On the removal of the barotropic condition in helicity studies of the compressible Euler and ideal compressible MHD equations
Daniel W. Boutros and John D. Gibbon · 2025
Read On the removal of the barotropic condition in helicity studies of the compressible Euler and ideal compressible MHD equations by Daniel W. Boutros and John D. Gibbon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17990.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Boutros and John Gibbon work on a quantity called helicity, which tracks how vortex lines twist and link in a fluid. In a 2025 paper they remove a limiting assumption from its theory for gases that can be compressed. The older conservation law for helicity held only when pressure depended on density in a simple way.
Their new definition weights the flow by density, and while the total is no longer conserved, its change follows a cleaner rule. The rate of change depends on potential vorticity and energy, not on pressure directly, which makes analysis easier. They extend the same idea to magnetized fluids with a new cross-helicity. The work also yields a bound on a length scale tied to the starting vorticity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel W. Boutros and John D. Gibbon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17990
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the removal of the barotropic condition in helicity studies of the compressible Euler and ideal compressible MHD equations Daniel W. Boutros and John D. Gibbon Abstract The helicity is a topological conserved quantity of the Euler equations which imposes significant constraints on the dynamics of vortex lines. In the compressible setting the conservation law only holds under the assumption that the pressure is barotropic. We show that by introducing a new definition of helicity density h ρ = ( ρ 𝒖 ) ⋅ curl ( ρ 𝒖 ) h_{\rho}=(\rho\mbox{\boldmath$u$})\cdot\mbox{curl}\,(\rho\mbox{\boldmath$u$}) this assumption on the pressure can be removed, although ∫ V h ρ 𝑑 V \int_{V}h_{\rho}dV is no longer conserved. However, we show for the non-barotropic compressible Euler equations that the new helicity density h ρ h_{\rho} obeys an entropy-type relation (in the sense of hyperbolic conservation laws) whose flux 𝑱 ρ \mbox{\boldmath$J$}_{\rho} contains all the pressure terms and whose source involves the potential vorticity q = 𝝎 ⋅ ∇ ρ q=\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}\cdot\nabla\rho . Therefore the rate of change of ∫ V h ρ 𝑑 V \int_{V}h_{\rho}dV no longer depends on the pressure and is easier to analyse, as it only depends on the potential vorticity and kinetic energy as well as div 𝒖 u . This result also carries over to the inhomogeneous incompressible Euler equations for which the potential vorticity q q is a material constant. Therefore q q is bounded by its initial value q 0 = q ( 𝒙 , 0 ) q_{0}=q(\mbox{\boldmath$x$},\,0) , which enables us to define an inverse resolution length scale λ H − 1 \lambda_{H}^{-1} whose upper bound is found to be proportional to ‖ q 0 ‖ ∞ 2 / 7 \|q_{0}\|_{\infty}^{2/7} . In a similar manner, we also introduce a new cross-helicity density for the ideal non-barotropic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations. Keywords: Helicity, topological fluid dynamics, barotropic approximation, potential vorticity, compressible Euler equations, inhomogeneous incompressible Euler equations, compressible MHD equations Mathematics Subject Classification: 76N99 (primary), 76W05, 76B99 (secondary) 1 Introduction It was first shown by Helmholtz (1858) that for an ideal, barotropic fluid with conservative body forces, vortex lines are transported by the flow. Thomson (1868) (later Lord Kelvin) then recognised that any knots and linkages in these lines are conserved. Almost a century later, Moreau (1961) showed that the helicity \mathcal{H} is conserved, a result that was later proved independently by Moffatt (1969) , who went further in recognizing its relationship with the magnetic helicity invariant of Woltjer (1958a) , and with the cross-helicity invariant \mathcal{H}_{c} of the ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations ( Woltjer 1958b ) . In a fluid flow with velocity vector u and vorticity vector \mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}=\nabla\times\mbox{\boldmath$u$} the helicity is defined to be a volume integral of the form \mathcal{H}=\int_{V}\mbox{\boldmath$u$}\cdot\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}\,dV . In this context, Moffatt (1969) showed explicitly that it is also a measure of the degree of vortex line linkages in a localised disturbance. This reference ( Moffatt 1969 ) has been the foundation for a significant body of work on helicity applied to knots and