Permuted Charged Lepton Correction in the Framework of Dirac Seesaw

Sagar Tirtha Goswami, Subhankar Roy · 2025

Read Permuted Charged Lepton Correction in the Framework of Dirac Seesaw by Sagar Tirtha Goswami, Subhankar Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18181.txt.

Introduction

Sagar Tirtha Goswami and Subhankar Roy propose a 2025 model for how neutrinos get their tiny masses. Their model keeps neutrinos as Dirac particles and gives them mass through a seesaw route inside a wide symmetry frame. A fix from the charged lepton side, with its entries swapped around, plays a key role.

The authors trace what that swapping does to things we can measure: the order of neutrino masses, the angles that mix them, and a phase tied to matter-antimatter gaps. The frame also speaks to rare decays that break flavor rules and to dark matter, which widens its testable reach.

Catalog record

CREATORSagar Tirtha Goswami, Subhankar Roy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE138 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18181

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Permuted Charged Lepton Correction in the Framework of Dirac Seesaw Sagar Tirtha Goswami, Subhankar Roy Abstract A Dirac neutrino mass model is proposed, based on an extended group structure of S ​ U ​ ( 2 ) L ⊗ U ​ ( 1 ) Y ⊗ A 4 ⊗ Z 3 ⊗ Z 10 SU(2)_{L}\otimes U(1)_{Y}\otimes A_{4}\otimes Z_{3}\otimes Z_{10} with the Dirac Type I seesaw mechanism. This work explores the impact of parametrization and permutation in the charged lepton diagonalizing matrix, driven by free parameters in the charged lepton sector, on the predictions of observable parameters. Some interesting consequences on the neutrino mass hierarchies, mixing angles and the Dirac CP phase are observed. The framework also finds application in the study of charged lepton flavour violation and dark matter. I Introduction The neutrino ( \nu ) is a peculiar particle in the standard model (SM) of particle physics. The SM says that it is massless, because there is no evidence of a right handed \nu ( \nu_{R} ) in nature. Hence, we can not form a mass term ( \bar{\nu}_{L}\nu_{R}+h.c. ) in the Lagrangian. But the idea of \nu oscillation, first proposed by Bruno Pontecorvo in 1957 [ 1 ] , and later confirmed by experiments [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] suggest that \nu has mass, however tiny it may be. To account for this mass, we might assume the existence of \nu_{R} and form the mass term. But then we run into a new problem. To explain the tiny mass of \nu , we have no other way but to accept an extremely small Yukawa coupling constant ( \lesssim 10^{-11} ). This does not answer why the mass is so small, but rather it enhances the flavour hierarchy problem [ 14 ] . The other alternative is to consider \nu to be a Majorana particle, thanks to its electrical neutrality. In this case, we do not require a right handed counterpart and can form a mass term with simply the left handed part only ( \bar{\nu}_{L}\nu_{L}^{c}+h.c. ). As to why the mass is so small, we have several mechanisms that explain it. Popular among these are seesaw mechanism [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] , radiative mass mechanism [ 20 , 21 ] etc. But the catch is that a Majorana mass term violates lepton number and lepton number violation (LNV) has not been observed in nature [ 22 ] . This fact alone casts doubt on the Majorana paradigm for \nu . So, given this uncertainty, it is reasonable to stick to the Dirac nature