Hawking’s singularity theorem for Lipschitz Lorentzian metrics

Matteo Calisti, Melanie Graf, Eduardo Hafemann · 2025

Read Hawking’s singularity theorem for Lipschitz Lorentzian metrics by Matteo Calisti, Melanie Graf, Eduardo Hafemann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18450.txt.

Introduction

Matteo Calisti and co-authors proved in 2025 that Hawking's famous singularity theorem survives when spacetime is less smooth than textbooks assume. The theorem says gravity forces some paths to end, signaling a singularity, but its proof needs calculus on a tidy metric. Realistic models may only be Lipschitz, with kinks where derivatives fail.

The team bounded the curvature of smoothed versions of such spacetimes and replaced the classic focusing argument with a volume estimate that tolerates kinks. Singularities thus appear even in rougher universes, widening the theorem's reach to messier, more physical settings.

Catalog record

CREATORMatteo Calisti, Melanie Graf, Eduardo Hafemann
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE100 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18450

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hawking’s singularity theorem for Lipschitz Lorentzian metrics Thanks: [email protected] , Faculty of Mathematics, University of Vienna, Oskar-Morgenstern-Platz 1, 1090 Wien, Austria. Thanks: [email protected] , Faculty of Mathematics, University of Vienna, Oskar-Morgenstern-Platz 1, 1090 Wien, Austria. Matteo Calisti, Melanie Graf, Eduardo Hafemann Abstract We prove Hawking’s singularity theorem for spacetime metrics of local Lipschitz regularity. The proof rests on (1) new estimates for the Ricci curvature of regularising smooth metrics that are based upon a quite general Friedrichs-type lemma and (2) the replacement of the usual focusing techniques for timelike geodesics—which in the absence of a classical ODE-theory for the initial value problem are no longer available—by a worldvolume estimate based on a segment-type inequality that allows one to control the volume of the set of points in a spacelike surface that possess long maximisers. MSC2020: 83C75; 53C50, 46T30 Keywords: Singularity theorems, low regularity, regularisation, causality theory 1 Introduction The singularity theorems form an important body of results in Lorentzian differential geometry that firmly establish the occurrence of spacetime singularities as a generic feature of General Relativity (GR). More precisely they assert causal geodesic incompleteness under different sets of physically reasonable conditions like those associated with complete gravitational collapse [ 50 ] or an expanding universe [ 27 ] . Naturally these results, which appeared roughly in the second half of the 1960-ies, were formulated for smooth spacetimes. However, already Hawking and Ellis in their classic [ 28 ] discussed the issue of regularity: A lack of low-regularity versions of the theorems, that is for spacetime metrics g below the C^{2} -class, would undermine their physical significance. Indeed, then incompleteness and hence a spacetime singularity in the sense of the standard definition (see e.g. [ 15 , p. 10] and [ 28 , Sec. 8.1] for a discussion) could be avoided by a drop in regularity of g : If, for example, g were in C^{1,1} , then via the field equations there would be a finite jump in the matter variables, which hardly could be termed ‘singular’ on physical grounds. Therefore [ 28 , Sec. 8.4] contains an in-depth discussion of these issues in which the authors argue for a C^{1,1} -version of Hawking’s theorem [ 28 , Sec. 8.2, Thm. 4] and express their expectation that also all the other classical theorems would extend to this regularity. Accepting this for the moment one may observe that given these results, the alternative to incompleteness would now be locally unbounded curvature. This, however, still might be manageable as long as one can make sense of the field equations, which, in particular, is possible if g is locally Lipschitz continuous, i.e., g\in C^{0,1} , as again highlighted in [ 28 , Sec. 8.4] . In particular, this includes very prominent classes of solutions like impulsive gravitational waves (e.g. [ 51 ] , [ 25 , Ch. 20] , [ 52 ] ), thin shells and many matched spacetimes (e.g. [ 29 , 32 , 42 ] ) which all exhibit a \delta -function like curvature concentrated on a hypersurface. This is precisely the regularity class we deal with in this work, where we extend the validity of the Hawking singularity theorem to spacetime metrics g\in C^{0,1} . While the singularity theorems’ regularity issues have been duly addressed throughout the decades, see e.g. [ 56 , Sec. 6.2] , real progress only has been made rather recently. By extending Lorentzian causality theory (mainly) to continuous spacetime metrics [ 14 , 16 , 45 , 53 , 37 ] and to even more general settings [ 46 , 36 ] on the one hand, and by sharpening the analytic tool of approximation via convolution on the other, the classical theorems could be proven for C^{1,1} -metrics [ 38 , 39 , 21 ] and later also for g\in C^{1} [ 20 , 55 , 35 ] . Here we take this endeavour one decisive step further, namely to g\in C^{0,1} . Let us briefly address the added difficulties we have to deal with in this regularity. While for C^{1} -metrics the initial value problem for the geodesic equation is still solvable, albeit not uniquely so, we here face the problem that its right hand side is merely locally bounded. This forces us to work with maximising curves rather than with solutions to the ODE and so the ODE-techniques decisively used in the C^{1} -results [ 20 , Sec. 2] to approximate the geodesics of the rough metric by geodesics of approximating metrics are no longer at our disposal. This forces us to significantly modify the analytical core of the proof, which provides the focusing of geodesics under curvature bounds. While we still rely on a regularisation scheme that allows us to exploit the distributional strong energy condition, we will then apply the newly developed worldvolume estimates of [ 22 ] to the smooth regularising metrics. This will allow us to control (the volume of) the set of points on a Cauchy surface that possess long maximisers, but on the other hand forces us to sharpen our estimates on regularised curvature. Indeed, exploiting Friedrichs lemma-type arguments we provide new L^{p} -estimates on the Ricci curvature for Lipschitz metrics and their regularisation, which constitute the main analytical advance of our work. Moreover, we also have to deal with the ‘initial condition’ of the theorem, i.e., a bound on the mean curvature of a spacelike hypersurface. We extend the standard condition to Lipschitz regularity by a smearing out of the hypersurface. Finally, let us address the potential extensions of our methods to the other singularity theorems within Lipschitz regularity. In the Penrose case, where one is concerned with null geodesics emanating from a trapped surface, one would have to replace the usual focusing estimates by a null version of the segment-type inequality. While this seems feasible in principle, it cannot be expected to be a simple variation of the timelike analysis of [ 22 ] . Moreover, the very notion of a trapped surface would have to be adapted in a way similar to the smearing out of the (Cauchy-) hypersurface in the present work. Additionally, the regularisation approach to leverage the distributional null energy condition to gain estimates on the respective approximations is technically more demanding, cf. the C^{1} -case in [ 20 , 35 ] —all issues we reserve for future research. Finally, the Hawking-Penrose theorem already classically relies on a more involved focusing analysis providing the existence of conjugate points along a single causal geodesic solely under an energy and a genericity condition which, from our present perspective, seems particularly difficult to extend to the Lipschitz case. We organise our work as follows. After stating our conventions, we collect some necessary prerequisites in Section 2 . This first concerns causality theory for (Lipschitz)-continuous metrics, where we also detail how for g\in C^{0,1} we may exploit results from the more general settings of closed cone structures of [ 47 ] and Lorentzian length spaces [ 36 ] . Then we set up the regularisation scheme to be used throughout and, finally, introduce the worldvolume estimates of [ 22 ] , which are inspired by the segment inequality of [ 13 ] . In Section 3

Read the complete text