linkages in both ideal fluids and MHD : see also Pouquet et al (1976) , Berger and Field (1984) , Moffatt (1978) ; Moffatt (1985) ; Moffatt (1990) and Moffatt and Ricca (1992) . Moreover, it was shown in Enciso et al (2016) that the helicity is the only integral invariant for a general volume-preserving flow. We refer to the paper by Moffatt (2014) for an overview of results and a wide range of references in the subject. The effect of helicity dynamics on the energy cascade, as well as the energy dissipation rate, has been investigated in Biferale et al (2012) ; Capocci et al (2023) ; Linkmann (2018) (see references therein), see also Biferale and Titi (2013) . In fact, tracking the helicity density has now become a standard diagnostic tool in the study of vortical structures in large scale numerical simulations of both incompressible Euler and Navier-Stokes flows : see Kerr (2018) ; Kerr (2023) . For more general recent references in incompressible Navier-Stokes turbulence, see Iyer et al (2019) , Yeung and Ravikumar (2020) and Buaria et al (2022) . In the setting of ideal compressible flows, a (nearly) universal feature in the study of helicity dynamics has been the assumption of barotropicity of the fluid : that is, the pressure P is taken to be solely a function of the fluid density \rho , so iso-surfaces of pressure and density are parallel. As has been described in Thorpe et al (2003) , the results of Helmholtz and Kelvin on vortex lines and structures were introduced to the meteorological and oceanographic communities by Bjerknes (1898) (in which rotational effects were included) through his circulation theorem 1 1 1 This is also called the Poincaré-Bjerknes circulation theorem ( Poincaré 1893 ) . . The essential role played by barotropicity had been pointed out earlier by Silberstein (1896) . In meteorological reality, the validity of the barotropic assumption is somewhat limited. For instance, regions of barotropicity in the atmosphere have a uniform temperature distribution and are distinguished by the absence of fronts, so the barotropic assumption is generally restricted to the tropics ( Roulstone and Norbury 2013 ; Vallis 2019 ; Rogachevskii 2021 ) , whereas in the mid-latitudes the atmosphere is generally baroclinic. For instance, the Unified Model run by the UK Meteorological Office assumes that the pressure is a function of both density and temperature ( Davies et al 2005 ) . The barotropic assumption has greater validity, however, in the study of stellar interiors or of the interstellar medium ( Yokoi 2013 ) . One common class of barotropic models used in astrophysics are polytropic fluids, where it is assumed that P\propto\rho^{\gamma} for \gamma\geq 1 . In the non-barotropic case, a generalised helicity (which is a conserved quantity) has been introduced in Mobbs (1981) : see also Gaffet (1985) and Salmon (1988) . Similarly, a generalised cross helicity can be introduced for the non-barotropic MHD equations ( Yahalom 2017 ) . As noted in Webb (2018) (see page 183), these generalised helicities are nonlocal quantities as they depend on a nonlocal variable, namely the Lagrangian time integral of the temperature. The goal of this paper is to introduce a generalised helicity which solely depends on local variables, even though it might not be fully conserved. Due to its local nature, the dynamics of this new generalised helicity is easier to interpret. In particular, the aim of this paper is to explore the circumstances under which the barotropic condition can be removed and to study the consequences of its removal. In order to explain briefly how Moreau (1961) and Moffatt (1969) used the barotropic assumption, let us consider an ideal compressible fluid with velocity vector u , density \rho , pressure P and vorticity \mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}=\mbox{curl}\,\mbox{\boldmath$u$} . In their standard form, without the inclusion of the (specific) internal energy (see § 2.2 ), the barotropic compressible Euler equations take the form \rho\frac{\mathrm{D}\mbox{\boldmath$u$}}{\mathrm{D}t}=-\bnabla P\,,\qquad\qquad\frac{\mathrm{D}\rho}{\mathrm{D}t}+\rho\mbox{div}\,\mbox{\boldmath$u$}=0\,, (1.1) where \mathrm{D}/\mathrm{D}t=\partial_{t}+\mbox{\boldmath$u$}\cdot\bnabla is the material derivative and P is solely a function of \rho . The equation for the vorticity is \frac{\mathrm{D}\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}}{\mathrm{D}t}+\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}\mbox{div}\,\mbox{\boldmath$u$}=\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}\cdot\bnabla\mbox{\boldmath$u$}-\bnabla\left(\rho^{-1}\right)\times\bnabla P\,. (1.2) We note that the cross product vanishes as \bnabla P and \bnabla\left(\rho^{-1}\right) are both parallel