Carving the Edges of the Rocky Planet Population

Eve J. Lee, James E. Owen · 2025

Read Carving the Edges of the Rocky Planet Population by Eve J. Lee, James E. Owen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17241.txt.

Introduction

Eve Lee and James Owen charted the edges of the rocky planet population in 2025. Small planets on short orbits are mostly rocky, stripped of gas or never holding it. In mass and radius plotted against orbit period, sharp boundaries appear, and explaining them tests planet physics.

The heaviest rocky planets stay under about ten Earth masses, dipping at the shortest and longer periods. Few rocky planets sit inside one-day orbits. Lee and Owen show tidal decay plus star-driven evaporation can carve the mass edge. The inner desert in radius points to magnetic drag as planets move through the star's magnetic field. Dying, evaporating planets seen today may have begun that spiral near one-day orbits.

Catalog record

CREATOREve J. Lee, James E. Owen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17241

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Carving the Edges of the Rocky Planet Population Eve J. Lee, James E. Owen Abstract Short-period planets provide ideal laboratories for testing star-planet interaction. Planets that are smaller than ∼ \sim 2 R ⊕ R_{\oplus} are considered to be largely rocky either having been stripped of or never having acquired the gaseous envelope. Zooming in on these short-period rocky planet population, clear edges appear in the mass-period and radius-period space. Over ∼ \sim 0.2–20 days and 0.09–1.42 M ⊙ M_{\odot} , the maximum mass of the rocky planets stay below ∼ \sim 10 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} with a hint of decrease towards ≲ \lesssim 1 day, ≳ \gtrsim 4 day, and ≲ 0.45 ​ M ⊙ \lesssim 0.45M_{\odot} . In radius-period space, there is a relative deficit of ≲ \lesssim 2 R ⊕ R_{\oplus} planets inside ∼ \sim 1 day. We demonstrate how the edges in the mass-period space can be explained by a combination of tidal decay and photoevaporation whereas the rocky planet desert in the radius-period space is a signature of magnetic drag on the planet as it orbits within the stellar magnetic field. Currently observed catastrophically evaporating planets may have started their death spiral from ∼ \sim 1 day with planets of mass up to ∼ \sim 0.3 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} under the magnetic drag. More discoveries and characterization of small planets around mid-late M and A stars would be welcome to better constrain the stellar parameters critical in shaping the edges of rocky planet population including their UV radiation history, tidal and magnetic properties. We used the following python packages: scipy [ 127 ] , numpy [ 36 ] , matplotlib [ 39 ] , pandas [ 128 ] . I Introduction Small planets abound in our Galaxy. With the detection of a clear gap that separates planets of size \lesssim 1.6–2 R_{\oplus} and those of size \sim 2–4 R_{\oplus} [ 25 , 123 , 38 ] in radius-period space, we now have statistical confirmation of two distinct populations. The smaller group is generally considered to be rocky terrestrial planets, corroborating previous expectations from mass-radius relations [ 102 ] . Under the mass loss origin of the radius gap, the population of the rocky planets may be considered as stripped cores of larger sub-Neptunes [ 121 , 79 , 80 , 34 , 99 , e.g.,] . Under the primordial origin of the radius gap, cores smaller than \sim 1–2 M_{\oplus} cannot accrete sufficient nebular gas to emerge as sub-Neptunes, so they are born practically rocky [ 59 , 60 ] . The two channels are not mutually exclusive: the primordial radius gap can be further sculpted by post-formation mass loss, which contributes particularly to the short period ( \lesssim 30–50 days) of rocky planet population [ 60 , e.g.,] . Indeed Rogers et al. [99] required some fraction of the super-Earth population to be born with negligible initial hydrogen atmospheres to be consistent with the population level statistics. Although these short-period rocky planets may not retain their initial memory of formation, they are ideal laboratories for testing star-planet interaction, including the XUV stellar flux-driven photoevaporation [ 80 , 43 , e.g.,] , tidal decay and circularization [ 57 , 88 , 92 , e.g.,] , and magnetic drag as the planet orbits through the stellar magnetic field [ 54 , 53 , e.g.,] . The latter two effects in particular can lead to the destruction of the planet as the planet reaches the Roche lobe limit, so we may expect their signature in terms of “edges” in the planet population. Recently, Parc et al. [82] suggested that there exists an upper limit to the mass of rocky planets at \sim 10 M_{\oplus} , irrespective of the mass of the host star over \sim 0.2–30 days (see their Figure 2; see also our Figure 1 ). Although this mass is close to the typically quoted critical core mass that triggers runaway gas accretion [ 66 , 115 , 91 , e.g.,] , runaway is likely not the cause of such a sharp edge to the planet mass distribution given how the critical core mass is expected to vary with the composition of the planet through opacity [ 41 , 93 , 58 , 89 , 106 , e.g.,] and we find plenty of sub-Neptunes (i.e., those that did not undergo runaway) with a mass exceeding \sim 10 M_{\oplus} [see 82 , their Figure 2] . Instead, in this paper, we consider the interplay between photoevaporation and tidal decay in creating a sharp cutoff to the maximum mass of short-period rocky planets. Yet another edge to the rocky planet population is the hint of a desert at \lesssim 1–3 days and \lesssim 1 R_{\oplus} in the radius-period space (see Figure 2 ; see also Dattilo et al. 19 , their Figure 6). This desert cannot be due to mass-loss as these planets are already rocky, and they are also not likely to be due to tidal decay, given the edge populations are smaller than Earth and therefore too small/light to drive sufficient tidal dissipation in the star to effect an orbital decay over \sim Gyr. Furthermore, this is unlikely to be a detection bias, as these small planets are detected at longer orbital periods. 1 1 1 However, one must consider that ultra-short-period planets can be hard to detect due to the finite cadence of the Kepler missions [ 104 ] . Instead, we note that approximately half of these ultra-short-period sub-Earths are around low-mass stars with mass below \sim 0.6 M_{\odot} which would be subject to a strong stellar magnetic field [ 112 , e.g.,] and the planet at short orbital periods would be subject to orbital decay by magnetic drag [ 54 , 53 , e.g.,] , similar to the orbital decay of Echo 1 satellite through the Earth ionosphere [ 22 ] and the electrodynamic interaction between Io and Jupiter [ 31 ] . This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we outline the underlying theory deriving analytically the expected shape of the edges of short-period rocky planets in the mass-period and radius-period space. We verify our expectation with detailed numerical modeling in Section III . Summary and discussion are provided in Section IV . II Theory We first begin by discussing the basic physics governing the star-planet interactions of close-in planets and present analytic arguments to derive the edges in mass-period and radius-period space. We then use our analytic boundaries to compare to the observed data, demonstrating that mass loss, tides, and magnetic interactions all likely play a role in sculpting the close-in rocky planet population. II.1 Maximum core mass II.1.1 Photoevaporative mass loss We first discuss why having 10 M_{\oplus} as the maximum core mass of rocky planets that is weakly variant with orbital period and stellar mass inside orbital periods of \sim 3–4 days is surprising in the context of photoevaporative mass loss alone. Following energy-limited approximation, \frac{GM_{p}\dot{M}_{\rm gas}}{R_{p}}=\frac{\eta}{4}L_{\rm XUV}\left(\frac{R_{p}}{a_{p}}\right)^{2} (1) where G is the gravitational constant, M_{p} is the mass of the planet (roughly the core mass), \dot{M}_{\rm gas} is the rate of envelope mass loss, R_{p} is the radius of the planet, \eta is the efficiency

Read the complete text