. The relevant iteration theorem says that the property of being proper is preserved under countable support iterations ( [ 23 ] ). A recent development is Neeman’s proof ( [ 20 ] ) of the consistency of \mathsf{PFA} using a forcing that has finite supports. This gives additional flexibility in constructing models of forcing axioms. A condition in Neeman’s forcing includes two components. The first component, known as the working part , is a finite support function analogous to a condition in a traditional iteration. The second component is a finite, \in -increasing sequence of models called side conditions . The two components are related by requiring the outputs of the working part to be (forced to be) generic conditions for plenty of the models in the side condition. This interaction between the two parts of a condition allows Neeman to argue that the entire poset is proper, and hence preserves \omega_{1} . For other examples of such “side conditions iteration theorems” see [ 1 ] and [ 9 ] . The idea of using side conditions in order to help argue for properness goes back to Todorc̆ević (see [ 25 ] and later expanded to include preservation of \omega_{1} and \omega_{2} in [ 26 ] ). The idea is remarkably fecund: by introducing models themselves into the conditions in a forcing, one can place natural constraints on how the models interact with the other components of a condition and thereby more smoothly argue for properness. Some other highlights include the following: [ 15 ] , [ 6 ] , [ 19 ] , [ 8 ] , and [ 16 ] , among many others. In this work, we introduce two forcing axioms for proper posets preserving some topological property \Phi of a given space X , specifically, Lindelöf spaces as well as countably tight spaces. The models will be constructed using Neeman’s finite-support method. We view the situation as analogous to the results in [ 27 ] and [ 17 ] , where those authors focus on proper posets preserving some noteworty feature of a tree on \omega_{1} . More specifically, we define forcing axioms of the form \mathsf{PFA}_{\Phi}(X) , where X is a topological space satisfying the topological property \Phi . Such an axiom asserts that if \mathbb{P} is a proper poset that preserves \Phi of X and if \left<D_{\alpha}:\alpha<\omega_{1}\right> is a sequence of dense subsets of \mathbb{P} , then we can find a filter meeting each D_{\alpha} . In the cases where \Phi equals (a) countably tight or (b) Lindelöf, and where X is a space of size less than a given supercompact cardinal, we provide proofs of the consistency of these axioms: see Theorems 7.3 and 8.3 . Note that in certain trivial cases (say, when X is at most countably infinite), the axiom \mathsf{PFA}_{\Phi}(X) is the same as \mathsf{PFA} . However, the question of the consequences of \mathsf{PFA}_{\Phi}(X) for non-trivial X is much more interesting. We will discuss the “spectrum of consequences” question in further work. The preservation of topological properties under various forcings has been an active area of research. A significant discovery is the fact that an \omega_{1} -closed forcing needn’t preserve the Lindelöf property in general ( [ 21 ] ). However, Dow showed that if one first adds \omega_{1} -many Cohen reals, and then forces with a poset which is \omega_{1} -closed in the extension , then such a two-step poset preserves the property of being countably tight ( [ 3 ] ) and the Lindelöf property ( [ 2 ] ). Iwasa ( [ 11 ] ) later studied the preservation of covering properties under Cohen forcing, and Kada ( [ 13 ] ) studied the preservation of covering properties under a more general type of forcing (so-called “weakly endowed”). The present author, together with Holshouser ( [ 7 ] ), generalized Dow’s results by showing that strongly proper forcings 1 1 1 We worked with posets that are strongly proper for “stationarily-many” countable elementary submodels; this is a strictly weaker notion than being strongly proper for a club of countable elementary submodels. The latter is typically taken to be the definition of a “strongly proper” poset. preserve a number of covering properties, including strategic versions, as well as countable tightness. Marun ( [