Automating Physics-Based Reasoning for SysML Model Validation

Candice Chambers, Summer Mueller, Parth Ganeriwala, Chiradeep Sen, Siddhartha Bhattacharyya · 2025

Read Automating Physics-Based Reasoning for SysML Model Validation by Candice Chambers, Summer Mueller, Parth Ganeriwala, Chiradeep Sen, Siddhartha Bhattacharyya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18514.txt.

Introduction

Candice Chambers and four co-authors add physics-based reasoning to the checking of SysML system models. Formal models let engineers verify designs early, and current tools check information flow, interactions, and consistency well. They rarely reason about whether modeled behavior obeys physical principles, a real gap for electromechanical systems. The approach joins function representation research with physics-based verification techniques.

Four case studies, a coffeemaker, vacuum cleaner, hairdryer, and wired speaker, show the method at work. Checks split into structural reasoning on block diagrams and functional reasoning on activity diagrams. The authors aim to catch behavior errors that pure consistency checks would miss.

Catalog record

CREATORCandice Chambers, Summer Mueller, Parth Ganeriwala, Chiradeep Sen, Siddhartha Bhattacharyya
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18514

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Automating Physics-Based Reasoning for SysML Model Validation Candice Chambers, Summer Mueller, Parth Ganeriwala, Chiradeep Sen, Siddhartha Bhattacharyya Abstract System and software design benefits greatly from formal modeling, allowing for automated analysis and verification early in the design phase. Current methods excel at checking information flow and component interactions, ensuring consistency, and identifying dependencies within Systems Modeling Language (SysML) models. However, these approaches often lack the capability to perform physics-based reasoning about a system’s behavior represented in SysML models, particularly in the electromechanical domain. This significant gap critically hinders the ability to automatically and effectively verify the correctness and consistency of the model’s behavior against well-established underlying physical principles. Therefore, this paper presents an approach that leverages existing research on function representation, including formal languages, graphical representations, and reasoning algorithms, and integrates them with physics-based verification techniques. Four case studies (coffeemaker, vacuum cleaner, hairdryer, and wired speaker) are inspected to illustrate the model’s practicality and effectiveness in performing physics-based reasoning on systems modeled in SysML. This automated physics-based reasoning is broken into two main categories: (i) structural, which is performed on BDD and IBD, and (ii) functional, which is then performed on activity diagrams. This work advances the field of automated reasoning by providing a framework for verifying structural and functional correctness and consistency with physical laws within SysML models. I Introduction Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) with SysML is gaining traction for designing complex systems [ 1 ] . MBSE emphasizes the need for developing analytical models early in the design phase to enable automated reasoning. This has led to the creation of structured and formal method-based approaches. For example, safety-critical industries such as aerospace and defense companies have been designing and developing model-based approaches with models developed in Architecture Analysis and Design Language (AADL) [ 2 , 3 ] and SysML [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] to provide artifacts generated from the design phase itself. Similarly, model-based approaches have been developed for the modeling and analysis of specifications in cybersecurity [ 7 ] [ 8 ] . Architecture modeling and analysis enables graphical and formal representation of system components, interactions, and workflows, allowing engineers to evaluate design consistency, functional dependencies, model verification and validation early in development [ 9 ] . However, ensuring these models’ validity, especially regarding fundamental physical laws, remains challenging [ 10 ] . Traditional SysML validation techniques primarily address logical and structural aspects, like component interactions and information flow consistency [ 11 ] . While effective for identifying flaws in component dependencies or data flows, these methods often fall short in enforcing physics-based constraints [ 12 ] . Consequently, SysML models may appear correct in terms of connectivity and structure but still deviate from real-world physical principles—such as conservation of energy or balance laws of transport—which are critical in domains like electromechanical systems. To address this limitation, an automated approach was proposed to embed physics-based reasoning within SysML model validation, bridging the gap