Emission impossible: Balancing Environmental Concerns and Inflation

René A1̈​\mbox{\rmI}d, Maria Arduca, Sara Biagini, Luca Taschini · 2025

Read Emission impossible: Balancing Environmental Concerns and Inflation by René A1̈​\mbox{\rmI}d, Maria Arduca, Sara Biagini, Luca Taschini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16953.txt.

Introduction

Carbon pricing fights emissions, but it can also push up prices across the economy. René Aïd and three co-authors build a framework to weigh that tension in this 2025 paper. Firms in their model can cut emissions three ways: make less, clean up their process, or buy permits, and each choice feeds into the prices households pay.

First the authors solve how a market settles under any schedule of permit handouts a regulator might choose. Then they let the regulator balance two goals, emissions and inflation, with penalties for missing either. Tuning those penalties shows how priorities bend the outcome. Across sensible settings, they find, missing the emissions goal costs more than the savings from slightly lower inflation, so cuts should stay the top aim.

Catalog record

CREATORRené A1̈​\mbox{\rmI}d, Maria Arduca, Sara Biagini, Luca Taschini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16953

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Emission impossible: Balancing Environmental Concerns and Inflation Thanks: We thank Marc Baudry, Giorgia Callegaro, Estelle Cantillon, Anna Creti, Giorgio Ferrari, Fausto Gozzi Frank Riedel, Karin Mayr-Dorn, Aurelie Slechten and conference and seminar participates at the AMaMeF, FSR Climate Annual Conference, Spring Colloquium on Probability and Finance, Economics of Climate Change Seminar. The authors’ email addresses are [email protected] , [email protected] , [email protected] and [email protected] . René A1̈​\mbox{\rmI}d, Maria Arduca, Sara Biagini, Luca Taschini Abstract We provide a theoretical framework to examine how carbon pricing policies influence inflation and to estimate the policy-driven impact on goods prices from achieving net-zero emissions. Firms control emissions by adjusting production, abating, or purchasing permits, and these strategies determine emissions reductions that affect the consumer price index. We first examine an emissions-regulated economy, solving the market equilibrium under any dynamic allocation of allowances set by the regulator. Next, we analyze a regulator balancing emission reduction and inflation targets, identifying the optimal allocation when accounting for both environmental and inflationary concerns. By adjusting penalties for deviations from these targets, we demonstrate how regulatory priorities shape equilibrium outcomes. Under reasonable model parameterisation, even when considerable emphasis is placed on maintaining inflation at acceptable levels or grant lower priority to emissions reduction targets, the costs associated with emission deviations still exceed any savings from marginally lower inflation. Emission reduction goals should remain the primary focus for policymakers. Keywords : Allowance dynamic allocation; Cap-and-trade; Carbon pricing; Inflation; stochastic dynamic optimization; Market equilibrium. JEL subject classifications: C61, C62, H23, L51, Q43, Q52, Q54, Q58. Acknowledgements: We would like to thank the Finance for Energy Markets Research Initiative, the Chair EDF–Credit Agricole CIB Finance and Sustainable Development: Quantitative Approach, the French ANR PEPR Math-Vives project MIRTE ANR-23-EXMA-0011, and the LUISS visiting program for their financial support. 1 Introduction Carbon pricing has emerged as a key policy instrument in the global effort to mitigate climate change, with a growing number of jurisdictions adopting carbon taxes or cap-and-trade systems to curb greenhouse gas emissions ( World Bank Group (2024) ). These policies, which internalize the environmental cost of carbon-intensive activities, have been shown to be effective in reducing emissions ( Martin et al. (2016) , Dechezleprêtre et al. (2023) , among others). However, this effectiveness does not come without economic costs. By altering relative prices, carbon pricing raises the cost of emission-intensive goods, potentially affecting the overall price level. The empirical literature on the inflationary impact of carbon pricing offers mixed evidence. Some studies find that the impact on inflation has been relatively weak ( Metcalf (2019) ; Metcalf and Stock (2023b) ; Konradt and di Mauro (2023) ) while others indicate more substantial inflationary effects ( Känzig (2023) ). Criticism of carbon pricing and promises to “axe the tax” have surfaced in political debates, which may in turn prompt policymakers to slow down, weaken, or reconsider the scope of climate policies. This growing political and public scrutiny of carbon pricing has sparked discussions about the opportunity to balance inflation concerns with environmental targets to ensure that these policies remain both effective and publicly acceptable. In