A Tale of Three Location Trackers: AirTag, SmartTag, and Tile

HyunSeok Daniel Jang 1, Hazem Ibrahim 1, Rohail Asim 1, Matteo Varvello, 2 Yasir Zaki 1, 1 New York University Abu Dhabi, 2 Nokia Bell Labs, Email: { 1 daniel.jang, 1 hazem.ibrahim, 1 rohail.asim, 1 yasir.zaki}@nyu.edu, 2 [email protected] · 2025

Read A Tale of Three Location Trackers: AirTag, SmartTag, and Tile by HyunSeok Daniel Jang 1, Hazem Ibrahim 1, Rohail Asim 1, Matteo Varvello, 2 Yasir Zaki 1, 1 New York University Abu Dhabi, 2 Nokia Bell Labs, Email: { 1 daniel.jang, 1 hazem.ibrahim, 1 rohail.asim, 1 yasir.zaki}@nyu.edu, 2 [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17452.txt.

Introduction

HyunSeok Daniel Jang and four co-authors compare three popular Bluetooth location trackers in real-world use. Apple AirTag, Samsung SmartTag, and Tile devices all depend on passing phones and tablets to report their position. Makers promise accurate tracking, but field performance was poorly documented.

The team ran controlled tests with a known spread of reporting devices, plus uncontrolled trials in the wild. Twenty-two volunteers carried tags across twenty-nine countries. AirTag reported its location much more often than in earlier studies. The strongest factor was simply how many companion devices were nearby, which mattered more than brand differences. Post-pandemic travel patterns also shaped the results.

Catalog record

CREATORHyunSeok Daniel Jang 1, Hazem Ibrahim 1, Rohail Asim 1, Matteo Varvello, 2 Yasir Zaki 1, 1 New York University Abu Dhabi, 2 Nokia Bell Labs, Email: { 1 daniel.jang, 1 hazem.ibrahim, 1 rohail.asim, 1 yasir.zaki}@nyu.edu, 2 [email protected]
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17452

