Readout-induced leakage of the fluxonium qubit
Aayam Bista, Matthew Thibodeau, Ke Nie, Kaicheung Chow, Bryan K Clark, Angela Kou · 2025
Read Readout-induced leakage of the fluxonium qubit by Aayam Bista, Matthew Thibodeau, Ke Nie, Kaicheung Chow, Bryan K Clark, Angela Kou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17807.txt.
Introduction
Aayam Bista and his co-authors study a hidden cost of reading out a superconducting qubit, in a 2025 paper. The standard readout shines light into a resonator and infers the qubit state from the response. Teams push more photons in to read faster and more reliably, but the extra light can kick the qubit out of its stored state, even into higher energy levels. That breaks the gentle, non-demolishing measurement that quantum error correction depends on.
Working with fluxonium qubits, the team mapped how the state evolves as resonator photons are added. They saw jumps both inside and outside the qubit's working space. Modeling matched the data only when higher levels and one stray outside mode were included. The work shows leakage must be tracked, not just readout accuracy, when measurements grow stronger.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aayam Bista, Matthew Thibodeau, Ke Nie, Kaicheung Chow, Bryan K Clark, Angela Kou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17807
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Readout-induced leakage of the fluxonium qubit Aayam Bista, Matthew Thibodeau, Ke Nie, Kaicheung Chow, Bryan K Clark, Angela Kou Abstract Dispersive readout is widely used to perform high-fidelity measurement of superconducting qubits. Much work has been focused on the qubit readout fidelity, which depends on the achievable signal-to-noise ratio and the qubit relaxation time. As groups have pushed to increase readout fidelity by increasing readout photon number, dispersive readout has been shown to strongly affect the post-measurement qubit state. Such effects hinder the effectiveness of quantum error correction, which requires measurements that both have high readout fidelity and are quantum non-demolition (QND). Here, we experimentally investigate non-QND effects in the fluxonium. We map out the state evolution of fluxonium qubits in the presence of resonator photons and observe that these photons induce transitions in the fluxonium both within and outside the qubit subspace. We numerically model our system and find that transitions to higher-excited states and coupling to an external spurious mode are necessary to explain observed non-QND effects. I Introduction A particular strength of superconducting qubit platforms is the ability to perform dispersive readout of the qubit where the qubit state is reflected in the frequency of a coupled readout resonator [ 13 ] . Multiple groups have used dispersive readout to achieve very high signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) for readout, leading to readout fidelities, which characterize the probability that the readout outcome reflects the qubit state, of >99\% [ 48 , 40 ] . The main method for improving readout fidelities has been to increase the number of photons used for reading out the resonator. It has been observed by multiple groups, however, that dispersive readout using increased photon numbers is not quantum non-demolition (QND), i.e. the post measurement state is changed from the pre-measurement state by the measurement [ 20 , 34 , 46 , 24 , 12 , 15 ] . This presents a significant challenge for the implementation of quantum error correction, which requires that measurements have both high readout fidelities and are QND. For quantum error correction, it is the QND measurement fidelity \mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{QND}}=\frac{1}{2}[P(g,0|g)+P(e,1|e)] , where P(q,q_{m}|q) is the probability that a qubit initialized in the state |{q}\rangle is measured to be in |{q}\rangle with corresponding measurement outcome q_{m} and remains in |{q}\rangle post-measurement, that must be optimized [ 17 ] . Knowledge of the non-QND effects of dispersive readout and their origins is necessary to determine how best to maximize \mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{QND}} . Observed non-QND effects have manifested differently in different types of superconducting qubits. In transmons, non-QND effects have been shown to arise from leakage to higher levels of the transmon potential [ 11 , 20 , 34 ] . In the fluxonium, on other hand, non-QND effects have been observed in the form of decreased qubit relaxation time when the resonator is populated with only a few photons [ 46 , 24 , 38 , 10 ] . This negatively impacts