An analysis of Euclid’s geometrical foundations
Peter Malcolm Johnson · 2025
Read An analysis of Euclid’s geometrical foundations by Peter Malcolm Johnson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17406.txt.
Introduction
Euclid's Elements built geometry on a handful of starting points, and the earliest proofs avoid the famous parallel postulate. Peter Johnson reexamines those foundations in this 2025 paper, aiming to clarify the most obscure early steps. Equality, superposition, and angle comparison get close attention, along with the quiet handling of betweenness and crossing points.
Johnson also sketches a rigorous treatment of absolute geometry in Euclid's spirit. From two simple axioms about right angles, the properties of angles and triangles follow, leading to rigid motions in certain plane geometries. Brief comments connect the old foundations to modern developments. The paper should serve readers who teach or study the roots of geometry.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Peter Malcolm Johnson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17406
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An analysis of Euclid’s geometrical foundations Peter Malcolm Johnson Abstract The initial techniques developed in Euclid’s Elements , well before the use of the parallel postulate, are reexamined in order to clarify even the most obscure details, particularly those related to equality, superposition and angle comparison. Some commentary on modern developments is included. The known but often misunderstood implicit handling of betweenness and points of intersection is briefly treated. We also sketch a rigorous treatment of absolute geometry in a spirit similar to Euclid’s, one that allows properties of angles and triangles to be derived from two simple axioms on right angles, which then leads to rigid motions of certain planar geometries. Keywords: Euclid’s Elements, common notions, superposition, right angles, absolute geometry, foundations of geometry. MSC2020: 51-02 (Primary) 51-03, 01A20, 51F05 (Secondary) 1. Some remarks on Euclidean geometry Our ideas that arose from reading parts of the Elements and related works are those of a mathematician with some knowledge of the historical background, not those of a historian of mathematics familiar with the subtleties of Greek language and thought. In what follows, there will be a fruitful interplay between different viewpoints, ancient and modern, textual and mathematical. The principal motivation is to understand Euclid’s approach at the beginning of the Elements , where the first foundations of plane geometry are developed. We provide and defend a critical interpretation in which defects are examined but no obscurities remain, thus making this part of Euclid’s text fully comprehensible by a large class of readers. Some suggestions for alternative approaches are made, especially towards the end. Other commentary, often terse, is interspersed in an attempt to situate the present work within the large body of related research, on both ancient and modern themes. The Elements of Euclid, despite its limited scope, has had a deep and long-lasting influence on the development of mathematics and also on the history of mathematics. The meanings and purposes of its content, and of other surviving versions and fragments of Greek and Hellenistic mathematical writings, have long been the object of incisive analyses and debates, one important theme being the role of construction. Although modern scholarship has advanced, Heath’s translation of Euclid [Eu], based on Heiberg’s Greek edition, is accompanied by a wealth of information that synthesized all relevant knowledge at the time. The commentary on Book I, written by Proclus [Pr] about seven centuries after Euclid, contains much of interest. It is a uniquely detailed study of Euclidean geometry from a philosophical perspective. We use Morrow’s edited translation of that work but, as is customary, page references are to Friedlein’s Greek edition. In Euclid’s presentation of plane geometry, conclusions are drawn from the study of idealized versions of geometric diagrams formed from finitely many points (roughly, markers of position, often where objects cut or touch each other), straight lines (segments), and parts of circles. Angles, another important ingredient, will be treated later. There is an implicit notion of incidence, expressed in various ways, but not of course the conception of objects as sets of points, used below only for ease of expression. To prove results, suitable new points can be selected (they come into existence on the diagram), and straightedge-and-compass constructions made, adding to the diagram but erasing nothing. Such arguments are completely constructive, except those that make use of the Fifth Postulate on parallels. Here we diverge from Blåsjö’s constructive thesis [Bl], which makes no such exception. Euclid’s approach is not static, as geometric procedures can be carried out. To maintain the philosophical view of an ideal, unchanging geometric world, Proclus [Pr, 78] explains that all such procedures are acts taking place in the imagination. Applications are another matter: “… when it touches on the material world …” [Pr, 63]. The prevailing view is that a few proofs in the Elements rely on moving parts of diagrams. That interpretation is questionable, as it is sufficient to construct copies of objects in specified positions. More on this much-debated topic will appear below. Relatively recent approaches to axiomatic Euclidean geometry usually work with some form of Tarski’s system. Among the highlights are Gupta’s extremely ingenious constructions of various geometric objects, including midpoints of segments. This material forms part of the influential book [SST]. Approaches to constructive geometry in similar systems remain an active area of research. Some of these have been formalized in appropriate languages that permit computer-verified proofs. The article [BNW] gives an excellent exposition of how a meticulous analysis of a system like Euclid’s is needed in order to be able to carry out the complex project of complete formalization. Our much less formal approach to the most basic results of absolute geometry has key differences, notably concerning axioms for right angles, which may be of interest for future explorations in the area. The main purpose, however, is to propose a way to fully clarify the initial content of the Elements , suggesting modifications where necessary to ensure rigor. We now focus on how the most basic machinery is developed early in Book 1, how it can be further exploited in new ways, and what assumptions, especially implicit ones, are involved. These analyses will eventually lead to a way to obtain a distinctly different alternative approach to axiomatization and exposition, rigorous but still faithful to the spirit of Euclid’s geometry, one that also has notable consequences of a modern form. 2. Lines and their points To avoid confusion, what Euclid calls a straight line will often be called a segment , as segments of circles will not be discussed. A segment AB is defined uniquely by specifying two distinct points, its ends A and B. As a line, it is extendible at either end, and retains its identity, in some sense, if the ends change. Lines are never diminished, presumably because parts of diagrams cannot be erased. By explicit assumption, non-extreme points can be chosen on any segment AB. Such points are precisely those said to lie between A and B, in the strict sense of betweenness. It will soon be seen how this relation can be clearly understood in what we believe is its proper context. Contrary to what one might expect, Proclus [Pr, 285] seems reluctant to admit that there could be an idealized notion of an infinite line, extending beyond any given bound. He argues that this cannot be the object of knowing imagination. In Euclid, an infinite straight line is treated as an arbitrarily extendible segment with unspecified ends. Although not clearly stated, any two such lines are supposed to have at most one point in common if they differ, a view repeatedly defended by Proclus against objections that had been raised by Zeno and others. A convenient compromise, adopted below, is to say that two segments overlap if they share more than one point, while segments are collinear if some other segment overlaps each of them. The Fifth Postulate avoids mentioning infinite lines, which rarely appear in the Elements . It often suffices to extend a segment using a bound that can be determined from the diagram. Euclid’s Prop. I.27 gives an angular criterion showing that any point P not on a line l lies on a line parallel to l