Testing Cluster Membership of Planetary Nebulae with High-Precision Proper Motions. II . HST Observations of PHR J1315 − - 6555 in the Open Cluster AL 1 (ESO 96-SC04)

Andrea Bellini, Howard E. Bond, Kailash C. Sahu · 2025

Read Testing Cluster Membership of Planetary Nebulae with High-Precision Proper Motions. II . HST Observations of PHR J1315 − - 6555 in the Open Cluster AL 1 (ESO 96-SC04) by Andrea Bellini, Howard E. Bond, Kailash C. Sahu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17312.txt.

Introduction

Andrea Bellini, Howard Bond, and Kailash Sahu test in 2025 whether a glowing gas shell truly belongs to a star cluster it sits near on the sky. Such shells, called planetary nebulae, reveal their birth stars' masses only when their home cluster is known. Past checks gave the shell and cluster matching speeds, dust dimming, and distances.

New Hubble telescope images, paired with frames from twelve years earlier, gave exact drift measures for two candidate central stars. Both drift with cluster members, strongly backing membership, the team reports. The nearer candidate shines like a common sun-like star, hinting it has a close partner left from a shared-envelope phase. Confirmed members like this are rare anchors for how stars live and die.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrea Bellini, Howard E. Bond, Kailash C. Sahu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17312