of \nu ’s. If we put aside the issue of non availability of \nu_{R} , the other issue, namely the smallness of \nu mass, can be explained by similar mechanisms that we use in Majorana scenario. For example, seesaw mechanism can be used to explain this smallness [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] . In this work, we use Dirac Type I seesaw mechanism considering \nu ’s to be Dirac particles. Several works have explored this approach [ 24 , 25 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] . Our work here emphasizes the charged lepton (CL) sector in shaping predictions for observable parameters related to \nu . The impact of CL corrections on these parameters is well documented [ 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 ] . In this work, however, we introduce a specific Permuted Charged Lepton Correction (PCLC), which captures the combined effect of parametrization and permutation of the charged lepton (CL) diagonalizing matrix on the predictions. This is an interesting aspect not often found in literature. PCLC arises due to the presence of free parameters in the CL sector, offering ample flexibility that can be leveraged by linear algebra. We highlight how this flexibility leads to intriguing consequences for observable quantities. The plan of the work is as follows: in section II , we outline the framework of our work, including the effect of linear algebra on the diagonalizing matrices. We then present the numerical analysis in section III , while section IV explores the application of our framework to charged lepton flavour violation (CLFV) and dark matter (DM). Finally, the paper is concluded with a summary in section V . II Framework II.1 Basic Structure The present work is a \nu mass model, considering \nu ’s as Dirac particles. The underlying mass generation mechanism is Dirac Type I seesaw. The model is based on an extensive group structure of SU(2)_{L}\otimes U(1)_{Y}\otimes A_{4}\otimes Z_{3}\otimes Z_{10} , which breaks down to U(1)_{EM}\otimes Z_{3} after spontaneous symmetry breaking. Apart from the SM Higgs, H , we introduce two other scalar fields, \phi and \chi in the model. The Lagrangian of the model is presented as follows, \displaystyle-\mathcal{L} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\tilde{y}_{1}\,(\bar{l}_{L}\,H)_{1}\,l_{1,R}+\tilde{y}_{2}\,(\bar{l}_{L}\,H)_{1^{{}^{\prime}}}\,l_{2,R}+\tilde{y}_{3}\,(\bar{l}_{L}\,H)_{1^{{}^{\prime\prime}}}\,l_{3,R}+\tilde{y}_{4}\,(\bar{l}_{L}\,N_{R})_{3_{s}}\,\phi+\tilde{y}_{5}\,(\bar{l}_{L}\,N_{R})_{3_{a}}\,\phi (1) \displaystyle+\tilde{y}_{6}\,(\bar{N}_{L}\,\nu_{R})_{3_{s}}\,\chi+\tilde{y}_{7}\,(\bar{N}_{L}\,\nu_{R})_{3_{a}}\,\chi+m_{N}\,(\bar{N}_{L}\,N_{R})_{1}, where the Yukawa coupling constants are complex numbers, as denoted by the sign (~). The charge assignments of the fields under the said group structure is tabulated in Table 1 . The multiplication rules for the groups A_{4} , Z_{3} and, Z_{10} are shown in Appendixes A and B respectively. Fields \Groups U(1)_{Y} SU(2)_{L} A_{4} Z_{3}\,(q_{3}) Z_{10}\,(q_{10}) \bar{l}_{L} 1 2 3 2 3 l_{i,R} -2 1 1,1^{{}^{\prime\prime}},1^{{}^{\prime}} 1 3 H 1 2 3 0 4 \bar{N}_{L} 0 1 3 2 4 N_{R} 0 1 3 1 6 \nu_{R} 0 1 3 1 2 \phi -1 2 3 0 1 \chi 0 1 3 0 4 Table 1 : The charge assignments of various fields under the group structure of the model. . The cyclic groups Z_{3} and Z_{10} have special roles to play. The group Z_{3} prevents a Majarona mass term for \nu_{R} , i.e., \bar{\nu_{R}}^{c}\,\nu_{R} and it remains unbroken at all