between functional model correctness and adherence to physical laws. Our method integrates formal function representation, graphical analysis, and reasoning algorithms, enabling SysML models to be validated not only for logical consistency but also for physical validity. This approach extends formalism in functional representations from Ganeriwala et al. [ 10 ] . Specifically, our approach categorizes automated reasoning into two main aspects: (i) structural reasoning, applied to SysML’s Block Definition Diagrams (BDD) and Internal Block Diagrams (IBD), and (ii) functional reasoning, applied to Activity Diagrams representing dynamic workflows. By automating physics-based reasoning in this way, the framework facilitates comprehensive verification of a system’s structural and functional alignment with physical laws. Four case studies were examined across various domains, including electromechanical and energy systems, to demonstrate the practicality and effectiveness of this approach. These case studies illustrate how automated physics-based reasoning can detect inconsistencies that might be missed by conventional SysML validation techniques, enhancing model reliability and reducing the risk of costly redesigns later in the development process. In section II related work is discussed, with discussion on the representation of structure and functions in systems modeling in section III . In section IV , the automated reasoner defines and implements various inspections. The algorithmic design of automated functions reasoner is explained in section V . Then, in section VI , the automated reasoner performs the proposed validation on four use cases of electromechanical systems (coffeemaker, hair dryer, vacuum cleaner, and wired speaker) with the conclusion in section VII . II Review of Related Works Mahani et al. present an automatic approach for verifying finite state machines (FSM) modeled in SysML using the model checking tool New Symbolic Model Verifier (NuSMV) for a vehicular system [ 13 ] . NuSMV is a state-of-the-art model-checking tool developed at Carnegie Mellon University [ 14 ] . Model checking is a well-known formal verification technique that rigorously proves the correctness of a system based on its design requirements. This work is built using Cameo System Modeler (CSM) [ 15 ] . Therefore, this work installed a Cameo plugin that transforms the SysML FSM into NuSMV and replays its verifications in the Cameo environment as an executable SysML State Machine. This greatly assists designs in extracting all verification errors in the FSM and mitigating them promptly. Conversely, Zhu et al. proposed an approach that uses MBSE to model an avionic system and then maps this formal framework to capture the functional requirements to support the ARP4754A guidelines [ 16 ] . According to their proposed methodology, the black box operational scenario is modeled using SysML Sequence Diagrams; the functional scenario and chains are modeled using SysML Activity diagrams. Therefore, functional interface requirements can be captured from there. Ultimately, the top-level functional chains model is simulated to validate continuous functional chains against operational scenarios. Similarly, Zhang et al. proposed an approach that bridges the gap of traditional MBSE’s inability to integrate domain-specific simulation tools [ 9 ] . Domain-specific tools aid with removing ambiguities, inconsistencies, and challenges in the early design stage. Therefore, incorporating a descriptive system model with detailed domain-specific simulations allows for accurate design analysis. This approach lets designers validate the system’s functional and non-functional requirements early in the design life cycle. Yildirim et al. propose using the Enhanced Sequence Diagram (ESD) to improve the functional analysis of complex, multi-disciplinary systems [ 17 ] . This effort focused on interconnecting sequence diagrams from various use cases using parameters. The ESD framework is demonstrated using an electric hybrid bicycle case study. Through these scenarios, the ESD method proves effective for capturing and analyzing functional requirements, supporting rigorous functional modeling early in the design process, and enabling systems architecture development. Mao et al. present an algorithmic approach to perform physics-based reasoning for the functional decomposition of engineered systems [ 18 ] . Functional decomposition is an imperative step in the early system engineering and design phase based on its components or subassembles functions. Typically, functional decomposition is done manually; however, this work proposed a three-part algorithm that has been validated to decompose black box models. In conjunction with topological reasoning, these three sections are used to synthesize and assemble the function structure graph. Currently, there are no automated physics-based reasoners for validating functional and non-functional systems modeled in

Read the complete text