Statistical Tools for Frequency Response Functions from Posture Control Experiments: Estimation of Probability of a Sample and Comparison Between Groups of Unpaired Samples

Vittorio Lippi \orcidID 0000-0001-5520-8974 · 2025

Read Statistical Tools for Frequency Response Functions from Posture Control Experiments: Estimation of Probability of a Sample and Comparison Between Groups of Unpaired Samples by Vittorio Lippi \orcidID 0000-0001-5520-8974 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17891.txt.

Introduction

Vittorio Lippi presents statistical tools for posture control experiments in a paper from two thousand twenty-five, written alone. Such experiments summarize body sway with a frequency response function, a set of values across frequencies. Researchers may want to know how likely a new result is to come from a known group.

Lippi sums up a recent method that builds confidence bands for these functions by resampling. On that base, he proposes ways to score the likelihood that a single result belongs to a given set. He also gives a test for comparing two groups of unpaired samples. The tools could help diagnose conditions or judge how human-like a robot or wearable device moves.

Catalog record

CREATORVittorio Lippi \orcidID 0000-0001-5520-8974
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17891

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Statistical Tools for Frequency Response Functions from Posture Control Experiments: Estimation of Probability of a Sample and Comparison Between Groups of Unpaired Samples Vittorio Lippi \orcidID 0000-0001-5520-8974 Abstract The frequency response function (FRF) is an established way to describe the outcome of experiments in posture control literature. The FRF is an empirical transfer function between an input stimulus and the induced body segment sway profile, represented as a vector of complex values associated with a vector of frequencies. Having obtained an FRF from a trial with a subject, it can be useful to quantify the likelihood it belongs to a certain population, e.g., to diagnose a condition or to evaluate the human likeliness of a humanoid robot or a wearable device. In this work, a recently proposed method for FRF statistics based on confidence bands computed with bootstrap will be summarized, and, on its basis, possible ways to quantify the likelihood of FRFs belonging to a given set will be proposed. Furthermore, a statistical test to compare groups of unpaired samples is presented. 1 Introduction 1.1 Overview Figure 1: The pseudo-impulsive-response (PIR) on the left, the FRF (red stars), and the DFT of the PIR (colored lines). The PIR is computed with eq. x_{i}(t)=\sum^{M}_{k=1}\Re(H_{i,k})\cos(2\pi\varphi_{k}t)+\Im(H_{i,k})\sin(2\pi\varphi_{k}t) . The peculiarity of the FRF as proposed in posture control analysis is that the frequencies \varphi=[0.05,\>0.15,\>0.3,\>0.4,\>0.55,\>0.7,\>0.9,\>1.1,\>1.35,\>1.75,\>2.2]Hz are not equally spaced. The associated H is obtained as the average of the empirical transfer function over a range of frequencies. Such visualization of frequency response was defined for better plotting the signal peterka2002sensorimotor . Different sample times are tested to reconstruct the FRF through a DFT. The period of the PIR is defined as the inverse of the greatest common divisor of the frequencies in \varphi ; the sample time used in the examples is set to ten times the highest frequency in \varphi , i.e., 22 Hz. Notice how the gain tends to converge to zero between the peaks. The frequency response function (FRF) is a common representation used in posture control experiments to describe the relationship between an input stimulus and the resulting body movement VANDIEEN2018219 ; 1400711 ; hwang2016identification ; amiri2019experimental ; schut2019effect . The FRF is defined as an empirical transfer function. The FRF is a complex function of frequency, and its structure must be considered when performing statistical analysis to assess differences between groups of FRFs. An example of FRF is shown in Fig. 1 with a brief explanation. For an extended description of FRFs in posture control that goes beyond the limits of this paper, see peterka2002sensorimotor ; lippi2020human . The set used in the example is from lippi2020human . It should be noted that FRF is a linear representation of the input-output relationship and that, in general, human posture responses are nonlinear. For example, they exhibit proportionally smaller responses (gains) to larger stimuli Hettich2013 ; hettich2015human ; Hettich2014 . For this reason, when fitting linear models to posture control different parameters are obtained for different stimuli amplitudes, that is usually accounted as a reweighting in the model asslander2014sensory ; fb7822c9cc0445f5bf7a4339302a4ed5 