Simulating Curved Lipid Membranes Using Anchored Frozen Patches

James F. Tallman, Antonia Statt · 2025

Read Simulating Curved Lipid Membranes Using Anchored Frozen Patches by James F. Tallman, Antonia Statt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17989.txt.

Introduction

James Tallman and Antonia Statt propose a simulation method for curved lipid membranes in a 2025 paper. Lipid bilayers bend into high-curvature shapes during self-assembly and in many cell processes. Most particle simulations use flat sheets, since flat sheets join neatly across periodic boundaries.

Older workarounds shape a whole vesicle, cylinder, or disk, or force curves with walls and added potentials. Each route limits what can be studied. The new method anchors a curved membrane with frozen patches of equilibrated membrane. It works with all particle-based lipid models and extends with ease. Modelers gain a freer way to study bending, fusion, and other curved states.

Catalog record

CREATORJames F. Tallman, Antonia Statt
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17989

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simulating Curved Lipid Membranes Using Anchored Frozen Patches James F. Tallman, Antonia Statt Abstract Lipid bilayers often form high-curvature configurations due to self-assembly conditions or certain biological processes. However, particle-based simulations of lipid membranes are predominantly of flat lipid membranes because planar membranes are easily connected over periodic boundary conditions. To simulate a curved lipid membrane, one can simulate an entire vesicle, a cylinder, or a bicelle (disk-like bilayer aggregate). One can also use artificial methods to control curvature, such as applying virtual walls of beads, radial harmonic potentials, or “tape up the edges”. These existing methods have limitations due to the method by which curvature is imposed. Herein, we propose an alternative method of introducing arbitrary curvature by anchoring a curved lipid membrane with “frozen” equilibrated membrane patches. The method presented here is compatible with all particle-based lipid models and easily extended to many geometries. As an example, we simulate curved membranes with DPPC, DOPC, DLPC and DOPE lipids as parameterized by the Martini3 coarse-grained model. This method introduces limited finite-size artifacts, prevents lipid flip-flop at membrane edges, and allows fluctuations of the free membrane center. We provide verification of the method on flat membranes and discussion on extracting shape and per-leaflet quantities (thickness, order parameter) from curved membranes. Curvature produces asymmetric changes in lipid leaflet properties. Finally, we explore the coupled effect of curvature and membrane asymmetry in both number and lipid type. We report the resulting unique morphologies (inducing gel phase, faceting) and behaviors (thickness dependent on adjacent leaflet type) that are accessible with this method. I Introduction Lipid molecules can self-assemble into a variety of structures due to their amphiphillic nature 1 , with planar lipid bilayers being one of the most studied. However, many biologically and physically significant processes occur in bilayers adopting non-planar shapes. For example, bilayers form vesicles that have radii of curvature as small as 15 nm 2 ; 3 ; 4 , demonstrating the constraints imposed by geometry. Mitochondrial crista junctions have radii of curvature as small as 10 nm 5 ; 6 ; 7 . Similarly, lipid droplets form by the budding of lens-like oil droplets to minimize the monolayer curvature 8 ; 9 ; 10 , highlighting the role of curvature in maintaining membrane organization. Membrane fusion, fission, and budding further create highly localized regions of intense curvature 11 ; 3 ; 12 ; 13 ; 4 ; 14 . Additionally, lipid membranes often exhibit compositional or number asymmetries which either induce or are induced by membrane curvature 15 ; 16 . These asymmetries and curvatures are related to functional behaviors such as membrane fusion, repair, and signaling 16 . These examples collectively underscore the critical role of curvature in shaping the structural and functional behavior of lipid membranes. Fundamental understanding of lipid membranes has been developed through a combination of experimental and computational approaches. Experimental techniques provide critical insights into the structure and dynamics of membranes across nano- to mesoscopic scales, while molecular dynamics provide real-space molecular-level information into the assembly and behavior of model lipid membranes. Molecular dynamics often leverages periodic boundary conditions that constrain bilayer systems to one of three cases: a system modeling the self assembly of entire vesicles 17 or cylinders 18 , a system modeling bicelles 19 ; 20 ; 21 ; 17 ; 22 , or a system modeling planar membranes connected over the periodic boundary condition. As discussed in the work by Foley and Deserno 23 , membranes simulated over periodic boundary conditions cannot relax differential area strain by bending in the out-of-plane dimension, as any curvature must induce an opposite, energetically unfavorable, curvature elsewhere on the membrane. Nevertheless, it would be advantageous to be able to simulate curved membrane systems without needing to simulate the whole vesicle (which is computationally expensive) and without simulating bicelles (which allow frequent flip-flop over the free ends of the bicelle). Recent methods to solve this problem have been summarized by Larsen 24 . These methods impose artificial beads or forces to break the periodic symmetry of the simulation, allowing the study of curved membranes. One approach involves adding a wall of virtual beads to enclose the membrane into a given curvature 25 ; 26 ; 27 ; 6 . This method was used to demonstrate an increase in permeability in highly curved membranes 26 , allowed arbitrary geometry 27 , and introduced minimal defects 25 . Another method leverages harmonic radial constraints which enables simulation of membrane fluctuation and unimpaired lateral diffusion 28 . Attractive porous surfaces placed below the membrane have allowed the study of protein localization relative to curved membrane surfaces 29 . However, in these methods, the whole membrane is affected by the curvature imposing method. Because of this, certain related behaviors such as fusion, budding, and gel transitions become difficult or impossible to decouple from the imposition of curvature. In addition to artificial forces, there exist methods that apply artificial constraints through the boundary conditions. Membrane buckling, induced by reducing the cross-sectional area of the membrane artificially, is used to understand the effect of curvature on lipid properties 30 ; 7 ; 31 and a mechanism behind protein curvature sensing 32 . Additionally, a clever method of adding screw and glide plane symmetry along the periodic boundary condition allows the simulation of effectively curved membranes 33 . A notable recent contribution to studying membrane curvature is the “Sticky Tape” method 23 . Foley and Deserno offered a simple solution, “tape up the edges” 23 . With a free-floating “tape” which prevented lipid flip-flop at the edges, their systems, which contained either compositional or number asymmetry, could relax its curvature to the lowest energy state 23 . This method allows curvature to relax given the asymmetry present in the leaflets, and has relatively few artifacts introduced by the taped edges. However, the method is not (to our knowledge) constructed to model systems where curvature is not relaxed to equilibrium. Additionally, this method uses the ultra-coarse-grained Cooke-Deserno lipid model 34 , where lipid and “sticky tape” attractiveness is specific to the leaflet label, if one wanted to implement the protocol directly. The choice of lipid model in this work is justified by “facilitating novel simulation conditions, not to serve as a template for an experimentally realizable molecular system” 23 . The present work is, in essence, an attempt to extend and translate this model to experimentally realizable systems. Figure 1: Snapshots of equilibrated curved lipid (DPPC) membrane with an imposed angle of 67.5^{\circ} . Dark pink indicates lipid heads and muted pink indicates lipid tails. Grey lipids are frozen to enforce curvature. (Top) View of membrane section with explicit solvent rendered as transparent blue particles. (Bottom) View of a slice of the xz plane in which solvent particles have been deleted for clarity. Outer pink lines represent curves fit to the outer and inner leaflets. Inner muted pink line identifies the membrane midplane (see Appendix V.2 ). The elegant “sticky tape” method 23 inspired us to develop an alternate method, which we refer to as “frozen membrane anchors” in this work. Those frozen membrane anchors impose a net curvature in a system, but do not define the membrane shape the bilayer must

Read the complete text