Reflections on “Can AI Understand Our Universe?”
Yu Wang · 2025
Read Reflections on “Can AI Understand Our Universe?” by Yu Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17507.txt.
Introduction
Yu Wang reflects on whether AI can understand the universe in a short 2025 essay. The piece weighs both the deep ideas and the tools behind the question. Wang centers the debate on two senses of understanding: a gut grasp of how things feel, and a grasp of cause and effect. Three tools get close attention: Transformers, step-by-step reasoning in words, and systems that join text with images and other inputs. Wang closes with the view that AI could, in principle, form true understanding.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yu Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17507
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reflections on “Can AI Understand Our Universe?” Yu Wang Abstract This article briefly discusses the philosophical and technical aspects of AI. It focuses on two concepts of understanding: intuition and causality, and highlights three AI technologies: Transformers, chain-of-thought reasoning, and multimodal processing. We anticipate that in principle AI could form understanding, with these technologies representing promising advancements. keywords Artificial Intelligence (AI); Machine Learning (ML); Astronomical Techniques. PACS PACS numbers: † † catchline: Vol. , No. () – 1 Introduction In the article “Can AI Understand Our Universe?” [ 1 ] , we explore the potential of integrating multi-domain data through a single large language model (LLM) to assess whether AI can function as a unified mind for scientific research. Traditionally, research in astronomy and physics often relies on specialized models tailored to specific tasks and datasets. For instance, estimating redshifts of quasars, classifying astrophysical phenomena, and inferring black hole parameters usually require separate models designed to handle the unique characteristics of each dataset. Our study demonstrates that by fine-tuning a single GPT model, it is possible to handle diverse data and tasks simultaneously. In our astrophysical classification experiments, we used spectral data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) [ 2 , 3 ] . The fine-tuned GPT model achieved a classification accuracy of 82% on spectral data, demonstrating strong capabilities in celestial object recognition. Furthermore, by fine-tuning on quasar spectral data, the model achieved a relative accuracy of 90.66% in estimating the redshift, indicating that the GPT model is capable for both classification and regression of astrophysical tasks. For gamma-ray burst (GRB) classification [ 4 ] , we used spectral information instead of the traditional GRB duration [ 5 ] . The spectral classification results show 95.15% agreement with those based on GRB durations, revealing distinct spectral properties associated with different origins of GRBs. This offers an alternative approach for classifying GRBs especially for those with ambiguous duration-based classification. In black hole parameter inference, we simulated K_{\alpha} line data under different spin parameters and viewing angles [ 6 , 7 ] , and fine-tuned the model on these data. Experimental results showed that our model achieved 100% accuracy in spin direction inference, and relative accuracies of 86.66% and 94.55% for spin parameters and viewing angles, respectively, highlighting the potential applications for parameter estimation. We anticipated that with the exponential growth of observational data from future scientific instruments, AI will become a central tool for processing large-scale, multi-disciplinary data. The design of future large-scale scientific facilities should consider the requirements from AI which is pushing scientific exploration towards an era of unified and comprehensive data integration. As we wrote this previous article, we were constantly reflecting: What does understanding mean, and can machines possess the ability to understand? We also observe that currently many studies testing whether LLMs have logical reasoning and inference capabilities, with both positive and negative results [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . However, while our article and these studies focus on testing AI within the context of current technology, we are more interested in, in principle, whether AI can achieve understanding. Specifically, is “deducing the generative principles of data through data analysis” achievable. This is not merely a technical question but also philosophical. It involves the definition of understanding, the essence of machine learning, and the differences between human cognition and machine computation. In this article, we will briefly discuss two concepts of understanding in conjunction with current AI technologies. 2 Two Concepts of Understanding In the four-dimensional universe we live, humans perceive space and time through their senses, forming an intuitive understanding of the world. Intuition is not only an essential tool to explore the understanding, but also the foundation in daily life for quick decision-making. With the rise of artificial intelligence, an intriguing question emerges: Can AI construct its own intuition without human-like senses, perhaps even surpassing human perception of the world? Furthermore, can AI, through its unique data-processing capabilities, deeply understand causal relationships and provide new perspectives in fields unexplored by humans? 2.1 Intuition Humans perceive space through binocular vision and time through changes in events and the accumulation of memory [ 14 ] . How, then, is this perception formed? By contrast, how does AI perceive space and time? Can AI experience these dimensions differently and develop an intuition beyond human capabilities, enabling it to understand the world from entirely new perspectives? 2.1.1 Humans Intuition Intuition refers to the immediate understanding humans achieve through sensory experiences, forming a ”clear image” or ”immediate comprehension” [ 15 ] . It arises from integrating sensory inputs like vision, hearing, and touch, enabling direct perception of the world [ 16 ] . For example, when we see a tree, our vision immediately conveys its shape, color, and distance, without requiring reasoning or abstraction. This direct perception facilitates rapid acquisition of information, resulting in an “evident” understanding. Intuition is closely tied to the structure of the human brain [ 17 , 18 ] . with sensory systems evolved to process inputs for rapid perception and response. Intuitive experiences aid humans in forming concepts of space, time, and causality. However, these concepts may vary among species. For instance, a vision-deprived organism, though lacking the visual intuition familiar to us, may develop alternative perceptual methods, such as relying on touch or sound, to construct an understanding of the world [ 19 , 20 ] . Such differences in perceptual mechanisms may still support effective understanding, even if the resulting “intuition” differs from ours. Human senses also have significant limitations. Our vision is confined to a narrow band of visible light, and our hearing can only perceive sounds within a limited frequency range. These constraints restrict our “intuitive” experience of the world. However, technological advancements allow us to overcome these limitations. Telescopes reveal celestial objects and microscopes expose microscopic organisms beyond the reach of the naked eye [ 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 ] . As a result, human understanding of the world is not solely dependent on intuitive experiences but also relies heavily on data-driven reasoning and model construction. Many scientific discoveries and theoretical concepts, such as quantum mechanics and relativity, lie beyond human sensory perception. These advances rely on data analysis, logical reasoning, and mathematical modeling. In this regard, AI resembles humans in some ways: it lacks human sensory organs but can understand the world through data learning and statistical pattern recognition. AI builds knowledge using multimodal data—numerical values, images, and text—similar to how humans use instruments to observe phenomena beyond their natural sensory capabilities. Its advantage lies in processing volumes and complexities of data beyond human capacity, identifying correlations and causality through mathematical and statistical models. For example, in medical imaging, AI can detect subtle features imperceptible to humans, improving diagnostic accuracy [ 25 , 26 ] . Similarly, AI can analyze environmental data to understand complex systems, even without relying on humans “intuitive experiences” [ 27 , 28 ] . 2.1.2 AI’s Super-Intuition The core function of intuition in the understanding process is to provide a “mediating framework” that facilitates quick comprehension without relying on complex reasoning or fundamental theories [ 29 , 30 , 31