due to different conditions (as observed for different availabilities of sensory inputs jeka2010dynamics ; pasma2012sensory ). In the present work, the FRFs are regarded just as a description of the experimental trial, without any specific assumption on the underlying process; assumptions (i.e., linear or not linear model) can be part of a work using the presented methods. Statistics are typically performed by defining a scalar variable to be studied, such as the norm of the difference between FRFs, or by considering the components independently. However, this approach can introduce an arbitrary metric that may have little connection with the experiment. To properly consider the nature of the FRF, a method oriented to complex functions should be used. One method, based on random field theory pataky2014vector , considers the two components (imaginary and real) as independent variables Lippi2023 . The intuition that an FRF, being a transfer function, can be transformed into a real-time domain signal without loss of information suggests an approach. On such real functions, the confidence bands can be defined using methods for continuous functions lenhoff1999bootstrap . As the Fourier transform of a transfer function represents the impulsive response of a system, such function is referred to as pseudo-impulse-response , PIR. The method to use bootstrap to define confidence bands on PIRs to perform statistics on FRFs is described in Lippiforthcoming , and the code is available at LippiFRF24 . The average PIR is \bar{x}(t)=1/N\sum_{i=1}^{N}x_{i}(t) (1) and the STD is \hat{\sigma}_{x}(t)=\sqrt{(1/(N-1))\sum^{N}_{i=1}\left|x_{i}(t)-\bar{x}(t)\right|^{2}} (2) With these values, the prediction band can be defined for a new draw from the FRF distribution H_{n+1} , and hence for the respective PIR x_{N+1}(t) . With the desired confidence level \alpha\% , the constant C_{p} is defined to obtain the probability P\left[\max\limits_{t}\left(\frac{|x_{N+1}(t)-\bar{x}(t)|}{\hat{\sigma}_{x}(t)}\right)\leq C_{p}\right]=\frac{\alpha}{100} (3) and the prediction band for a new FRF is \bar{x}(t)\pm C_{p}\cdot\hat{\sigma}_{x}(t). (4) This work proposes a further application of such bands to quantify the degree to which a sample FRF belongs to a distribution. The bootstrap approximates the probability in eq. 3 as: \frac{1}{B}\sum\limits_{b=1}^{B}\left[\frac{1}{n}\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n}I\left(\max\limits_{t}\left(\frac{|x_{i}(t)-\hat{x}^{b}(t)|}{\hat{\sigma}^{b}_{x}(t)}\right)\leq C_{p}\right)\right] (5) where the function I() is equal to 1 when the condition in parentheses is verified and equal to 0 otherwise. In practice, the inner sum is the number of samples inside the prediction band for the b^{th} bootstrap iteration. Eq. 5 is the average, over the B bootstrap replications, of the proportion of the original data curves whose maximum standardized deviation from the bootstrap mean is less than or equal to C_{p} . The superscript b addressed that the quantity is computed based on the resampled set. Notice that \hat{\sigma}^{b}_{x}(t) is based on the resample set at every iteration of the bootstrap as recommended in hall1991two . Such “pivotization” also allows for null hypothesis testing without having to simulate the distribution produced by the null hypothesis davison2003recent , as will be shown in the examples. The number B is set to be relatively large with a trade-off between the accuracy and the computational time. Different indications about the required B are discussed in zoubir1998bootstrap . In a opposite situation to what is done in Lippiforthcoming , the C_{p} is known (inferred using the tested sample), and the \alpha is the quantity to be computed. The statistics obtained from the bootstrap repetitions, i.e., the inner term from eq. \left(\max\limits_{t}\left(\frac{|\hat{x}(t)-\hat{x}^{b}(t)|}{\hat{\sigma}^{b}_{x}(t)}\right)\right) are sorted in ascending order, and a histogram approximating the cumulative density function is computed. The desired \alpha is at the intersection of the cumulative histogram with the threshold C_{p} , as shown in Fig. 3 , right. 1.2 Probability that a sample belongs to a distribution. The need to classify FRFs in groups arises when the posturography is used to diagnose a condition or to assess the human likeness of a behavior produced by a robot humanoid or wearable as in lippi2020human . A modified version of the function computing the prediction band from Lippiforthcoming can compute the minimal band, including a given sample. See fig. 3 . This works by reversing the process used to compute the prediction band, i.e., finding the confidence \alpha given the distance from the mean: the maximum distance between the test sample and the estimated mean in the histogram

Read the complete text