Fits of α s \alpha_{s} from event-shapes in the three-jet region: extension to all energies
Paolo Nason, Giulia Zanderighi · 2025
Read Fits of α s \alpha_{s} from event-shapes in the three-jet region: extension to all energies by Paolo Nason, Giulia Zanderighi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-18173.txt.
Introduction
Paolo Nason and Giulia Zanderighi refine the value of the strong coupling from jet shapes. Their paper, from twenty twenty-five, extends an earlier fit. The coupling sets the strength of the force that binds quarks. They fit it with a partner term for effects outside standard perturbation theory, using three-jet events.
The earlier work used data from one machine at one energy. The new fit adds many machines across a wide energy span. The central value barely moves, which is a good sign. Spread across energies helps split the two kinds of corrections apart. Error bars split into test-based and theory-based parts. The result matches the world average well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paolo Nason, Giulia Zanderighi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-18173
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fits of α s \alpha_{s} from event-shapes in the three-jet region: extension to all energies Paolo Nason, Giulia Zanderighi Abstract This work is an extension of a previous publication [ 1 ] where we fitted the strong coupling α s \alpha_{s} together with the non-perturbative parameter α 0 \alpha_{0} from event-shape and jet-shape distributions using power corrections computed in the three-jet region. In ref. [ 1 ] only ALEPH data at the Z Z -pole were used in the fit. Here, instead, we include a large data sample from various e + e − e^{+}e^{-} experiments at energies ranging from 22 to 207 GeV and revisited the treatment of theoretical uncertainties. We find that the inclusion of different energies, while not changing the central fit result considerably, helps to disentangle the dependence of perturbative and non-perturbative corrections. Our best fit result is α s ( M Z ) = 0.1181 + 0.0002 − 0.0005 + 0.0018 − 0.0021 \alpha_{s}(M_{Z})=0.1181\begin{subarray}{c}+0.0002\\ -0.0005\end{subarray}\begin{subarray}{c}+0.0018\\ -0.0021\end{subarray} , where the first error includes experimental uncertianties and the second one includes uncertainties associated with scale variation, mass effects, fit limits, non-perturbative schemes and non-perturbative uncertainties. Preprint: MPP-2025-9 1 Introduction The determination of the strong coupling \alpha_{s} from shape variables in the three-jet region in e^{+}e^{-} -annihilation has always been considered the simplest context where to perform such measurement, since the observables are dominated by terms of order \alpha_{s} . In spite of the long history of e^{+}e^{-} QCD studies, this determination is controversial at present. On one side, these analyses show clearly the validity of QCD predictions. On the other, when requiring higher theoretical precision by including higher order in pertubation theory, different determinations do not seem consistent with each other, and some show a clear discrepancy with the world average (see e.g. the discussion in the 2024 Particle Data Group review on QCD [ 2 ] ). Part of the problem is due to the fact that the most precise measurements of shape variables are carried out at the Z peak, where the energy is not large enough for non-perturbative corrections to be negligible. In some analyses these effects are estimated using Monte Carlo models, while others use analytic approaches. One pitfall of the all analytic models used in the past is that they were obtained by extrapolating non-perturbative corrections calculated in the two-jet region to the regime of three-jets. This problem was addressed in refs. [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] and [ 1 ] where ways were found to estimate the power corrections in the three-jet region. In particular, in ref. [ 1 ] a fit of shape variables relying on the new calculation of power corrections was performed, leading to \alpha_{s} values that were larger than those obtained using the previous method, and well compatible with the world average. Subsequent work on the subject [ 6 ] has to some extend addressed the issues raised in refs. [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 1 ] by restricting the fit-range to the two-jet region. Ref. [ 7 ] has instead addressed the question of whether theoretical uncertainties in the di-jet factorized predictions can have a sizeable impact on the \alpha_{s} determination. The resummation of power-suppressed but logarithmically enhanced terms has recently been studies in ref. [ 8 ] . A further concern, that was pointed out in ref. [ 1 ] is the impact of resummed predictions in regions dominated by three well separated jets, where its validity is questionable. In spite of the fact that procedures to switch off resummation effects outside their region of validity are well established (e.g. through the use of modified logarithms or shape functions), it is often seen in practice that resummation effects lead to an increase of differential distributions by an amount which does not vanish even close ot the kinematic upper limit of the distributions, and instead amounts to a nearly constant factor larger than one. Given the availabity of more precise perturbative calculations, these resummed predictions can end up outside the fixed-order uncertainty band in the region where it should be most reliable. It is clear that larger theoretical predictions will typically lead to smaller values of the strong coupling, at times incompatible with the world average [ 2 ] . A last issue, first pointed out in ref. [ 9 ] , and which emerged in particular in the analyses of ref. [ 1 ] , is the intrinsic ambiguity in shape variable definitions due to the finite values of hadron masses. In ref. [ 9 ] three alternative schemes were proposed that lead to different results in shape variable distributions. Perturbative calculations deal with massless partons, and as such are not affected by such ambiguities, while the experimentally measured distributions are. It is however possible to use Monte Carlo generators to infer the shape variable distributions in these alternative schemes, starting from the distributions measured by the experiments in their standard scheme. This was found to be the largest source of uncertainties in ref. [ 1 ] , suggesting that all determinations of the strong coupling from shape varibales should include this uncertainty. If one instead believes that non-perturbative hadron-mass effects can be absored into a re-parametrization of power-suppressed effects, one needs to verify that, when using these alternative schemes, all mass effects are absorbed into the non-perturbative function and that the \alpha_{s} determimnations obtained are fully compatible. If this is not the case, a further uncertainty should be added. The present work is a follow-up of ref. [ 1 ] where we fitted the thrust, the C -parameter and the three-jet resolution variable y_{3} in terms of the strong coupling constant \alpha_{S}(M_{Z}) and a non-perturbative parameter \alpha_{0} . The work of ref. [ 1 ] was based upon two ingredients: the fixed-order calculation of shape-variable distributions at order \alpha_{s}^{3} [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] , and a calculation of non-perturbative corrections based upon the findings of ref. [ 5 ] . In ref. [ 1 ] we used only ALEPH data taken on the Z peak, while in the present work we use a much larger data-set with energies spanning from 22 to 207 GeV, available from different experiments, thus including a total of about 1400 data points. A number of improvements have been implemented in our fit procedure. First, we now use a dynamical scale in the perturbative calculations, obtained by computing at leading order the average value of the transverse momentum of the perturbative gluon giving rise to the third jet for each value of the observable. A second improvement regards the inclusion, in the previous fits [ 1 ] , of a theoretical error in the \chi^{2} definition. This led to very small \chi^{2} values, probably due to the fact that we did not include bin-by-bin theoretical error correlations. In this paper, we do not include a theoretical error in the \chi^{2} definition, and obtain more reasonable values of \chi^{2} . The theoretical error is instead included as usual by performing suitable variations on the setup of the theory predictions. Third, we developed a procedure to determine the fit-range in an automated way which is valid for different observables