Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin ⁡ 2 ​ β \sin 2\beta at Belle II

P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration · 2025

Read Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin ⁡ 2 ​ β \sin 2\beta at Belle II by P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17631.txt.

Introduction

Petros Stavroulakis, writing for the Belle II team, presents a new tool that tells which way a short-lived particle decayed. The tool, GFlaT, uses a graph neural network to judge the flavor of neutral B mesons born in a collider. Knowing the flavor is key to tests of matter-antimatter imbalance. The 2025 work checks the tool on a large sample of collisions recorded in Japan.

The new tagger sorted flavor far better than the old Belle II method, gaining about a fifth in power. To show it off, the team measured two linked values that track the imbalance in one decay type. From them they derived a key angle of the standard model. The values match what the field expects, which backs the tagger for future runs.

Catalog record

CREATORP. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17631

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin ⁡ 2 ​ β \sin 2\beta at Belle II P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration Abstract We present GFlaT, a new algorithm that uses a graph-neural-network to determine the flavor of neutral B \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} mesons produced in Υ ( 4 S ) \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} decays. We evaluate its performance using B \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays to flavor-specific hadronic final states reconstructed in a 362 fb − 1 362\text{\,}\mathrm{f}\mathrm{b}^{-1} sample of electron-positron collisions recorded at the Υ ( 4 S ) \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} resonance with the Belle II detector at the SuperKEKB collider. We achieve an effective tagging efficiency of 37.40 ± ± 0.43 % 37.40\pm\pm 0.43\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} , where the first uncertainty is statistical and the second systematic, which is 18% better than the previous Belle II algorithm. Demonstrating the algorithm, we use B 0 → J / ψ K S 0 \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{J\mspace{-2mu}/\mspace{-2mu}\psi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{S}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} decays to measure the direct and mixing-induced C ​ P C\!P violation parameters, C C = − 0.035 ± ± 0.026 -0.035\pm\pm 0.026\text{\,} and S S = 0.724 ± ± 0.035 0.724\pm\pm 0.035\text{\,} , from which we obtain β \beta = 23.2 ± ± 1.5 ° 23.2\pm\pm 1.5\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree} . 1 Introduction In the standard model of particle physics, an irreducible complex phase in the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix [ 1 ] gives rise to C\!P violation. Measurements of mixing-induced C\!P violation in \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} meson decays constrain the values of the CKM-unitarity-triangle angles \beta and \alpha , 1 1 1 These angles are also known as \phi_{1} and \phi_{2} . which helps probe for sources of C\!P violation beyond the standard model. Such measurements require knowledge of the neutral \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} meson flavor. At Belle II [ 2 ] , \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} and \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} mesons are produced in coherent pairs from \mathit{{e}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{e}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} collisions at the \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} resonance. Since they are entangled, tagging the flavor of one of the mesons, \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , at the time of its decay determines the flavor of the other one, \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , at that same time [ 3 ] . The probability density to observe \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decay to a C\!P eigenstate at a time \Delta t from when \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays with flavor q_{\text{tag}} ( +1 for \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} , -1 for \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} ) is given by P(\Delta t,q_{\text{tag}})=\frac{e^{-\absolutevalue*{\Delta t}/\tau}}{4\tau}\big\{1+q_{\text{tag}}(1-2w)[S\sin(\Delta m_{\Pdown} \Delta t)-C\cos(\Delta m_{\Pdown} \Delta t)]\big\}, (1) where q_{\text{tag}} is determined by the flavor tagger, w is the probability to wrongly determine it, \tau is the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} lifetime, and \Delta m_{\mathit{{d}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}} is the difference of masses of the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} mass eigenstates [ 4 ] . Here S and C are parameters that quantify mixing-induced and direct C\!P violation. In the standard model, S=\sin 2\beta and C=0 to good precision [ 5 , 6 ] . In order to be able to measure S and C as accurately as possible, one needs to have precise knowledge of w . We determine it from events where \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays to \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} , for which P(\Delta t,q_{\text{sig}},q_{\text{tag}})=\frac{e^{-\absolutevalue*{\Delta t}/\tau}}{4\tau}\quantity{1 - \qsig\qtag(1 - 2w) \cosine(\Delta m_{d} \Delta t)}, (2) Besides flavor tagging effects, the finite resolution of the detector also affects the determination of \Delta t and therefore all time-dependent measurements. We account for this by convolving Eq. 1 and 2 with the \Delta t resolution model used in Ref [ 4 ] . 