the QND measurement fidelity in two ways: it decreases the readout fidelity, which is exponentially sensitive to the relaxation time [ 14 , 25 ] and decreases the QNDness. The origin of the non-QND effects in fluxonium remains unclear, and without a model for them it is difficult to optimize device construction and measurement protocols. Recent theoretical work has conjectured that the observed non-QND effects in the fluxonium are due to measurement-induced transitions to higher-energy fluxonium states [ 31 ] or higher-frequency parasitic modes residing in the fluxonium superinductance [ 35 ] . Experiments on fluxonium readout have mainly reported on achieved readout fidelity in the presence of non-QND effects with different devices exhibiting non-QND effects at drastically different photon numbers [ 46 , 24 , 38 , 10 , 15 ] . It is crucial, however, that we understand the origins of these non-QND effects in order to improve fluxonium QND measurement fidelity and make progress on building fluxonium-based processors. Here we experimentally investigate the effects of resonator photon number on the fluxonium qubit state. Our observations demonstrate that decreases in relaxation times of the fluxonium in the presence of readout photons are due to transitions both within and outside of the qubit subspace. We find both a monotonic decrease of QNDness with respect to the resonator population alongside additional non-monotonic dips of the relaxation time at particular population values. We numerically model the observed non-QND effects in our data and find that the inclusion of a spurious mode into a driven fluxonium-resonator Hamiltonian is necessary to model observed qubit transition probabilities. By varying the applied external flux to change both the transition selection rules and fluxonium frequency, we identify the importance of defect-based two-level systems in causing observed non-QND effects. We thus find that both resonator-driven transitions to higher-energy fluxonium states and resonator photon -induced coupling to spurious modes are responsible for non-QND behavior in the fluxonium. We finally discuss implications of this model for improving and controlling dispersive readout in the fluxonium. Figure 1: (a) Circuit schematic of the device. A fluxonium (blue) with inductive energy E_{L} , Josephson energy E_{J} , and capacitive energy E_{C} is capacitively coupled (red) with mutual capacitance C_{C} to a readout resonator (green) with capacitance C_{R} and inductance L_{R} . The flux applied to the fluxonium is denoted by \phi_{\mathrm{ext}} (b) Energy level diagram of the fluxonium. A periodic drive at the resonator frequency, f_{r}=\omega_{r}/2\pi , can induce transitions from |{g}\rangle or |{e}\rangle to levels outside the qubit subspace denoted by |{o}\rangle . (c) Pulse sequence for investigating the effect of readout photons on the fluxonium state. An \hat{\mathrm{I}} or \hat{\mathrm{X}} /2 operation is first applied to the fluxonium. We then perform an initial projective measurement of the fluxonium state followed by a varying drive to introduce \bar{n} photons into the resonator. A final stronger and longer projective measurement is then performed on the fluxonium. (d) Readout histograms of the fluxonium qubit before and after 15 photons have been introduced in the resonator. The state corresponding to each distribution is labeled in black. II Probing the fluxonium in the presence of resonator photons We investigated the behavior of multiple fluxonium devices (parameters in Table I) coupled to driven resonators (Fig. 1 (a),(b)) by monitoring their state evolutions in the presence of resonator photons (Fig. 1 (c)) [ 34 ] . We will focus here on Device A before discussing the other devices in Section VI. In our experiment, we first either use the \hat{\mathrm{X}}/2 operation followed by the first measurement, to start in an equal mixture of |{g}\rangle and |{e}\rangle or apply no pulse and start in the thermal equilibrium population of |{g}\rangle and |{e}\rangle , to ensure statistically significant initial counts in both states. An initial measurement, using approximately three readout photons and applied for 5 \mu s, is then performed to discriminate between the |{g}\rangle and |{e}\rangle states. Here, we chose a low readout power to mitigate non-QND effects and excitations out of the qubit subspace. Immediately after the initial measurement, we applied a drive on the resonator to mimic the effect of readout photons in the resonator during a measurement pulse. We will refer to this drive on the resonator between measurements as the proxy readout drive. No measurement result