energy scales. The Z_{10} group [ 37 ] is instrumental in preventing tree level Dirac mass terms like, \bar{l}_{L}H\nu_{R} , \bar{l}_{L}\phi\nu_{R} , \bar{l}_{L}\chi\nu_{R} etc. With the applications of cyclic groups explained, we now consider the vacuum expectation values (VEV) of the scalar field, H as (1,1,1)^{T}v_{H} , which gives the charged lepton mass matrix, M_{L} as follows, M_{L}=\begin{pmatrix}\tilde{m}_{L1}&\tilde{m}_{L2}&\tilde{m}_{L3}\\ \tilde{m}_{L1}&\omega\,\tilde{m}_{L2}&\omega^{2}\,\tilde{m}_{L3}\\ \tilde{m}_{L1}&\omega^{2}\,\tilde{m}_{L2}&\omega\,\tilde{m}_{L3}\end{pmatrix}, (2) where we have \omega=(-1+i\sqrt{3})/2 and \tilde{m}_{Li}=\tilde{y}_{i}\,v_{H},i=1,2,3 . It is seen that M_{L} is non-diagonal and has three independent complex parameters, viz., \tilde{m}_{L1},\,\tilde{m}_{L2} and \tilde{m}_{L3} . The \nu mass matrix, M_{\nu} , on the other hand, from the Dirac Type I seesaw mechanism, considering the VEV alignments of the scalar fields \phi and \chi as (0,k_{1},k_{2})^{T}v_{\phi} and (0,f_{1},f_{2})^{T}v_{\chi} , respectively, with k_{1},k_{2},f_{1},f_{2},v_{\phi},v_{\chi}\in\mathbb{R} , is derived as M_{\nu}=B\,M^{-1}\,D, (3) where we have, \displaystyle B \displaystyle= \displaystyle\begin{pmatrix}0&(\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})k_{2}&(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})k_{1}\\ (\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})k_{2}&0&0\\ (\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})k_{1}&0&0\end{pmatrix}v_{\phi}, \displaystyle M \displaystyle= \displaystyle\begin{pmatrix}m_{N}&0&0\\ 0&m_{N}&0\\ 0&0&m_{N}\end{pmatrix}, \displaystyle D \displaystyle= \displaystyle\begin{pmatrix}0&(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})f_{2}&(\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})f_{1}\\ (\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})f_{2}&0&0\\ (\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})f_{1}&0&0\end{pmatrix}v_{\chi}. (4) Clearly, M_{\nu} is defined in the symmetry basis, and it looks like the following, M_{\nu}=\begin{pmatrix}x_{1}e^{ix_{2}}&0&0\\ 0&s_{1}e^{is_{2}}&z_{1}e^{iz_{2}}\\ 0&w_{1}e^{iw_{2}}&\frac{z_{1}w_{1}}{s_{1}}e^{[i(z_{2}+w_{2}-s_{2})]}\end{pmatrix}, (5) with x_{1}=(v_{\chi}\,v_{\phi})|(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})f_{1}k_{1}+(\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})f_{2}k_{2}|/m_{N} , s_{1}=(f_{2}k_{2}v_{\chi}v_{\phi})|(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})|/m_{N} , z_{1}=(f_{1}k_{2}v_{\chi}v_{\phi})|(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})|/m_{N} , w_{1}=(f_{2}k_{1}v_{\chi}v_{\phi})|(\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})|/m_{N} , x_{2}=(v_{\chi}\,v_{\phi}) arg [(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})f_{1}k_{1}+(\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})f_{2}k_{2}]/m_{N} , s_{2}=(f_{2}k_{2}v_{\chi}v_{\phi}) arg [\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})]/m_{N} , z_{2}=(f_{1}k_{2}v_{\chi}v_{\phi}) arg [(\tilde{y}_{4}-\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}-\tilde{y}_{7})]/m_{N} , and w_{2}=(f_{2}k_{1}v_{\chi}v_{\phi}) arg [(\tilde{y}_{4}+\tilde{y}_{5})(\tilde{y}_{6}+\tilde{y}_{7})]/m_{N} . We see that M_{\nu} contains eight real free parameters. With M_{\nu} defined, we next introduce the hermitian matrix, H_{\nu}=M_{\nu}\,M_{\nu}^{\dagger} , as shown below, H_{\nu}=\begin{pmatrix}a&0&0\\ 0&b&\sqrt{bc}\,e^{-i\rho}\\ 0&\sqrt{bc}\,e^{i\rho}&c\end{pmatrix}, (6)

Read the complete text