Artificial Intelligence Clones

Annie Liang ∗ · 2025

Read Artificial Intelligence Clones by Annie Liang ∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16996.txt.

Introduction

Annie Liang models AI clones in matchmaking in twenty twenty-five. Language models trained on personal data can mimic individual personalities. Such clones could transform search for partners, spouses, or employees. An AI can screen vastly more candidates than any person can meet.

Liang's framework weighs that expanded capacity against imperfect representation. A personality is a point in a multi-dimensional space, and a clone is a noisy copy of it. Two regimes are compared: meeting people in person, and matching through clones. A finite number of real meetings beats search over infinitely many clones, she shows. Representation error eats the search advantage surprisingly fast. Readers get a crisp theoretical caution for the coming market in digital doubles.

Catalog record

CREATORAnnie Liang ∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16996

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Artificial Intelligence Clones Thanks: The author thanks Keaton Ellis, Drew Fudenberg, Andrei Iakovlev, David Levine, Alexandru Lupsasca, Suproteem Sarkar, and Eduard Talamas for helpful comments, and National Science Foundation Grant SES-2145352 for financial support. Thanks: ∗ Northwestern University Annie Liang ∗ Abstract . Large language models, trained on personal data, are increasingly able to mimic individual personalities. These “AI clones” or “AI agents” have the potential to transform how people search for matches in contexts ranging from marriage to employment. This paper presents a theoretical framework to study the tradeoff between the substantially expanded search capacity of AI representations and their imperfect representation of humans. An individual’s personality is modeled as a point in k k -dimensional Euclidean space, and an individual’s AI representation is modeled as a noisy approximation of that personality. I compare two search regimes: Under in person search, each person randomly meets some number of individuals and matches to the most compatible among them; under AI-mediated search, individuals match to the person with the most compatible AI representation. I show that a finite number of in-person encounters yields a better expected match than search over infinite AI representations. Moreover, when personality is sufficiently high-dimensional, simply meeting two people in person is more effective than search on an AI platform, regardless of the size of its candidate pool. 1. Introduction Recent advances in large language models have brought us closer to a world in which individuals are represented by “AI clones” or “AI delegates” trained on their personal data ( Park et al., 2024 ) . This technology has the potential to transform how we search and match over human candidates, particularly in settings where direct engagement is costly. Labor markets are already moving in this direction: Roughly 90% of employers already use an automated system to screen candidates ( Amitabh and Ansari, 2025 ) , with four in ten employers reporting in a survey that they intend to use AI to “talk to” candidates ( Demopoulos, 2024 ) . These changes are facilitated by new AI platforms: Replicant enables job candidates to create digital representatives of themselves (see Figure 1 ), while Ribbon AI and Alex enable firms to automate their job recruiter ( Rocha, 2025 ; Temkin, 2025 ) . A similar shift is underway for dating markets. Bumble’s founder has described a future in which “your dating concierge could go and date for you with other dating concierges” ( Whittaker, 2024 ) , and platforms such as Volar Dating and Teaser AI have already adopted business models explicitly oriented around this approach ( Metz, 2024 ; Lin, 2024 ) . 1 1 1 This idea also appears in the Black Mirror episode “Hang the DJ,” in which the characters are revealed to be digital copies running simulations to gauge compatibility for their real-life counterparts. , 2 2 2 The rich medium of unstructured conversation allows AI representations to assess compatibility across many personality traits, in contrast to traditional online dating platforms which typically represent individuals by a limited set of attributes. Figure 1 . Replicant helps job candidates create AI clones to represent them in conversations with recruiters and potential employees. Source: Replicant website ( Replicant, 2024 ) . Across these domains, the appeal of AI-mediated matching is scale : AI representations enable search over far more candidates than a person could feasibly meet. But representations of complex human personalities based on limited training data are necessarily imperfect. Thus, there is a tradeoff between the platform’s improved scale of search and its reduced fidelity of representation. This paper develops a theoretical framework to study this tradeoff. Individuals are modeled as points in k -dimensional Euclidean space, and AI clones as noisy representations of those points. I ask when search conducted over AI proxies can outperform direct human evaluation. The answer turns out to crucially depend on the dimensionality of the search space. When sufficiently many attributes are relevant to match compatibility ( k is large), the value of AI-mediated search is extremely low: participating on an AI platform, no matter how large its candidate pool, is no better than meeting two people in person. The paper then turns to the broader social implications of use of AI representations for search. Specifically, I consider an extension in which the AI platform is able to develop more accurate AI representations for individuals in a “data-rich” group compared to a “data-poor” group. Despite the two groups being otherwise identical, Subject is matched to a data-rich individual with probability exceeding one-half. This probability moreover converges to 1 as the number of dimensions grows large. These results points to a potential new form of social stratification, where an individual’s outcomes depend not just on their intrinsic characteristics, but also on how effectively artificial intelligence can understand and represent those characteristics. Section 2 describes the model. Subject’s target match is normalized to the origin, with potential matches drawn uniformly at random from the unit ball. Subject prefers to be matched to an individual closer to their target, and Subject’s payoff is decreasing in the Euclidean distance between the target and the match. I compare two search regimes: Under in-person search, Subject randomly meets m individuals and matches to the closest among them. Under AI-mediated search, all individuals are represented by noisy perturbations of their true personality vector, henceforth their AI representations . Subject is matched to the individual whose AI representation is closest to the representation of Subject’s target, but Subject’s payoffs are determined by the true distance between this individual and the target. This model is inspired by AI representations but applies broadly to search problems with two defining features. First, match quality depends on many attributes that are difficult to measure. Second, human evaluators have an intuitive and holistic understanding of match quality that does not require explicit assessment of those underlying attributes. For example, a recruiter can know that a candidate interviewed well without having precisely assessed the candidate on component dimensions. In such environments, automated search is constrained by imperfect representations of the candidates and the target, while human search is constrained by the cost of direct engagement. The central tradeoff is between the errors of automated search and the capacity constraints of human evaluation. My results focus on a quantity I call the AI-equivalent sample size , which measures the value of the AI platform. The AI-equivalent sample size is the smallest m such that if Subject is permitted m draws in the in-person regime, then no search size advantage on the AI platform can compensate for the error introduced by the AI representations. That is, Subject would rather meet m individuals in person than search over an infinite number of individuals on the AI platform. Section 3 presents the main results. The first result, Proposition 1 , says that the AI-equivalent sample size is always finite. In other words, for any level of AI approximation error, there exists a finite number of in-person encounters sufficient to outperform any search size advantage offered by the AI platform. To show this, I demonstrate an intuitive but novel monotone-likelihood ratio property: smaller Euclidean distances between AI representations are associated with smaller Euclidean distances between the actual points.

Read the complete text