Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin 2 β \sin 2\beta at Belle II
P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration · 2025
Read Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin 2 β \sin 2\beta at Belle II by P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17631.txt.
Introduction
Petros Stavroulakis, writing for the Belle II team, presents a new tool that tells which way a short-lived particle decayed. The tool, GFlaT, uses a graph neural network to judge the flavor of neutral B mesons born in a collider. Knowing the flavor is key to tests of matter-antimatter imbalance. The 2025 work checks the tool on a large sample of collisions recorded in Japan.
The new tagger sorted flavor far better than the old Belle II method, gaining about a fifth in power. To show it off, the team measured two linked values that track the imbalance in one decay type. From them they derived a key angle of the standard model. The values match what the field expects, which backs the tagger for future runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 17 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17631
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Graph Neural Network Flavor Tagger and measurement of sin 2 β \sin 2\beta at Belle II P. Stavroulakis on behalf of the Belle II collaboration Abstract We present GFlaT, a new algorithm that uses a graph-neural-network to determine the flavor of neutral B \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} mesons produced in Υ ( 4 S ) \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} decays. We evaluate its performance using B \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays to flavor-specific hadronic final states reconstructed in a 362 fb − 1 362\text{\,}\mathrm{f}\mathrm{b}^{-1} sample of electron-positron collisions recorded at the Υ ( 4 S ) \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} resonance with the Belle II detector at the SuperKEKB collider. We achieve an effective tagging efficiency of 37.40 ± ± 0.43 % 37.40\pm\pm 0.43\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} , where the first uncertainty is statistical and the second systematic, which is 18% better than the previous Belle II algorithm. Demonstrating the algorithm, we use B 0 → J / ψ K S 0 \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{J\mspace{-2mu}/\mspace{-2mu}\psi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{S}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} decays to measure the direct and mixing-induced C P C\!P violation parameters, C C = − 0.035 ± ± 0.026 -0.035\pm\pm 0.026\text{\,} and S S = 0.724 ± ± 0.035 0.724\pm\pm 0.035\text{\,} , from which we obtain β \beta = 23.2 ± ± 1.5 ° 23.2\pm\pm 1.5\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree} . 1 Introduction In the standard model of particle physics, an irreducible complex phase in the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix [ 1 ] gives rise to C\!P violation. Measurements of mixing-induced C\!P violation in \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} meson decays constrain the values of the CKM-unitarity-triangle angles \beta and \alpha , 1 1 1 These angles are also known as \phi_{1} and \phi_{2} . which helps probe for sources of C\!P violation beyond the standard model. Such measurements require knowledge of the neutral \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} meson flavor. At Belle II [ 2 ] , \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} and \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} mesons are produced in coherent pairs from \mathit{{e}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{e}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} collisions at the \mathit{{\Upsilon}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}{(4S)} resonance. Since they are entangled, tagging the flavor of one of the mesons, \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , at the time of its decay determines the flavor of the other one, \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , at that same time [ 3 ] . The probability density to observe \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decay to a C\!P eigenstate at a time \Delta t from when \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays with flavor q_{\text{tag}} ( +1 for \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} , -1 for \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} ) is given by P(\Delta t,q_{\text{tag}})=\frac{e^{-\absolutevalue*{\Delta t}/\tau}}{4\tau}\big\{1+q_{\text{tag}}(1-2w)[S\sin(\Delta m_{\Pdown} \Delta t)-C\cos(\Delta m_{\Pdown} \Delta t)]\big\}, (1) where q_{\text{tag}} is determined by the flavor tagger, w is the probability to wrongly determine it, \tau is the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} lifetime, and \Delta m_{\mathit{{d}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}} is the difference of masses of the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} mass eigenstates [ 4 ] . Here S and C are parameters that quantify mixing-induced and direct C\!P violation. In the standard model, S=\sin 2\beta and C=0 to good precision [ 5 , 6 ] . In order to be able to measure S and C as accurately as possible, one needs to have precise knowledge of w . We determine it from events where \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays to \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} , for which P(\Delta t,q_{\text{sig}},q_{\text{tag}})=\frac{e^{-\absolutevalue*{\Delta t}/\tau}}{4\tau}\quantity{1 - \qsig\qtag(1 - 2w) \cosine(\Delta m_{d} \Delta t)}, (2) Besides flavor tagging effects, the finite resolution of the detector also affects the determination of \Delta t and therefore all time-dependent measurements. We account for this by convolving Eq. 1 and 2 with the \Delta t resolution model used in Ref [ 4 ] . 