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing Cluster Membership of Planetary Nebulae with High-Precision Proper Motions. II . HST Observations of PHR J1315 − - 6555 in the Open Cluster AL 1 (ESO 96-SC04) Andrea Bellini, Howard E. Bond, Kailash C. Sahu Abstract Planetary nebulae (PNe) shown to be members of star clusters provide information on their properties and evolutionary histories that cannot be determined for PNe in the field, in particular the initial masses of their progenitor stars. Here we investigate the bipolar PN PHR J1315 − - 6555 (hereafter PHR J1315), which lies near the open cluster AL 1 (ESO 96-SC04) on the sky. Previous work has established that the PN and cluster have similar radial velocities and amounts of interstellar reddening, and similar distances estimated using independent methods. We have obtained new images of the PN and cluster using the Hubble Space Telescope ( HST ). Combined with archival HST frames taken 12 years earlier, they provide high-precision proper motions (PMs) for two candidate central stars of PHR J1315. We find that the PMs of both candidates are consistent with those of cluster members, strongly confirming the PN’s membership in AL 1. The candidate lying closer to the center of PHR J1315 has the color and luminosity of an early F-type dwarf, suggesting that it may be the optical primary in a close post-common-envelope binary. We used the HST data to construct a color-magnitude diagram for AL 1, which we corrected for significant foreground differential reddening. Isochrone fitting reveals that the cluster lies at a remarkably large distance of about 13 kpc, and has an age of about 1.0 Gyr. The initial mass of the progenitor of PHR J1315 was about 2.1 ​ M ⊙ 2.1\,M_{\odot} . We suggest followup investigations that would provide tighter constraints on the object’s evolution. I Introduction: Planetary Nebulae in Star Clusters If a planetary nebula (PN) is verified to be a member of a star cluster, it becomes possible to derive constraints on the mass and composition of the PN’s progenitor star—information that cannot be obtained for PNe in the field. Moreover, the absolute luminosity of the PN nucleus (PNN) can be found using the cluster’s distance derived using main-sequence (MS) fitting. The mass of the PNN can then be deduced from theoretical core-mass/luminosity relations [ 45 , for example] —thus providing a point on the important initial-final mass relation [ 23 , 5 , 43 , e.g.,] . Additionally, the chemical composition of the PN, along with the progenitor mass, provide information about the dredge-up of processed material from the stellar interior—theoretically predicted to depend strongly on the initial mass of the progenitor star [see the recent review by 39 , and references therein] . This paper is the second in a series in which we report membership tests for PNe that lie close to star clusters on the sky. Our tests are based on obtaining precise measurements of proper motions (PMs) of the PNNi. In our initial study [ 14 , hereafter Paper I] , we reviewed previous attempts to confirm star-cluster membership for PNe. The criteria are that the PN has to lie within the tidal radius of the cluster, and it must have a radial velocity, interstellar extinction, estimated distance, and PM that are in agreement with those of the potential host cluster. In the case of PNe belonging to Galactic globular clusters (GCs), three objects had already been shown to satisfy all of the membership criteria, including the PM tests [ 13 , and references therein] . In Paper I we reported PM measurements for a fourth candidate, the PN JaFu 1 lying near the Galactic-bulge GC Palomar 6. We determined the PM of its central star through the use of multi-epoch high-resolution imaging with the Hubble Space Telescope ( HST ). Unfortunately, we found a significant discordance between the PM of the nucleus and the mean PM of members of Palomar 6, ruling out cluster membership for JaFu 1. 1 1 1 In spite of the high and remarkably similar radial velocities of the PN and cluster. Turning to open clusters (OCs), we note that over a dozen PNe lie tantalizingly close to Galactic OCs on the sky. However, detailed investigations have disqualified nearly all of them as members, as reviewed in depth by Majaess et al. [42] , Majaess et al. [41] , Frew et al. [30] , and Davis et al. [24] , and summarized in our Paper I . A convincing case of a PN belonging to an OC is IPHASX J055226.2+323724 (PN G177.6+03.0). This PN has recently been confirmed as a member of the OC M37 (NGC 2099), based on the Gaia PM of its nucleus, its nebular radial velocity (RV), and its interstellar extinction, all of which agree with those of the cluster [ 35 , 29 , 55 ] . Only two further Galactic PNe, to our knowledge, remain at present as strong candidate members of OCs to add to the case of the M37 PN . These are PHR J1315 - 6555 (hereafter PHR J1315; IAU designation PN G305.3 - 03.1) in the OC AL 1, and BMP J1613 - 5406 in NGC 6067 [ 30 , 27 , 28 ] . In the Local Group, a PN that likely belongs to an OC in M31 was identified by Bond [12] and analyzed spectroscopically by Davis et al. [24] . In the present paper, we report PM measurements with HST for two stars that are candidate nuclei of PHR J1315. For BMP J1613 - 5406 , at this writing we have obtained only first-epoch HST imaging of its PNN and host cluster, so a PM determination must await a second observation in 2026. II The Distant Open Cluster AL 1 Andrews & Lindsay [3] reported their discovery of a compact (diameter \sim 75^{\prime\prime} ) OC in the southern constellation Musca on a long-exposure photographic plate obtained with the Armagh-Dunsink-Harvard (ADH) Schmidt telescope at the Boyden Observatory. The cluster was also noted independently by van den Bergh & Hagen [54, no. 144 in their list] in an imaging survey of the southern Galactic plane using blue- and red-sensitive plates from the Curtis Schmidt telescope at Cerro Tololo. It was recognized yet again by Lauberts [40] in the European Southern Observatory/Uppsala Survey of the ESO(B) Atlas photographs obtained with the ESO 1-m Schmidt telescope at La Silla, Chile; in this publication the cluster is cataloged as ESO 96-SC04. Hereafter we designate the cluster as AL 1, in recognition of the first published discovery. AL 1 lies in a crowded low-Galactic-latitude field, and is centered at Galactic coordinates (l,b)=(305\fdg 4,-3\fdg 2) . The first ground-based CCD photometric observations of Al 1 were obtained by Phelps et al. [52] . Based on these data, Janes & Phelps [36] estimated the cluster’s distance to be 7.57 kpc, but the color-magnitude diagram (CMD) showed heavy contamination by field stars. CCD data obtained by Carraro et al. [21] yielded a larger distance of d\simeq 11.8 kpc; the authors pointed out that this makes AL 1 one of the most distant known Galactic OCs. They estimated a reddening of E(B-V)=0.75 and an age of 700 Myr, based on isochrone fitting in the

Read the complete text