2 Flavor Tagging at Belle II 2.1 Category-based Flavor Tagger Until recently, flavor tagging was performed at Belle II via a category-based approach [ 7 ] which uses topological, kinematic and particle identification information from the decay of the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} in order to assign it to one of several flavor-specific tagging categories. The assignment with the highest probability is then used to make a prediction on the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , exploiting the correlation between the charge of one of the final state particles and the flavor of the decaying \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} meson. The output of this category-based flavor tagger consists of the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} at the time of its decay, q_{\text{tag}} , and the confidence of the flavor assignment, r , which can range anywhere between 0 (lowest confidence) to 1 (highest confidence). The mistag probability, w , is characteristic of the flavor tagger and is usually determined in seven bins of r defined by the edges [0.0,0.1,0.25,0.45,0.6,0.725,0.875,1.0] . To evaluate the performance of the flavor tagger we use the effective tagging efficiency, \varepsilon_{\text{tag}}=\sum_{i}\varepsilon_{i}(1-2w_{i})^{2}, (3) where \varepsilon_{i} is the efficiency to assign a flavor to \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} and w_{i} is the mistag probability in the i -th r bin. A higher effective tagging efficiency directly translates to more statistically precise measurements of S and C . 2.2 Graph-Neural-Network Flavor Tagger Recently, a new flavor tagging algorithm [ 8 ] based on a dynamic-graph-convolutional neural network [ 9 ] was developed at Belle II , which makes use of the relational information between the final state particles in the tag-side in order to increase the effective tagging efficiency. Figure 1 shows the qr distributions of both the category-based and graph-neural-network-based flavor taggers. The latter improves on the former via better tagging of events in which the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays into final states without any charged leptons. This leads to a qr distribution that is more peaking at the edges and flatter in the middle and, consequently, to a relative improvement of 20\% in effective tagging efficiency, that is estimated from simulation. Figure 1: Distributions of qr for true \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} and \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} from GFlaT and the category-based flavor tagger in simulated data. 3 Calibration of GFlaT We use \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} decays to evaluate the performance of GFlaT and calibrate its parameters, since they allow to access the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} without the need for flavor tagging. To achieve this, we perform a time-dependent analysis, that allows to also extract the parameters of the \Delta t resolution function. We specifically reconstruct \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\to\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} decays and \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{*-}}}\to\mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{D}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} decays with \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{D}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} , \mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} , or \mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} , using charged particle tracks and calorimeter clusters. \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} candidates are reconstructed from a \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}} and a charged particle track consistent with a \mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} . A kinematic fit is performed for each \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} candidate in order to determine its decay vertex position. We first perform an unbinned maximum likelihood fit to the \Delta E distribution, defined as \Delta E\equiv E-E_{\text{beam}} , where E_{\text{beam}} , E are the beam energy and \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} energy in the c.m. frame, respectively. We then subtract the background in the \Delta t distribution using sWeight [ 10 ] and fit the resulting signal distribution simultaneously in the 7 bins of r , 2 flavors of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} and 2 flavors of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} to extract the parameters of the flavor tagger and \Delta t resolution function. The parameters obtained with the procedure described above are considered 2 2 2 This assumption was verified between \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} and \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{J\mspace{-2mu}/\mspace{-2mu}\psi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{S}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} decays in simulation. to be independent of decay mode and are used in all subsequent time-dependent measurements. Figure 2 shows the signal extraction fit to the \Delta E distribution as well as the fit to the background-free \Delta t distribution in the r -bin with the highest confidence. We obtain an effective tagging efficiency of \varepsilon_{\text{tag}}=(37.40\pm 0.43\pm 0.36)\% For comparison, we evaluate the effective tagging efficiency using the category-based flavor tagger on

Read the complete text