2 Flavor Tagging at Belle II 2.1 Category-based Flavor Tagger Until recently, flavor tagging was performed at Belle II via a category-based approach [ 7 ] which uses topological, kinematic and particle identification information from the decay of the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} in order to assign it to one of several flavor-specific tagging categories. The assignment with the highest probability is then used to make a prediction on the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} , exploiting the correlation between the charge of one of the final state particles and the flavor of the decaying \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} meson. The output of this category-based flavor tagger consists of the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} at the time of its decay, q_{\text{tag}} , and the confidence of the flavor assignment, r , which can range anywhere between 0 (lowest confidence) to 1 (highest confidence). The mistag probability, w , is characteristic of the flavor tagger and is usually determined in seven bins of r defined by the edges [0.0,0.1,0.25,0.45,0.6,0.725,0.875,1.0] . To evaluate the performance of the flavor tagger we use the effective tagging efficiency, \varepsilon_{\text{tag}}=\sum_{i}\varepsilon_{i}(1-2w_{i})^{2}, (3) where \varepsilon_{i} is the efficiency to assign a flavor to \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} and w_{i} is the mistag probability in the i -th r bin. A higher effective tagging efficiency directly translates to more statistically precise measurements of S and C . 2.2 Graph-Neural-Network Flavor Tagger Recently, a new flavor tagging algorithm [ 8 ] based on a dynamic-graph-convolutional neural network [ 9 ] was developed at Belle II , which makes use of the relational information between the final state particles in the tag-side in order to increase the effective tagging efficiency. Figure 1 shows the qr distributions of both the category-based and graph-neural-network-based flavor taggers. The latter improves on the former via better tagging of events in which the \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} decays into final states without any charged leptons. This leads to a qr distribution that is more peaking at the edges and flatter in the middle and, consequently, to a relative improvement of 20\% in effective tagging efficiency, that is estimated from simulation. Figure 1: Distributions of qr for true \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} and \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{B}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} from GFlaT and the category-based flavor tagger in simulated data. 3 Calibration of GFlaT We use \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} decays to evaluate the performance of GFlaT and calibrate its parameters, since they allow to access the flavor of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} without the need for flavor tagging. To achieve this, we perform a time-dependent analysis, that allows to also extract the parameters of the \Delta t resolution function. We specifically reconstruct \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\to\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} decays and \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{*-}}}\to\mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{D}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} decays with \mathit{{\mkern 4.0mu\overline{\mkern-4.0mu{D}}}{}_{\mspace{-2mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{0mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} , \mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} , or \mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{-}}} , using charged particle tracks and calorimeter clusters. \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} candidates are reconstructed from a \mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}} and a charged particle track consistent with a \mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} . A kinematic fit is performed for each \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} candidate in order to determine its decay vertex position. We first perform an unbinned maximum likelihood fit to the \Delta E distribution, defined as \Delta E\equiv E-E_{\text{beam}} , where E_{\text{beam}} , E are the beam energy and \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} energy in the c.m. frame, respectively. We then subtract the background in the \Delta t distribution using sWeight [ 10 ] and fit the resulting signal distribution simultaneously in the 7 bins of r , 2 flavors of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{tag}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} and 2 flavors of \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{sig}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}} to extract the parameters of the flavor tagger and \Delta t resolution function. The parameters obtained with the procedure described above are considered 2 2 2 This assumption was verified between \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{D}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{(*)-}}}\mathit{{\pi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{+}}} and \mathit{{B}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}}\to\mathit{{J\mspace{-2mu}/\mspace{-2mu}\psi}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{}}}\mathit{{K}{}_{\mspace{-3mu}\scriptstyle{\text{S}}}^{\mspace{-1mu}\scriptstyle{$0$}}} decays in simulation. to be independent of decay mode and are used in all subsequent time-dependent measurements. Figure 2 shows the signal extraction fit to the \Delta E distribution as well as the fit to the background-free \Delta t distribution in the r -bin with the highest confidence. We obtain an effective tagging efficiency of \varepsilon_{\text{tag}}=(37.40\pm 0.43\pm 0.36)\% For comparison, we evaluate the effective tagging efficiency using the category-based flavor tagger on