this paper, we develop a theoretical framework to explore how policymakers can trade off less ambitious carbon emission reduction targets for lower inflationary pressures arising from carbon pricing. We consider a regulatory authority that determines the optimal allocation of emission allowances by explicitly balancing its tolerance for inflationary pressure with the need to meet stringent emission reduction goals. Pressing too hard on emissions reductions risks driving up inflation, whereas being overly cautious on inflation may impede progress in decarbonizing the economy. We derive the optimal allowance allocation by factoring in both environmental and inflationary concerns. By adjusting penalties for deviations from these targets, we demonstrate how regulatory priorities shape equilibrium outcomes. Whether inflation concerns should influence policy as a means to secure public acceptance is ultimately an empirical question. Calibrating the model to data, our results indicate that emissions reduction goals should remain the primary focus. Under reasonable parameterization, even when policymakers devote considerable effort to maintaining inflation at acceptable levels or assign lower priority to emissions reduction targets, the costs tied to emission deviations still outweigh any benefits from marginally lower inflation. We contribute to the debate on the effects of carbon pricing on inflation by presenting a theoretical framework to study how carbon pricing policies influence inflation and by applying this model to calculate the theoretical policy-driven impact on goods prices resulting from achieving net-zero emissions. Our analysis considers an economy where emissions are limited by a regulatory authority through a cap-and-trade system. Firms can employ three strategies to comply with the policy: adjusting production levels, undertaking costly pollution abatement, or purchasing permits. These strategies determine the total amount of controlled emissions reductions, which, in turn, influence changes in the consumer price index. We begin by solving the compliance problem, deriving the firms’ optimal compliance strategies. Next, we solve for the market equilibrium, obtaining the equilibrium permit price given a specific emissions cap and corresponding allocation program. Essentially, we model the primary transmission channel for policy-driven inflation: changes in production. These production adjustments are influenced by firms’ strategic decisions between abatement and trading, which, in turn, depend on the permit price set in the cap-and-trade market. The permit price ultimately reflects the availability of permits, determined by the allocation program established by the regulator. We then consider an alternative policy approach where the regulator decides the allocation program not only to meet emission reduction targets but also to account for policy-driven inflationary pressures. This introduces a deliberate trade-off in the regulatory approach, balancing environmental objectives with inflationary pressure. To formalize this trade-off, we explicitly model it within the regulator’s objective function. The regulator aims to minimize the overall compliance costs incurred by firms, while simultaneously managing deviations from both a pre-set emission reduction target and an acceptable inflation target. We demonstrate how the equilibrium permit price is inherently tied to this trade-off and depends on the regulator’s priorities. If the regulator places greater emphasis on achieving stringent emission reduction targets, the allocation program will be designed to impose a tighter cap, leading to higher permit prices. Conversely, if the regulator is more focused on minimizing inflationary impacts, the allocation program may allow for more permits, thereby reducing the upward pressure on permit prices and the resulting inflation. We apply the theoretical model to empirical data, using an illustrative example as a unifying thread throughout the paper. First, we illustrate how the allocation program affects controlled emissions, which are determined by firms’ optimal decisions to abate emissions, adjust production, or trade permits. These decisions are directly influenced by the stringency of the allocation program and, in turn, determine the equilibrium permit price. Second, we continue the example to calculate the theoretical inflationary effects of achieving net-zero emissions in Europe by 2050, assuming no additional consideration of inflationary impacts. This step provides a baseline for understanding the potential price-level implications of ambitious carbon reduction targets. Third, we evaluate the trade-off between emissions reduction and inflationary impacts, focusing on the regulator’s decision-making process. By varying the penalization parameters associated with deviations from emission reduction and inflation targets, we illustrate how the regulator balances these competing objectives. This analysis emphasizes

Read the complete text