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Tale of Three Location Trackers: AirTag, SmartTag, and Tile HyunSeok Daniel Jang 1, Hazem Ibrahim 1, Rohail Asim 1, Matteo Varvello, 2 Yasir Zaki 1, 1 New York University Abu Dhabi, 2 Nokia Bell Labs, Email: { 1 daniel.jang, 1 hazem.ibrahim, 1 rohail.asim, 1 yasir.zaki}@nyu.edu, 2 [email protected] Abstract Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) location trackers, or “tags”, are popular consumer devices for monitoring personal items. These tags rely on their respective network of companion devices that are capable of detecting their BLE signals and relay location information back to the owner. While manufacturers claim that such crowd-sourced approach yields accurate location tracking, the tags’ real-world performance characteristics remain insufficiently understood. To this end, this study presents a comprehensive analysis of three major players in the market: Apple’s AirTag, Samsung’s SmartTag, and Tile. Our methodology combines controlled experiments—with a known large distribution of location-reporting devices—as well as in-the-wild experiments—with no control on the number and kind of reporting devices encountered, thus emulating real-life use-cases. Leveraging data collection techniques improved from prior research, we recruit 22 volunteers traveling across 29 countries, examining the tags’ performance under various environments and conditions. Our findings highlight crucial updates in device behavior since previous studies, with AirTag showing marked improvements in location report frequency. Companion device density emerged as the primary determinant of tag performance, overshadowing technological differences between products. Additionally, we find that post-COVID-19 mobility trends could have contributed to enhanced performance for AirTag and SmartTag. Tile, despite its cross-platform compatibility, exhibited notably lower accuracy, particularly in Asia and Africa, due to limited global adoption. Statistical modeling of spatial errors—measured as the distance betwen reported and actual tag locations—shows log-normal distributions across all tags, highlighting the need for improved location estimation methods to reduce occasional significant inaccuracies. I Introduction Location tracking technologies have become increasingly prevalent in recent years, with products like Apple’s AirTag [ 1 ] , Samsung’s SmartTag [ 2 ] , and Tile [ 3 ] offering consumers the ability to monitor the location of personal belongings. These devices continuously broadcast Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) packets and rely on a network of compatible devices to relay their position, raising questions about their accuracy, effectiveness, and potential for misuse (e.g., stalking). While previous research has explored the performance of some of these tags, our study aims to provide a more comprehensive and up-to-date analysis of the location tracking ecosystem. This paper specifically builds upon the work of [ 4 ] , which compared the performance of AirTag and SmartTag in both controlled and in-the-wild experiments. The original study utilized custom-developed crawlers for each tag’s companion apps (FindMy and SmartThings) to collect detailed location histories reported by devices. Controlled experiments provided insights into tag behavior, e.g., how frequently their location is reported. The tags were deployed in a secluded area alongside Apple and Samsung devices at increasing distances and in a busy campus cafeteria where WiFi connectivity provided an estimate of the surrounding device population. Complementary in-the-wild experiments explored opportunistic location reporting under varying conditions, e.g., user mobility, population densities, times of day, and days of the week. These experiments involved four volunteers traveling across six countries, each carrying both tags attached to a smartphone equipped with a custom app that logged contextual data such as GPS location and connectivity, etc. This study addresses key limitations of the original work by (1) expanding the scope of tag devices studied, (2) improving the data collection methodology, and (3) enhancing the representativeness of in-the-wild experiments. The original study was limited to AirTag and SmartTag, which lack cross-platform compatibility and rely solely on their proprietary ecosystems—iOS for AirTag and Samsung devices for SmartTag. To address this, we include Tile, a product compatible with both iOS and Android through its integration with the Life360 1 1 1 Life360 is a family safety platform which acquired Tile in November 2021. This move extended Tile’s network to include Life360 users who opt into location services. app [ 5 ] and the Tile app. This selection allows us to compare device-dependent tags (AirTag and SmartTag) with app-dependent alternatives (Tile), offering insights into how different approaches to building a location-reporting ecosystem affect performance. We also address the original study’s reliance on Optical Character Recognition (OCR) [ 6 ] for extracting tag locations from companion applications, which introduced potential timestamp errors of up to one minute. In our work, we implement improved crawlers capable of directly parsing cache files for precise, minute-by-minute location monitoring. Additionally, we overcome the limited geographical scope and representativeness of the original study, which was conducted in six countries during the COVID-19 pandemic, when social distancing measures likely reduced the density of nearby devices. Our in-the-wild experiments involve 22 volunteers traveling across 29 countries, providing a more realistic and global perspective of tags’ performance. By comparing our findings with those of the original study, we evaluate how real-world conditions, including increased device density post-pandemic, influence tag effectiveness. Finally, we leverage the tags’ location report dataset to statistically model their distance from ground-truth locations, offering an in-depth evaluation of the methods used by manufacturers to estimate a tag’s location. Our key findings are the following: Update in Device Behavior. Controlled experiments revealed significant changes in AirTag behavior, likely due to firmware updates. While the previous study had found AirTags broadcasting weaker BLE signals compared to SmartTags, our new findings indicate that they now transmit at comparable signal strengths to both SmartTags and Tiles, leading to a marked increase in update rate (the number of unique location reports per hour). In the cafeteria experiment, AirTag’s update rate scaled with Apple device density, reaching over 45 average updates at peak hours ( > 300 devices)—contrary to [ 4 ] ’s finding of a constant 10-15 updates regardless of device count. Importance of Companion Device Density. Contrary to earlier findings in [ 4 ] , our experiment in the wild reveals that the efficacy of location tags is primarily determined by the prevalence of compatible location-reporting devices rather than the specific technology employed. We observe a general correlation between tag performance and the estimated likelihood of encountering companion devices, derived from population density and the country-level mobile market-share. Poor Tile Performance. Tile’s accuracy is notably lower than that of AirTag and SmartTag, despite its compatibility with both iOS and Android Performance varies by region, with the highest accuracy observed in the Americas and Europe, while accuracy is significantly lower in Asia and Africa. This disparity appears to result from infrequent location updates, likely due to the limited global adoption of Life360/Tile. Impact of COVID-19. Following the relaxation of COVID-19 social-distancing measures (2020–2022), public mobility and activity levels gradually returned to pre-pandemic norms, increasing the number of active companion devices available in the environment. This rise in mobility likely contributed to improved location-reporting performance. Compared to the findings in [ 4 ] , AirTags and SmartTags demonstrate enhanced accuracy, reflecting the greater availability of nearby companion devices as public activity resumed. Statistical Modeling for Enhanced Tracking. We apply statistical models to analyze spatial (positional) errors relative to the GPS ground truth. Spatial errors for all tags follow a log-normal distribution, with heavy tails indicating occasional significant deviations. We also find that SmartTag significantly underestimates

Read the complete text