Estimating the Causal Effect of Redlining on Present-day Air Pollution

2025

Read Estimating the Causal Effect of Redlining on Present-day Air Pollution (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16958.txt.

Introduction

Xiaodan Zhou and co-authors reweigh whether redlining caused part of today's air pollution gaps. Their paper from 2025 starts from studies linking the 1930s housing bias maps to current fine particle and nitrogen dioxide levels. Plain links may hide bias, since records from before the policy are thin.

The team joins the old maps with 2010 pollution data and rebuilds the missing pre policy state from 1940 census proxies: joblessness, rent, and Black population share. A latent factor frame, in space and out, supports a causal read under broad assumptions. Redlined zones showed notably higher nitrogen dioxide today. Fine particle gaps were smaller. Los Angeles and Atlanta showed the strongest effects of the cities studied.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16958

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating the Causal Effect of Redlining on Present-day Air Pollution Abstract Recent studies have shown associations between redlining policies (1935-1974) and present-day fine particulate matter (PM 2.5 ) and nitrogen dioxide (NO 2 ) air pollution concentrations. In this paper, we reevaluate these associations using spatial causal inference. Redlining policies enacted in the 1930s, so there is very limited documentation of pre-treatment covariates. Consequently, traditional methods fails to sufficiently account for unmeasured confounders, potentially biasing causal interpretations. By integrating historical redlining data with 2010 PM 2.5 and NO 2 concentrations, our study aims to discern whether a causal link exists. Our study addresses challenges with a novel spatial and non-spatial latent factor framework, using the unemployment rate, house rent and percentage of Black population in 1940 U.S. Census as proxies to reconstruct pre-treatment latent socio-economic status. We establish identification of a causal effect under broad assumptions, and use Bayesian Markov Chain Monte Carlo to quantify uncertainty. Our analysis indicates that historically redlined neighborhoods are exposed to notably higher NO 2 concentration. In contrast, the disparities in PM 2.5 between these neighborhoods are less pronounced. Among the cities analyzed, Los Angeles, CA, and Atlanta, GA, demonstrate the most significant effects for both NO 2 and PM 2.5 . Key words: Air pollution exposure; Latent factor model; Proxy variable; Redlining policy; Spatial causal model. Xiaodan Zhou 1 1 1 North Carolina State University , Shu Yang 1 , Brian J Reich 1 1 Introduction 1.1 Redlining policy The redlining policy, initiated in 1935 by the Federal Home Loan Bank Board, mandated the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC) to create ‘residential security maps’. These maps classified residential regions with grades reflecting investment security: ‘A’ for Desirable, ‘B’ for Still Desirable, ‘C’ for Declining, and ‘D’ for Redlined. This grading system, operational until the 1974, directly influenced lending decisions. Regions graded ‘A’ were considered minimal risk by banks and mortgage lenders for loans and safe investments, while those labeled ‘D’ were deemed hazardous. Some studies have investigated the financial inequalities stemming from the redlining policy, with a emphasis on causal analysis and addressing potential confounders. Aaronson et al. 2021 employed a boundary-design approach to mitigate these confounders. Their analysis concentrated on areas adjacent to redlining boundaries (D), comparing ‘treated’ and ‘controlled’ boundaries using propensity score weighting. They discovered that regions assigned to be redlined experienced deteriorating housing market outcomes in the following decades. Similarly, Fishback et al. 2020 conducted a detailed boundary analysis, examining socio-economic characteristics near C-D grade borders. They observed a decline in home values and an increase in black population shares on the D-side compared to the C-side. The growing interest in environmental inequality has led to association-based studies concerning the redlining policy. Lane et al. 2022 revealed a consistent and nearly monotonic relationship between air pollutants and redlining grades, noting particularly an increase (over 50%) in NO 2 concentrations from A-graded to D-graded regions. The study also found that within each grade, disparities in air pollution exposure based on race and ethnicity continue to exist. This underscores the racially discriminatory impact of redlining on communities. Additionally, Jung et al. 2022 discovered that between 1998 and 2012, in New York City, schools in historically redlined regions saw smaller reductions in combustion-related air pollutants compared to others. However, the direct causal link between redlining policies and air pollution exposure remains uncertain, despite the apparent association. In this paper, we revisit the data and apply methods from spatial causal inference to determine if the link between redlining and air pollution persists after accounting for spatial dependence and confounding variables. We link this historical redlining data with current air pollution concentrations, and assesses the potential long-term environmental effects of redlining policies (1935-1974) on present-day air pollution concentrations. This analysis faces two key challenges. First, both redlining grades and air pollution concentrations exhibit spatial patterns, which must be carefully considered. Second, there is a risk of unmeasured confounding factors, particularly socio-economic status, that could influence both the historical redlining grades and current air pollution concentrations. In the following section, we outline our approach to addressing these challenges. 1.2 Spatial Causal Inference and Unmeasured Confounding Addressing unmeasured confounding has become a major topic in causal inference. A unmeasured confounder could introduce bias into the estimated effect and lead to incorrect conclusions about the true causal relationship. There are a wide range of methods to adjust for unmeasured confounding, such as instrumental variables ( Bound et al. 1995 ) , negative controls ( Lipsitch et al. 2010 ) , latent and proxy variables ( Kuroki and Pearl 2014 ) . These methods are not specifically designed for spatial data, but have been adopted to account for spatial unmeasured confounding in application studies, such as Davis et al. 2021 , Shao et al. 2022 , Giffin et al. 2021 , Haschka et al. 2020 , Tustin et al. 2017 , and Jerzak et al. 2023 . Moreover, causal methods applied to complex spatial data have been drawing attention. A spatial confounder is a unmeasured confounder that contains spatial structure. The ‘blessing’ of spatial confounder, compared with unstructured confounder, is that the spatial information may be used to capture some of the variability in the confounder, thus mitigating the bias ( Gilbert et al. 2021 ) . Dupont et al. 2022 developed method named ‘spatial+’, for cases when the treatment is spatially dependent but not fully determined by spatial location. A partial linear regression was used to adjust for spatial confounding. Guan et al. 2023 assumed a global-scale confounding (global relative to the treatment variable) and adjusted for confounding in the spatial domain by adding a spatially smoothed version of the treatment to the mean of the response variable. In spatial+ and the spectral adjustment, the treatment was assumed continuous. Other methods include region adjustment via spatial smoothing ( Schnell and Papadogeorgou 2020 ) , distance adjusted propensity score matching ( Papadogeorgou et al. 2019 ) , spatial propensity-score ( Davis et al. 2019 ) , which have been reviewed in Reich et al. 2021 . There are challenges in the redlining data that cannot be addressed by existing methods. Social-economic status is arguably the most important confounding variable. Though some relevant data can be found in the U.S. Census, it is dangerous to assume that we can use them to fully account for social-economic status, thus potentially biasing causal interpretations. Moreover, the time lapse of 75 years between the policy action and the pollution measurement further obscures causal links. In addition, the existence of spatial correlation in all of treatment, outcome, proxies, and potentially the latent confounder, complicates the problem. In response to these challenges, we expect a method that accommodates for latent confounding factors using proxy variables, and accommodates for unmeasured spatial confounders. We want such a method to sufficiently account for unmeasured confounders and draw consistent estimates. However, none of existing method would allow use the leverage the spatial structure and observed variable while taking use of the proxy variable for unobserved spatial confounding, while the use of proxy for non-spatial causal analysis has been prevalent such as Kong et al. 2019 , Yang et al. 2020 , and Miao et al. 2018 . This paper

Read the complete text