Critical String Theory in a D = 4 D=4 Robertson-Walker Background and the Large Scale Structure of Spacetime
Jaroslaw S. Jaracz · 2025
Read Critical String Theory in a D = 4 D=4 Robertson-Walker Background and the Large Scale Structure of Spacetime by Jaroslaw S. Jaracz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-17204.txt.
Introduction
Jaracz asks whether string theory can fit a four-dimensional cosmos with no extra hidden dimensions in a 2025 paper. He builds expanding-universe models of the Robertson-Walker type and checks a key consistency test. For one still model, all the test terms vanish at leading order, so the setup holds together.
Jaracz names that still case the anti-Einstein static universe. Its matter acts like a fluid with negative energy density. Such a fluid had been floated by hand as a guess for dark energy and dark matter. Here it shows up on its own from the math. Small shifts away from the still case give varied histories, one with a long squeeze, then growth that reads like a big bang.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jaroslaw S. Jaracz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-17204
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Critical String Theory in a D = 4 D=4 Robertson-Walker Background and the Large Scale Structure of Spacetime Jaroslaw S. Jaracz Abstract . We show that 4 4 -dimensional Robertson-Walker spacetimes can be constructed for which all of the beta functions vanish to leading order, yielding consistent string theory without the need for any extra dimensions. We find that, up to scaling of some constants, there is a unique static solution, which we refer to as an anti-Einstein static universe. This is an infinite universe with negative scalar curvature. The associated stress energy tensor can be interpreted as a perfect fluid with a negative energy density. Interestingly, a fluid with a negative energy density was proposed in [ 2 ] as an ad hoc hypothesis to serve as a possible explanation for dark energy and dark matter. Here, such a fluid spontaneously appears by trying to fit string theory into only 4 4 dimensions. Since our universe appears approximately static, we can look at perturbations away from the anti-Einstein static universe. This has to be done numerically and we only do it for a few choices of initial conditions (a full systematic numerical analysis of solutions will have to wait for the future). We find that these solutions are very sensitive to the initial conditions and yield a variety of behaviors. We hope that this behavior is rich enough to match cosmological observations by appropriately choosing the initial conditions (which needs to be systematically investigated with a search in the space of initial conditions). One of these solutions that we found is particularly interesting. It has a hubble parameter which is negative in the past (meaning a contracting universe), then a point at which the hubble parameter changes sign, so the universe starts expanding which could be identified with a big bang, after which the hubble parameter continues growing. Throughout all of this time, the acceleration is positive since the Hubble parameter is increasing. Finally, we comment that our result does not contradict [ 1 ] as it seems that the authors overlooked the possibility of a purely complex axion field which allows for the Robertson-Walker metrics to make a contribution c R W ≥ 4 c_{RW}\geq 4 to the central charge. Thus, we can interpret dark matter and dark energy as being parts of a mechanism needed to keep 4 4 -dimensional string theory consistent. 1. Introduction Before starting the article proper, we need to address the (rightfully so) highly skeptical readers. As we will see the conclusions of the article, follow from some straightforward calculations, and then looking at the perturbations of the only static solution to the resulting equations. Then naturally, if it is so simple, how come no one has done it before? We believe the answer is two fold. First, the idea of using a 4 -dimensional Robertson-Walker spacetime for a background in string theory is very natural once one has learned about the beta functions. But the second instinct is that if this worked, since string theory has been around for so long someone would have already done it, which serves to filter out a large number of people interested in the idea. Second, the next instinct would be to check the literature, where one of the main references is [ 1 ] where the authors plainly state that the contribution to the central charge made by the Robertson-Walker metrics is c_{RW}<4 meaning that D=4 will not work, and so the case is closed. This filters out the remaining people interested in the problem. However, we were not aware of [ 1 ] , so we simply tried to solve the beta functions for D=4 , found this to be quite easy, and then were confused why we had not heard of this before. This brought us to [ 1 ] , which claims that c_{RW}<4 . So why is this not a contradiction of our result? The key is found in the paragraph prior to equation (12) where the authors obtain the forumla \displaystyle K=\frac{1}{4}\beta^{2}e^{-2\phi_{0}} (1.1) for the static case where \beta is a constant related to the axion field. So here the authors concluded that K\geq 0 in which case indeed c_{RW}<4 . We had arrived at the same formula ( 3.2 ), since we have \phi=2\Phi comparing the notations of the two articles, but we instead concluded that \beta=i|\beta| needs to be purely complex, and K<0 . This allows us to make the contribution to the central charge be whatever we want. Why didn’t the authors consider a complex axion? The article was written before the discoveries of the dark energy and dark matter problems. At the time, everyone ”knew” all matter has nonnegative energy density, and thus the scalar curvature should be nonnegative. We suppose that by the time the dark energy and dark matter problems were discovered, the string community had moved onto compactifications, branes, and eventually Ads/CFT so no one thought to go back to 4 -dimensional string theory. Finally, we mention if one accepts the calculations in [ 1 ] , one can skip the majority of our paper and simply let the axion field be purely complex in that article. However, since we believe this is an important result, we include all of the calculations in painstaking detail. We believe the equations are right, as they also match the equations of [ 1 ] , but if there is a mistake, it should be easy to spot the mistake. Also, our calculations are done in a different way, as we treat \beta^{\Phi}=0 as a conserved quantity dependent on initial conditions, rather than an equation of motion. In both cases, one arrives at 3 equations, one of which is dependednt, but we think our way is better for the numerical analysis of solutions. Now that we have addressed this issue, we can move onto the article. String theory is one of the leading candidates for a theory of quantum gravity. It was originally proposed in the 1960s as a way of explaining the strong interaction. It was found that a massless spin- 2 particle naturally arises on its own in the theory, and eventually it was realized that this particle could be identified with the graviton. Thus, string theory is a quantum theory where gravity pops out on its own, without being forced into the theory. See [ 9 ] for a sketch of the early history. However, like all theories of quantum gravity, string theory has its problems. First, in the bosonic case, the dimension of the spacetime has to be 26 . By the addition of supersymmetry [ 6 ] , this can be lowered down to 10 or 11 depending on the type of string theory used. These extra dimensions have never been observed, so they are usually compactified, which leads to the study of Calabi-Yau manifolds, which then leads to the so-called landscape problem, where there are roughly 10^{500} different compactifications, and no way to choose which one is the correct one to describe our universe. See [ 10 ] and [ 8 ] for some perspectives. Moreover, supersymmetry has never been observed, even though evidence for it was expected to be