AI Governance through Markets

Philip Moreira Tomei 1,2 , Rupal Jain 2,3 , Matija Franklin 1,2,4 · 2025

Read AI Governance through Markets by Philip Moreira Tomei 1,2 , Rupal Jain 2,3 , Matija Franklin 1,2,4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17755.txt.

Introduction

Philip Moreira Tomei, Rupal Jain, and Matija Franklin argue that markets should help govern artificial intelligence, not just regulators. Current oversight leans on rules written by governments. The authors contend that market tools can reward safe development directly, by tying the risk of AI systems to financial risk for the firms that build them. They examine four such tools in depth.

The four are insurance, auditing, procurement, and due diligence by investors. Each, they argue, can push firms to disclose more about their systems and to take safety seriously, because silence or sloppiness would cost money. The authors do not claim markets alone can protect the public. Instead they urge standard disclosure rules that let market pressure work, and they call on regulators, economists, and researchers to build and test these approaches. The paper is a position piece aimed at widening the governance toolbox.

Catalog record

CREATORPhilip Moreira Tomei 1,2 , Rupal Jain 2,3 , Matija Franklin 1,2,4
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17755

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI Governance through Markets Philip Moreira Tomei 1,2 , Rupal Jain 2,3 , Matija Franklin 1,2,4 Abstract . This paper argues that market governance mechanisms should be considered a key approach in the governance of artificial intelligence (AI), alongside traditional regulatory frameworks. While current governance approaches predominantly focus on regulation, we contend that market-based mechanisms offer effective incentives for responsible AI development. We examine four emerging vectors of market governance: insurance, auditing, procurement, and due diligence, demonstrating how these mechanisms can affirm the relationship between AI risk and financial risk while addressing capital allocation inefficiencies. While we do not claim that market forces alone can adequately protect societal interests, we maintain that standardised AI disclosures and market mechanisms can create powerful incentives for safe and responsible AI development. This paper urges regulators, economists, and machine learning researchers to investigate and implement market-based approaches to AI governance. 1. Overview The field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) governance has predominantly emphasised regulatory frameworks ( Anderljung et al. 2023 ; Schuett 2023 ; Roberts et al. 2021 ) and international cooperation ( Cha 2024 ; Gruetzemacher et al. 2023 ) to address AI risk. Meanwhile, uncertainty regarding AI risks is a major barrier to widespread enterprise adoption ( KPMG [n. d.] ) ( Altintas 2024 ) . Despite the economic benefits, organisations recognise AI risk as a business risk and lack the tools to confidently address it ( Deloitte 2024a ) . Market governance approaches, such as insurance, auditing, procurement, and due diligence, can serve to both mitigate AI risk and enable AI growth - aligning market forces with prosocial behaviour ( Smith 2016 ) . Market governance mechanisms are processes that structure economic behaviour by aligning financial incentives with desired outcomes. By directing capital flows, they possess the distinct advantage of embedding their own enforcement and incentive structures ( Cullenward and Victor 2020 ) . Regulatory initiatives for AI, on the other hand, have faced increasing criticism for being perceived as anti-competitive ( Moutii and Moutii 2024 ) and anti-growth ( Weinstein 2024 ) . We contend that rational and responsible approaches to AI governance can align with economic objectives. Policy interventions may prove instrumental in creating a robust market governance ecosystem ( Kiely 1998 ) . Analysis of the market governance of AI opens up distinct opportunities for both public and private involvement. Mechanisms such as insurance, auditing, due diligence, and procurement offer opportunities for both startups and large enterprises to capitalise on the growing need for AI de-risking which is projected to reach a value of $276 billion by 2030 ( Ventures 2024 ) . These mechanisms also afford policymakers and quasi-regulatory entities—including industry consortia, trade associations, and standards organisations — strategic pathways for market shaping. Through the deployment of incentive structures, subsidisation programs, public-private collaborations, and standardisation frameworks, policymakers can leverage markets to govern artificial intelligence development while advancing critical economic, technological, and societal imperatives. 1.1. Governance Through Markets Figure 1. 4 AI market governance mechanisms. By market governance mechanisms, we refer to tools and processes that align financial incentives with desired social or economic outcomes by structuring economic behaviour ( Sbragia 2000 ) . These mechanisms include (but are not limited to) insurance, auditing, procurement practices, and due diligence - which in turn serve risk distribution, information discovery, protocolisation and capital allocation. In the context of AI governance, market governance mechanisms aim to decrease AI risk by pricing, measuring and mitigating the risk incurred in AI deployment and development. These mechanisms further enable public and private stakeholders to shape AI in ways that align with broader societal and economic goals, fostering a balance between innovation and risk mitigation. As Hadfield and Clark argue ( Hadfield and Clark 2023 ) AI fundamentally disrupts traditional regulatory frameworks in ways that demand comprehensive reconsideration of our approach. Their analysis suggests that the primary challenge is not simply creating new rules for AI-specific risks, but developing dynamic regulatory approaches that can adapt to AI’s pervasive influence. Their proposal for regulatory markets can be seen as one possible structure within which market governance mechanisms can operate. Their example demonstrates the broad array of policy strategies available towards market governance of AI, which can range from complete self-governance to government mandates with punitive enforcement. Market governance mechanisms often function as private regulators, for-profit and non- profit organizations that develop and supply regulatory services, which compete to sell to targets, this is the case for instance with the protocol organisations and assurance providers ( Micheler and Whaley 2020 ) we describe later. This is not necessarily always the case, due diligence and insurance have similar effects but would not fall under this label. It is important to note that AI Risk and its associated uncertainty are a major barrier to AI adoption across the economy ( Ameye et al. 2023 ; McKinsey and Company 2024 ) . This is exemplified by how AI service providers have resorted to providing unlimited indemnities to maintain their sales volume ( Cloud [n. d.] ) . Market governance mechanisms work to reduce asymmetry and risk, enhancing the stability and efficiency of markets and enabling adoption ( Kauffman and Weber 2021 ) . For example, insurance functions as market governance by facilitating the distribution and management of uncertainty across a broad pool of market participants ( Knight 1921 ) , thereby mitigating individual exposure to risk while promoting resource allocation through the collective absorption of losses ( Boettke and Candela 2021 ) . We do not believe the aforementioned four mechanisms to be exhaustive but rather exemplary of the kind of intervention points which are able to work alongside market forces to govern AI. We wish to highlight the way markets are already governing AI and widen the possibility space for AI governance research beyond hard regulation. Each of these mechanisms represents an opportunity for both public and private interventions into the governance of AI backed by the power of markets. 1.2. AI Risk as Market Failure The uncertainty around AI risk is a major barrier to enterprise adoption of AI technologies ( KPMG [n. d.] ; Altintas 2024 ) . Large enterprise customers are uncertain about how to measure, mitigate and govern the risks posed by AI integration into their organisations ( Deloitte 2024a ) . Notwithstanding its potential economic advantages, this issue persists as a significant impediment to the dissemination of AI technologies. Consequently, organisations have already recognised that AI-related risks are synonymous with business risks, and are responding in a manner that reflects this understanding. The awareness of these risks and the inability of organisations to address them prevents firms and society at large from benefiting from AI technologies. In this vein, we may understand the uncertainty around AI Risk and its mitigation as market failure. The failure, that is, to measure and mitigate the private costs of AI development and deployment and price its externalities. By AI risk, we imply a risk from the development and deployment of AI systems. This risk to the firm is magnified in how closely AI is being integrated to value-generating and infrastructural operations. We use the following formula to quantify this risk-adjusted value ( Artzner et al. 2007 ) of AI

Read the complete text