The Third Moment of AI Ethics: Developing Relatable and Contextualized Tools

Sarah Hladikova, Yuling Wang, Andreia Martinho · 2025

Read The Third Moment of AI Ethics: Developing Relatable and Contextualized Tools by Sarah Hladikova, Yuling Wang, Andreia Martinho (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16954.txt.

Introduction

Sarah Hladikova, Yuling Wang, and Andreia Martinho build a practical AI ethics tool in this 2025 paper. AI ethics writing has grown fast, yet practitioners rarely use its principles on the job. Abstract words, poor access, and thin how-to guidance block uptake.

Working with industry users, the team designed an open-source tool that turns norms into concrete steps. Its format matches how software teams already build products. The tool stays grounded in set ethical frameworks while speaking plainly. A proof of concept study in the United States self-driving industry tested the approach. Results support relatable, context-fit tools as the next phase of AI ethics work.

Catalog record

CREATORSarah Hladikova, Yuling Wang, Andreia Martinho
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16954

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Third Moment of AI Ethics: Developing Relatable and Contextualized Tools Sarah Hladikova, Yuling Wang, Andreia Martinho Abstract Artificial intelligence (AI) ethics has gained significant momentum, evidenced by the growing body of published literature, policy guidelines, and public discourse. However, the practical implementation and adoption of AI ethics principles among practitioners has not kept pace with this theoretical development. Common barriers to adoption include overly abstract language, poor accessibility, and insufficient practical guidance for implementation. Through participatory design with industry practitioners, we developed an open-source tool that bridges this gap. Our tool is firmly grounded in normative ethical frameworks while offering concrete, actionable guidance in an intuitive format that aligns with established software development workflows. We validated this approach through a proof of concept study in the United States autonomous driving industry. 1 Introduction The AI Ethics community responded to the call for normative guidance of AI with a multitude of soft governance mechanisms, such as principles, frameworks, and guidelines [ 32 , 17 , 33 ] . These documents were critical for the development of a shared normative foundation about AI, revolving around core principles modeled after the classic Medical Ethics Principles. Meta-analyses of AI ethics guidelines show that there is a consensus that AI technologies should be beneficial to people and the environment ( beneficence ); robust and secure ( non-maleficence ); respectful of human values ( autonomy ); fair ( justice ); and explainable and accountable ( explainability ) [ 21 , 11 , 38 , 31 , 28 , 29 ] . The early efforts in developing AI ethics guidelines had limited effect on software development practice [ 43 ] . Hence, the AI Ethics community focused on operationalizing these principles and guidelines [ 36 , 2 , 32 , 31 , 22 , 3 , 42 , 39 , 45 , 14 , 23 , 9 , 41 ] . The Morley Typology, a staple in this so-called from what to how moment of AI Ethics, is a comprehensive framework that matches available methods and tools to the core AI Ethics principles ( Beneficence, Non-Maleficence, Justice, Autonomy, and Explainability ), and to stages in the algorithm development pipeline (Business Development; Design; Training and Test; Prototyping; Testing; Development; Monitoring ) [ 31 ] . However, it seems that these principles and tools have yet to be integrated into technology R&D practices [ 17 ] . Several reports indicate their minimal impact on professional practices [ 43 , 34 , 23 , 44 , 33 ] . One factor contributing to this challenge is that these normative mechanisms are presented as external entities with respect to particular domains of science and technology, thus lacking relatability [ 32 ] . We consider that, as AI continues to become more embedded in different aspects of society, the AI Ethics community should focus on improving the relatability and context specificity of the normative tools. We are aligned with scholars who have called for AI Ethics to develop tools that go beyond general guidelines for professional and ethical practice, reflect normative diversity, do not require a deep background in philosophy, and ensure all stakeholders are engaged and involved in design decisions [ 32 ] . In this research, we first reflect on the contemporary challenges of AI Ethics and subsequently describe an AI Ethics tool that we developed in what we propose to be the third moment of AI ethics. The tool is grounded in the current normative literature of AI Ethics, yet it is also practical. We included a proof of concept study in the Autonomous Driving industry and requested input from practitioners working in autonomous driving startups in the United States. 2 The Challenges of AI Ethics 2.1 AI Ethics as a Branch of Applied Ethics Ethics explores matters of right and wrong, reflecting the moral spectrum of a particular concept, policy, or technology [ 28 ] . The normative debates welcome disagreement, speculation, and abstraction, thus allowing both diversity of thought and serious ethical consideration [ 29 , 28 ] . These debates slowly build a robust, rich, and diverse normative foundation, which eventually serves as the basis for governance and regulatory mechanisms. AI Ethics explores the ethical implications of AI technologies. It scrutinizes the moral issues arising from the design, development, deployment, and use of AI systems. Like other branches of Applied Ethics, such as Medical Ethics, the normative principles and tools may be used to reflect on complex moral dilemmas, but they also aim to guide the practice (i.e. technology development and innovation). The community working in this space has focused mainly on translating and incorporating normative elements through the design pipeline. These issues are deeply embedded in the larger societal context, namely in domains such as Transportation [ 26 ] , Healthcare [ 27 ] , or Justice [ 25 ] . The socio-technical nature of AI prompts ethicists to examine the role of software developers and other practitioners in the outcomes of the technology. 2.2 The Challenges of AI Ethics in the current AI Paradigm AI Ethics faces unique challenges related to the urgency of normative guidance , multi-purpose nature of AI , and multitude of stakeholders [ 28 ] . The recent state of affairs in AI is characterized by the fast development and deployment of these technologies, as well as an urgent need for practical and operational normative guidance, resulting in an AI Ethics Boom , [ 8 ] where many academic, government, and industry organizations started publishing normative guidance to AI. These efforts were predominantly concerned with the principles that ought to guide the modus operandi of practitioners, however, as mentioned earlier, there was little to none guidance on the implementation of such principles into practice [ 8 ] . Another challenge for AI Ethics is related to the fact that modern AI is a multi-purpose technology. AI is currently applied to several societal domains, such as Transportation, Healthcare, or Justice [ 28 ] . AI Ethics needs to consider how risks, conflicting rights and interests, and social preferences vary in different contexts [ 30 ] . Just as in other Applied Ethics domains, namely Medical Ethics or Business Ethics, there are many distinct issues that require rigorous examination and scrutiny. As a result of the multi-purpose nature of AI, there are many stakeholders involved in the development of various AI-powered technologies. Organizations such as Google, Amazon, Facebook, or OpenAI, have shown a strong interest in AI Ethics and have developed several guidelines [ 15 , 1 ] . Traditionally, the Ethics community is hesitant about industry-led initiatives regarding Ethics and often dismisses these initiatives as attempts to shape the normative conversations to their own interests [ 31 , 21 ] . However, it may also be argued that these organizations produce guidelines as a response to the Ethics communities (as well as, perhaps, concerns and criticism in popular culture and media). The Ethics work is rarely ready to use as it is often abstract, speculative, and intricate. A challenge for the AI Ethics researchers is to operationalize their work and communicate effectively with other communities in the AI space [ 28 ] . Past experience with other applied fields of

Read the complete text